Re: question
Sgian Dubh
>"will the auto stuff leave anything in the mahogany pores that will be light color and detract?"
In my experience the answer is yes, whether you use automotive burnishing pastes or pumice and rottenstone. The exception to that is burnishing over a fully filled grain if you are dealing with either an open grained wood like oak, or semi-open pored wood like mahogany or walnut.
If you want to avoid that white stuff in the grain look you might want to consider a polish where you can get the sheen you want using other means, eg, a 10%, 30% or 50% sheen lacquer applied with a spray gun; or rub down shellac using, for example, wet and dry papers, wire wool or nylon abrasive pads plus a lubricant, eg, white spirits (aka mineral spirits).
The fly in the ointment bit with this abrasives method when done on open pored woods is that the abrasive doesn't always get into the bottom of the pores leaving shiny bits grinning up between the dulled bits. Slainte.