Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Hardwood floors - Layout

Posts

Hardwood floors - Layout

#1

Hardwood floors - Layout

John T

>Ok, I'm back with another in my series of hardwood floor questions...

One of the rooms I want to do is our living room, and its an odd shape

The room is sunken, and is like a square, with one corner looped off, so it looks like a lopsided pentagon. The short sides (thin lines in the picture) are actually entryways (one leads to the main entry foyer, the other to the dining room, which will also be done in hardwood).

the angled wall is actually a half-height wall, and looks into the kitchen. We currently have our TV against this wall, so it's sort of the center of attention, with the furniture arranged against the long walls(Thick lines in the diagram) I hope this is making sense....

My question is:

Which way should I arrange the flooring?

My idea is to run diagonally (i.e. paralllel to the angled wall).

Pros or cons?

If it matters, I'm looking at 3 inch red oak flooring.

Thanks in advance for any replies.

-John-


img

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#2

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

Andy Halterman: 30s officially over

>Perpendicular to the floor joists. That is the ONLY layout you need to be concerned with.

Andy Halterman

Not able to see Russia from my house in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#3

Yup.....No arguement in that Andy

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#4

A.J. Hamler

That's generally true...

A.J. Hamler

>That's generally true. If hardwood flooring planks are installed perpendicular to joists (which are assumably at 16" apart), those planks are supported at 16" intervals, which is the best and optimal configuration. Lay those same planks parallel to the joists, and they're not supported by the joists at all, only by the subfloor.

But as long as hardwood flooring is supported in such a way that each plank has joist support at several points along its length, you're pretty much OK. If John's joists run parallel, say, to the right-hand wall in the sketch and he puts the hardwood planks in line with the angled corner on the upper left, he'll get all the support he needs. (Assuming, of course, that the subfloor is sufficiently thick.) It looks like the angle of that angled wall is about 45 degrees -- just guessing. If that's the case, then, and assuming that his joists are on 16" centers, then each plank will be supported at about 22-1/2 inches. With a good subfloor, strong flooring such as oak will be just fine in such a configuration. I wouldn't want to lay hardwood flooring planks at any angle greater than 45 degrees to the joists, however.

However, if John's intended plank direction is parallel to the joists and/or the planks are not supported at multiple points along their length, he can eventually expect some sag no matter what kind of subfloor he has.

A.J.

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#5

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Just a thought - I assume you want to make the flooring parallel to the angled wall since that's a focal point. An option would be to make the first few courses along the angled wall parallel to it, then make the rest perpendicular to the joists. Those would run into the angled-wall-parallel courses at the 45-ish angle, which would mean a bit of work getting them just right. You'd have to cut each end and then use a router to recut the tongue or groove. Also, if the flooring is prefinished, that usually has a little chamfer at the end, which you'd lose on the perpendicular-to-the-joists boards. However, it's a neat look. I did a room which had a sort of similar situation, in that I felt I needed to run a few courses the "wrong" way at a focal point. Then the rest of the boards come in perpendicular to those few courses.

If you are curious (and if those smarter about flooring do not chime in to say that my floor will fall apart over the years) I can post a pic.

Ken

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#6

Re: That's generally true...

Fred Davis

>Then there is west coast stick framing ..

Far more floors in single storey's and first floors in two storey out there built in the sixties , seventies and right up to now have post and beam girder support which is typically 4x6 girders over 4x4 posts every 48 " O.C. and subfloored with 4'x8' x 1 1/8th" plywood panels.

Since they also in ,most cases run the hardwood flooring parellel with the long dimension in the room, then you can see how bonding the flooring to the subfloor with PL 400 adhesive gives you a membrane

1 and 7/8ths " thick that is for all practical purposes the same as if it were solid wood.

This prevents the sag one would expect in a support system 48" O.C.As far as I and structural engineers are concerned, this also applies to any subfloor installation and or hardwood finish floor that I had anything to do with.

FredD

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#7

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

Fred Davis

>John,

since I did not look at your schetch before I answered in general on subfloor support and installation of hardwood flooring , I don't know what kind of subfloor you have , but if it is in fairly good condition and doesn't have any obvious failure spots in it you can run the flooring any direction you wish , assuming you will be bonding it to the subfloor.

That being said , if you run it the way you described , parallel to the half wall then you will have angle cuts on both ends of every run of flooring which would automatically be the most wasteful of the material.

Running parallel to the long wall if it does not interfere with runs in the other rooms(ideally each room would run the same direction) would be the least wasteful of material and far faster labor wise.

Remember I am saying this only on the assumption you will be bonding the flooring with adhesive in addition to just enough blind nailing with nails or staples to hole the boards in place untill the glue dries.

FredD

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#8

Re: That's generally true...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>But it can make for some bouncy floors, in some cases, when the ground moves. And it sometimes does, here.

We had such a floor in the front room, and the entertainment center would bounce when the cat ran through. When the same cat also soiled the corner of the carpet really badly, I ripped everything out to those 4x6 joists, restructured, laid new subfloor and new carpets. With modern adhesives, and doubling the 2x6s under the subfloor, it doesn't move or squeak at all now.

But it was a long two week project that summer.

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#9

Re: That's generally true...

Fred Davis

>Bouncy????, you ever walk on a post tensioned floor, popular in the San Ramon Valley Bishop Business park, floor is supported by high tensioned cables at about 60,00 pounds per inch, trampoline city.

I noticed you used glue on the second time around, bounce could very well have been a bad builer who exceeded the max between girder posts of seven feet. The max was bad enough , most quality builders use a much closer spacing , more on the order of four or five feet.

Am just guessing but I bet the subfloor was not bonded to the girders with glue either, if it was , you would have had a hell of a time pulling it up.

FredD

Re: Hardwood floors - Layout

#10

Re: Not a bad builder, just low budget

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>These were at one time 'value homes'. Not nearly so today.

The posts were on 4' centers, but the subfloor wasn't glued down. It is now. And power nailed, too.

The bathroom floors are fairly resistant to water and rot, now that Mr. Overbuilder, with more money and time per project, has been able to repair them so that they should last the rest of MY life.

I remember Bishop Ranch fondly. My labs were in the basement of the Pacific Bell headquarters, though. We didn't have bouncy floor problems there.