Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

Posts

Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#1

Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

John T

>OK, so I'm thinking of installing hardwood flooring in a few rooms in my home.

Of course, like anything worth doing, this calls for purchasing new tools....

I have about 500 sf. of flooring to lay, so a pneumatic floor nailer will be necessary, but I may need to rent this, if the cost of purchase is prohibitive (i.e. my wife gives me "that look" when I tell her what it will cost).

However, currently, I don't own a compressor, SO.....

I see this as an opportunity to buy a compressor (especially if packaged with a brad nailer or other air tool), and/or the above-mentioned flooring nailer.

My question is, the flooring nailers seem to call for ~100 - 120 psi from the compressor. What kind of compressor am I looking for to be able to drive the flooring nailer (I'm guessing the 3 gallon pancake ones aren't going to cut it? though they SAY they spit out 120 psi...).

Compressor recommendations? Prefer smaller, and portable, and hopefully under $500 for the compressor and floor nailer.

I'll probably be posting more as I get closer to gearing up for this project (never installed hardwood floor before).

Thanks in advance for any and all replies!

-JOhn-

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#2

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

John E in SC

>My thoughts: A pancake compressor will do (PSI isn't the problems with smaller compressors. The smaller tank will require the motor to cycle more, but you should have plenty of pressure for a nail gun). But personally, I would by a good "medium sized" (whatever that means to you) compressor - you'll find tons of uses for it if you have one. I can't imagine not having a compressor - I use it all the time. Also, I would go ahead and buy a decent pneumatic flooring nailer. I bought the Porter Cable FCN-200 - you won't go wrong with that one - for about $400 if I remember correctly. Used it on two rooms (and was able to take my time doing it, which you won't be able to do if you're paying a daily rental rate), and then sold it for $350 on ebay. No way I could have rented one for what the nailer ended up "costing" me.

Overall, doing your own flooring is not that tough, and is a very rewarding project. By the way, you'll probably also want a pneumatic finish nailer for the first few courses of boards near the wall - there typically isn't room to use a regular flooring nailer close to the wall, and it will also come in hand for shoe moulding, etc. etc.

Good luck,

John

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A preference...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Whenever I lay a hardwood floor (not terribly often), I prefer to face-nail the first course with 10d or so finish nails to help keep it in place. This is when starting against a wall. The "correct" way to start is on the centerline of the room, nailing against a scrap board screwed to the floor for a few courses, then pull the scrap, put a spline in the groove and run the opposite way for that half of the room.

Jason

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#4

Wimp?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>An air nailer for a mere 500 sq ft ?!?

You want to take your time laying the floor to space joints and develop grain of wood and fix problems with sub floor and the flooring pieces. It all pays off in the end. So, you do not want to rent a nailer that would leave you rushed laying the floor.

Buy a used, or new, manual nailer. At the rate you will select, saw and fit you will not be taxed pounding in the nails. It is a two wack job per nail and the hammer does the work.

Years ago someone in the club purchased a manual nailer and it has been loaned for numerous flooring jobs in the past years.

The other advice I will offer is to fix problems as they show up, like miscut floor strips. If the piece doesn't fit easily find and fix the problem in the subfloor or the flooring piece. If you pound it into submission it will reveal itself later. Oh, and hire a competent person to sand.

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#5

Re: Bill's right

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>The manual flooring nailer is only tiring if you're working with a crew where someone else is trimming and fitting the flooring while you're just hammering. Unless, of course, you need the excuse so you can buy a compressor, which is also a worthwhile tool.

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#6

I apparently am....

John E in SC

>A few years ago, I was helping a bunch of guys trying to cover the pulpit area at our church with hardwood flooring. They had rented a manual nailer. Maybe it was the one we had, but neither I nor any of the other men there could whack that thing hard enough consistantly to get it to work, and a half-driven nail was a nightmare to try and get out. We went and got a pneumatic nailer to finish the job, and never looked back. If you've got gorilla arms you would probably be OK, but it ain't for me.

John

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#7

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

Kevin Mac Luskie

>I just finished up installing 1300 sqft of Quartersawn White oak in my new addition. About 900 sqft in 2 connected rooms on the first floor, and a hallway and bedroom on the 2nd floor. It was the first time I had every installed hardwood floor. My Craftsman Pancake air compressor worked perfectly for the entire project. I bought a Harbor Freight Pneumatic flooring stapler/nailer (it will do both) For $160 new. It worked perfectly as well. It might not last for 20k sqft of flooring. But I fell I could easily get another 3-4k out of it without needing any servicing. [I read one article somewhere the the HF floor nailer could be repaired with the same rebuild kit you can buy for the Bostich I think.]

