Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Finishing help

Posts

Finishing help

#1

Finishing help

herkdriver234

>I am in the process of refinishing a 1920-1930 time frame quarter sawn oak center post kitchen table and chairs. The origional finish I'm pretty shure was shellac. I want a durable finish but I do not want to use poly type finishes. Since we will be using this table I don't think going back with shellac is a good idea. I am leaning toward varnish. I need to know if this is a good idea and what would be the best varnish product to use. I would also like to know if I can spray the varnish. I have both high pressure and HVLP systems.

What do you guys think?

Re: Finishing help

#2

Re: Finishing help

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You certainly can spray varnish. I do it all the time. You may need to thin it a bit. But why you eschew a urethane varnish for a table is a puzzle to me. For a table you want durability. I finished a table about 30 years ago with urethane and we and the two kids ate on it every day and it still looks good. After spraying it I rubbed it out to a nice subdued sheen. Done properly one can't tell lacquer from shellac or varnish.

You are going to have to find a warm place to cure the varnish if you want it dust free quickly.

An alternative is to spray a conversion varnish. It will go dust free in a minute and these finishes are durable.

Re: Finishing help

#3

Re: Finishing help

herkdriver234

>Thanks for the responce Bill.

The reason I am not a fan of urthane is that I don't really want to use a modern finish with a period piece plus using varnish will be easier to repair. What is conversion varnish?

Keith

Re: Finishing help

#4

Re: Finishing help

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>If it WAS shellac, recovering it would be pretty easy. Just level it out, and pad on some more. No stripping, no incompatibility, no crazing. And testing is as easy as some denatured alcohol in an inconspicuous place. Top coating with furniture wax like Johnson's or Briwax or similar should give you what you want.

But then, I'm a shellac junkie, with no place really to spray, once the weather turns from summer-like to the rest of the year's offering. I pad almost everything, including varnishes.

Re: Finishing help

#5

Re: Finishing help

Fred Davis

>It is likely that it is a Shellac finish , testing as Glenn says on a unseen area will tell you. Shellac is a lovely finish and can be applied many diferent ways , though I would spray, any scratches are easily repaired.

FredD

Re: Finishing help

#6

todays's "varnish" is a modern finish

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The varnish you buy today is but remotely related to a "period" varnish. The only authentic "period" finish you will be able to readily purchase is shellac or oil. The only significant difference between "varnish" and "urethane varnish" is that maybe the urethane will be harder and more durable. But then modern urethane varnish is not what it used to be either, so the durability and hardness differs greatly among manufacturers. I don't see any difference in repairability. After 15 years I sanded urethane varnished floors and put on another coat. What could be easier? If the finish is durable you won't have to repair it.

If it helps you conscience any, a magnificent pie crust table displayed at the August SAPFM conference was finished with urethane varnish because, to quote its maker, "this is a table we use a lot and I wanted the finish to be durable". I didn't hear anyone say that they could tell a difference in appearance from a shellaced table.

If I was doing a dining table there is no doubt that I would be putting some sort of urethane on its top.

Conversion varnish is some sort of modern product that applies like lacquer but is more durable. Its distinguishing feature is that it crosslinks after application yielding a more durable finish than lacquer. Any cabinet supply place supplying finishes to the trade will sell some version of it. It goes on like lacquer. I have used tens of gallons of it and I like it for where durability is needed.

Re: Finishing help

#7

Re: Finishing help

Howard Acheson

>Let me suggest that you consider a varnish like Waterlox Original Gloss or Satin or Behlen's Rockhard. Both are phenolic resin varnishes and both are harder and more durable than big box polyurethane varnishes. Poly varnishes are actually formulated to be somewhat softer than non-poly varnish so they are slightly more scratch resistant. Both the Waterlox and the Behlens are as tough and durable as a poly. Both will also give you a more clear finish than big box poly varnish.

BTW, what have you done to prepare the surface for your new finish? Surface preparation is the most important aspect of refinishing.

Re: Finishing help

#8

traditional varnish

Michael Dresdner

>As Bill pointed out, most modern varnishes are not the same as traditional ones. They are made by reacting oils into either alkyd or urethane resins, or both. Traditional varnishes were made by cooking oils with natural resins. I said most because you can still find two types of traditional varnishes on the market; true spar varnish and violin varnish, both of which are, at least by some makers, still formulated the old way. However, I agree completely with Bill in that if it is appearance you care about, you won't be able to tell a properly applied modern varnish from an old one, and you will spend less and get more durability to boot.