Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

Posts

? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#1

? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

Mike Hamilton

>My BIL lost a cherry tree to a wind storm not too long ago and offered it to me. There was some rot in the butt and the tree broke in heavy winds. He sawed me a log well above the break - about 9.5 feet long by 15 inches in diameter. It looks like there is another 5 foot section to be had below the first branch. Only one obvious cats-eye in the longer piece and none in the shorter. He assumed I'd want to cut this into turning stock - I'm thinking it makes sense to mill this. I'm assuming I can get this out of the woods and take it to the sawyer (to save money).

I'm looking for more experienced thoughts on whether I'm kidding myself on this. I'm going to break out the Stihl and make bowl stock out of the upper lengths and crotches, so this will be my fall-back option for the log.

Thanks for your thoughts,

Mike


gift log

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#2

thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In general a tree of that size certainly will yield some useful lumber. Some will be clear, some will have sap, some will have a knot or two and that near the center will be useless. I am sure a mill would buy the 9' log if it was delivered to them and they would not likely buy the 5' log.

A considerable effort will be expended before usable lumber is at hand. Questions to ask are whether you need the lumber, can you get the log to a mill, and will they saw it. Do you have time you want to spend on this effort. Do you have a place to air dry the lumber and a place to kiln dry it or the equivalent? What are the alternatives? Can you buy already sawed and graded lumber from the mill? Would it be useful split into turning blanks or whatever? You won't make minimum wage on this project, but it can be a fun experience.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#3

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers

John K Jordan

>Mike,

You might mention where you live and/or call Woodmizer to check for sawmills and private saw owners in your area. Someone might be willing to saw for you very inexpensively or for free if you can haul the logs to them. The larger sawmills probably won't be bothered.

I have a wood mizer and have made plenty of wonderful boards from such logs, as well as cut a number of logs for others on shares. One cherry from a neighbor gave me three straight 10' logs, about 18" at the largest end. It's hard to saw a log less than 4' long since that is the distance between the cross supports, but a small diameter 5' log like that would be very quick and easy to saw. Even when I am making bowl blanks, it's easier to remove the pith and cut slabs on the sawmill then chop the slabs into smaller pieces.

JKJ

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#4

Re: Thoughts from my experience

Joe in Tallahassee FLA

>I have had quite a few logs milled over the years to support my WW habit, including quite a few cherry trees. Here's a few thoughts:

From the picture you supplied the log looks a little bowed. If it is, that will affect the amount and quality of your boards.

I have found Cherry, at least what I've gotten in N. Florida, to have a high degree of drying defects. In particular is a tendancy for meandering splits to happen along most of the length of many boards. The meander from side to side keeps you from being able to rip out a decent long board next to the split. The main point is, you can expect a significant loss due to drying defects.

Bugs, powder post beetles and their cousins, may need to be dealt with. We sure have to here. The best way is to cook the critters during a kiln drying schedule. If you are limited to air drying your options are limited.

But regardless, it is still a pleasure to get some decent wood starting with a chainsaw. Sawing a log is like opening a present, you don't know what you got until the wrapper comes off. Sometimes you get some very nice surprises.

Good Luck.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#5

cherry drying defects

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Cherry is one of the easiest species to dry. However, parts of the boards near the center of the log typically split. A good rule of thumb is that the center 3-4" will be useless. It is common practice when sawing cherry to box the heat out and send it off for pallet lumber. However on a log that size this limitation is not a worrisome loss. Also, boards with sap on one side and heart on the other tend to cup severely. This problem can be mitigated by keeping the sapwood in one board when sawing.

The problems Joe has seen are not typical for cherry cut in its normal range unless areas near the tree center are included in boards. Here in E. TN we are too far south for good cherry unless it is cut at high elevation so I would imagine N. FL is even less favorable.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#6

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I've had a number of similar size cherry trees milled via woodmizer, gotten good yield. I'd absolutely try to mill those two; I'd also mill the crotch, it looks to be a good size and there should be some nice figure there. You probably know this already, but the best figure is usually gotten by milling so that the pieces look like the letter "Y".

Regarding the crook, if you mill so that you get boards that are a bit curved (crook), you can sometimes incorporate the curve into natural edge pieces that have a beauty all their own, Nakashima-style.