Hope that info helps you out.

-Kevin

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#8

Something way wrong

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am certainly not exceptionally strong and a long ways past my peak strength and I can set a flooring nail reliably in 2 whacks. l could do it in one but I have better control with a starting whack and a second whack for seating the nail and pulling up the flooring. I can gauge the force of the last whack to match how much nail needs to be driven and whether the floor needs to be pulled up more or less. (you certainly can lay a floor too tight) You are driving a relatively small nail with a hammer that must weight 2-3 pounds. The hammer weight does most of the work.

The "half driven nail" leads me to believe there was something wrong with technique or the nailer. The nailer should not let go of the nail till it is seated. So a partially driven nail presents no problem; whack it again,.... and again, however many times necessary to seat it. The only time a nail should be partially set is if there is an exceptionally hard place in the wood. I have seen such places occasionally on some very dense white oak.

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#9

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

Jim Dillon

>John,

Unless you really want a small compressor (a super valuable tool IMHO), rent (or buy) a manual nailer. Because I like to work at my own slow pace, I purchased the PC manual nailer from Amazon about 10 years ago and it has worked really well. Like Bill said, two whacks and the nail is in. Yes, working close to the wall is hard, if not impossible, but one can face nail or screw the board down and cut a wooden plug for the screw hole.

I got a load of help from Don Bollinger's book "Hardwood Floors" by Taunton Press.

Regarding small compressors, I've had good luck (that is, when I remember to change the oil 8-)) with my 10-year old Emglow (now Dewalt).

On rare occasion, I've had a nail bend over - but the cause was striking a plywood subfloor screw under the flooring. With really hard wood like locust, I lubricate the strip of nails with wax (actually toilet bowl "wax" rings).

Putting down flooring is a very rewarding experience and can be readily done by the DIYer. Go for it!

Jim

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#10

Re: Something way wrong

John E in SC

>We were laying white oak, but if I remember correctly, the nailer we had "let go" after one whack. I think it used cleats like my porter cable pneumatic one, rather than nails or staples. Maybe we just had a bad nailer. (But I don't plan on trying it again to find out :>)

John

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#11

Thanks for the Replies

John T

>Thanks to all for your replies.

John E, and Kevin: I hadn't thought of possible resale of the nailer (who ever gets rid of tools? I thought the objective was to collect as many as possible...). I actually floated this idea past the wife last night and she seemed to think it was a good idea. So I'll be shopping for a compressor (NEW TOOL!!! YAHOO!!) and will look into the HF nailer. $160-$200 doesn't sound too painful.

Bill: Yes, I am a wimp. I drive a desk all day, and work hard at doing as little as possible. The most exercise I get lately is my 12 ounce curls in the evening. Sure, I could probably do it with the manual nailer, but this way I have an excuse to buy a compressor!!

Sounds like a pancake or smallish compressor will be enough (since I will be going slowly, as Bill said. But this would give me the opportunity to spread the work out over several days (Weeks?).

Thanks again for the input.

Cheers.

-John-

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#12

I can do it in one swing....

Andy Halterman: 30s officially over

>consistently. Even close to the walls.

So there. :-)

Got just over 1200 feet to nail down tomorrow. I wonder if the four of us can get it done in a day?

Tuesday afternoon just can't get here quick enough......

Andy Halterman

Can almost smell the desert sage in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#13

Ditto

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I did the same as John - bought a small compressor and the Porter cable nailer (FCN 200 or something like that). I kinda wish I'd gone bigger, now I'm looking at buying a spray gun, but the little pancake model (2hp, 6 gallon) works just fine with the Porter cable floor nailer.

I really liked having the power tool. I found putting in a floor tiring enough just from getting up and down so much; but then, my knees aren't the greatest anymore. I had considered the manual but am glad I went with the pneumatic.

I've done a total of around 800-900 square feet, three rooms. One more, then I plan to sell the nailer.

As others mentioned, you'll be able to do a much better job if you can go at your own pace. I spent a lot of time matching board grain and color, worth every minute. A very satisfying job.

Ken

Re: Kinda OT: Hardwood Floor, first of a series

#14

Re: Thanks for the Replies

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I recently borrowed a HF pneumatic nailer and it worked fine on 2 rooms of flooring using only a small pancake compressor.

I used it to install pre-finished 3/4"x3" oak flooring. It was such a relief to not have to sand and finish the floor I cant begin to tell you. A few trim pieces installed and the floor was done.