Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Sharpening systems

Posts

Sharpening systems

#1

Sharpening systems

Allan D

>I've had the same set of soft and hard arkansas stones plus 8" bench grinder for over thirty years. The soft stone is worn concave to the point of being unusable and the bench grinder is shot. So I'm looking at a new setup. Lots of new options in sharpening have opened up in the last three decades. Also, in about five years I'll have completed all my planned major projects and will be retiring and downsizing my shop, getting rid of most of my floor machines. I plan to continue woodworking using mostly portable power tools and hand tools. I have a nice collection hand planes I want to use and keeping them sharp will be more important to me.

What set-ups do people here use and recommend?

Re: Sharpening systems

#2

JL

Re: Sharpening systems

JL

>What's wrong with getting a new soft Arkansas stone? If you are used to your Arkansas stones, why change?

My personal setup is an 8" bench grinder that I use for turning tools and a set of waterstones that I use for everything else. I have friends with diamond stones and they like those. I have a couple of small diamond paddles that I use for honing. BTW, my 8" grinder is a dual speed grinder that I keep on low speed. You can get hooked on "sharpening systems" and all of the hoopla, but it all boils down to how sharp can you get the tool personally. Have you been unhappy with the sharpening results that you've been getting?

My $0.02.

Re: Sharpening systems

#3

Re: Sharpening systems

Chad Pearson

>Has your soft Arkansas stone been worn down so much that it can't be flattened with some sandpaper? I regularly flatten my stones by putting a sheet of sandpaper on a flat surface (I have a nice piece of granite but a table saw would work also) and rubbing it until its flat.

Re: Sharpening systems

#4

Re: Sharpening systems

Frank Mutchler

>I've tried stones, scary sharp, grinder, voo-doo, etc. I bought a Lee Valley MKII power sharpening system & have never looked back. I use it to flatten chisel backs as well as to sharpen them. Plane blades are a 'piece a cake'. I leave it set up & protected with a dust cover so it only takes about 5 to 7 minutes to touch up an edge. No water or oil means no mess. I sharpen lathe tools with a grinder & misc jigs.

Re: Sharpening systems

#5

Re: Sharpening systems

Allan D

>I never considered flattening it with sandpaper. I'm intrigued. What type and what grit do you use? I haven't measured the concavity but let's assume it's 1/16". Would that be too much to removed?

Re: Sharpening systems

#6

Re: Sharpening systems

wilbur

>I love Japanese waterstones. I wouldn't think of using anything else for straight edge tools.

Having said that, I agree with the comments above that if you have been happy with the edges you were getting with your Arkansas stones, there's no need to change.

What I would do is get some sort of flat surface that you know is flat. A big ceramic tile, a cutoff piece of granite countertop, or the granite surface plate that they have at Woodcraft for $32 all will work. Then get some sheets of 150-220 grit sandpaper, stick it to the flat surface, and flatten your current stone. Don't worry about the actual grit -- you're going to be tossing the sandpaper anyway. 1/16" is not too much to flatten.

Then buy a new 8" grinder, and you'll be set. Woodcraft has one of those, as well.

On the other hand, if you weren't happy with your Arkansas stones, and if you want change your whole method of sharpening, I'll be happy to talk Japanese waterstones.

But again, if you were happy with your current method of sharpening, there's really no need to switch methods.

Re: Sharpening systems

#7

My method is the same as Wilber's

Chad Pearson

>

Re: Sharpening systems

#8

Well I'm amazed!

Allan D

>A half hour and two sheets of sandpaper and I have myself a new stone! I can't believe mere sandpaper could do that. I had considered getting it trued up again somehow be I thought I would have to send it out someplace and it would end up costing more than the $25 or $30 of a new stone.

Guess I should have remembered the old Rock, Sissors, Paper game where paper bests stone, right?

Re: Sharpening systems

#9

I use the Tormek system with no complaints

Hamish

>

Re: Sharpening systems

#10

Re: Sharpening systems

Bill White

>Well Dang Alan!!!!!

You didn't go hi-tech, spend $500.00, add two outlets to the shop.....

You're DISQUALIFIED!!!!!

You MUST beg forgiveness from the spending police.

Bill