Ken

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#7

Re: Thanks all, another ?

Mike Hamilton

>Thanks for the comments and thoughts.

I've contacted WoodMizer and gotten a list of sawyers local to the log. If the price is reasonable, I'll have it milled. But I think that crotch will be worked for platters. Next to decide how to mill it. I'm thinking either 6 or 8 quarter stock sawn through and through. Any better ideas? I'm all ears.

Mike

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#8

Re: Thanks all, another ?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Those sizes sound right to me. More 8/4, if reasonable. Table legs are alway popular, and needn't be 8' long...

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#9

Re: Back from the sawyer's *LINK*

Mike Hamilton

>I decided to have the BIL's gift logs sawn rather than chop it all for turning stock. The wood was an 80 mile trip from me, so I made two trips.

On the first, we (also BIL John and his friend Jerry) proved to ourselves we could get the logs out intact. The tree was on the least accessible spot on the property. We also cut and got out turning stock from above and below the logs.

Second trip was to the sawyer. End result was 135 bdft of 8/4 cherry for a under $100 - including my gas and lunch for three. I'm a pretty happy guy today.

Pics at the link below, cursor over the thumbnails to see the full captions without expanding them all.

Regards,

Mike

(anybody need a sawyer in northwest Indiana - I got a guy for you)


Processing the gift wood

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#10

enjoyed the story

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Glad it worked out and you had a good time. In a stack that narrow it will dry quickly. Cherry gives up its water more easily than many of the hardwoods we use.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#11

A few things I would do

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I have not had much luck leaving the bark on. it seems to attract bugs down here.

Also, on thicker cherry, I have just starting sawing the sapwood off. It looses it moisture very fast, then checks within just a few days. Maybe it won't since we are heading into the cool season.

I would not leave those sticks that long. The rain falling on them will carry back into the stack, and cause stain.

I would elevate the roof on the lower end. A slight tilt or wind will send all of its water right down into the stack.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#12

Re: thanks for your thoughts

Mike Hamilton

>

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#13

how that log would have been sawed for grade lumbe

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't mean to imply that I have any quibble how you had the log sawed for your purposes. I thought some might want to contrast sawing at a mill producing lumber to sell.

After the first slab was removed the log would have been turned 180 degrees to put this smooth face securely on the frame. A slab would have been removed from the other side. Likely a 4/4 board would have been removed next so that less bark would need to be edged off this more curved part of the trunk. Additional boards, 8/4 or whatever, would be removed from this face until a defect was hit that would downgrade the board to #1 common or less. The log would then be turned back 180 degrees and this process repeated. Then the log would be turned 90 degrees and a slab removed, etc. In the end each face of the log would have the high grade lumber sawed off it until a cant was left with the defects concentrated in it. This cant would then be sawed through without additional turning.

What is different. More high grade lumber would be produced. The lumber would on average be more narrow and it would contain no rift or quartered boards. The boards cut from the center would be very low grade and could be worthless for furniture purposes.

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#14

Nice stash Mike..........

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>........did the Aleve help ? Im betting so, its certainly needed after every time I do a woodmizer session.

A small suggestion, kinda surprised no one else here mentioned it, but you may want to add some additional sticker support on both ends of the stack w/ additional weight so the ends dont bow or lift up. I had a 4x6 small cant bow 4" to 6" or so that was un supported....just a thought....may or may not be needed since cherry is pretty forgiving.

Nice job Mike....well done ....and very satisfying wasnt it ?

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#15

Re: Nice stash Mike..........

Mike Hamilton

>Satisfying indeed, Scott. When I was done at the sawyer, I asked him "so if I needed this lumber from you and didn't already have my own log, what would you have charged me?" His answer was $1.75 / bdft. Not much of an hourly rate for our labors, but I learned a lot and had a very enjoyable time.

Regards,

Mike

Re: ? for the sawyers and wood mongers *LINK*

#16

Re: how that log would have been sawed for grade l

Mike Hamilton

>Thanks for the comparison Bill. The sawyer was willing to saw however I wanted and verified several times that I would be happy with sawing through and through - now I understand why.

Regards,

Mike