Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT Relay Switch

Posts

OT Relay Switch

#1

OT Relay Switch

Sawman

>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am getting ready to install a alternate fuel furnace along side my LP forced air unit. I would like to wire it up so that when the "new" furnace blower comes on the "old" blower would also come on.

Can someone recommend the proper relay and suggest a wiring diagram?

Thanks

Re: OT Relay Switch

#2

Re: OT Relay Switch

Dan Donaldson

>Does the new furnace have a relay for the motor? I am guessing if it does that it is a 24 volt relay. If so, then I would get a duplicate of it and run it in parallel with the 24 volts of the other one.

Re: OT Relay Switch

#3

Re: OT Relay Switch

GalenV

>Not sure why you need both blowers running. Does the new furnace draw air from the same old cold air pelnumb and new discharge into the same hot air plenumb? Seems you would not need both blowers running if only one furnace runs. A damper in the duct would need to be closed on one or you may just pump air in a loop at the furnaces. Maybe I am missing something in How they are connected.

Could be as simple as the parrallel relay on the new furnace as Dan noted. If contacts rated for the new blower the parallel relay would probably have sufficient contact rating for the old blower. If the old furnace has a manual blower switch you can wired the relay contact parallel to that 110 volt switch.

If the old furnace has a two speed blower for AC and heat then it could be a little more complicated to wire. Do you have diagram for both to see what you have?

Be careful if you are dealing with both 24 volt control and 110 volt blower you never let the paths meet!

Re: OT Relay Switch

#4

Lots of questions raised here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Others have asked why you're wanting to turn both on, and I'm equally confused. If they're both dumping into the same plenum, you need to consider whether you'll be creating airflow issues with and without both blowers running.

If I recall correctly (this is shorthand for "haven't done this for a living for more than 30 years"), the blower is tied into or at least affected by/affects both the low and high temp limit switches and is thus integrated into the safety controls for the furnace, so you need to understand the circuit layout for your existing and your new furnace.

You want to spend some time doping out the circuit layout of your furnace - if you can't draw it after studying it and can't tell whether there are any possible negatives from your proposed wiring change, you shouldn't be tampering with it, for fear of damaging the furnace.

Re: OT Relay Switch

#5

Re: Lots of questions raised here

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>You're close - the blower is tied into the low-temp/hi temp switch, but that's just to ensure it's on before the flame is, and off after the flame has cooled off. The blower fan can run fine on it's own and the 24VAC wire associated to the unit's t-stat is usually a pretty safe direct run to the manual fan on/off cct.

BUT - I too have questions on why you want both blowers. If the intent is to run two furnaces side by side and have them both pull air from the same return air path and push air into the same supply air path, you need to think this through.

1) Your ductwork was sized for a specific volume of air to run through. If you run two fans in parallel, you'll probably increase the net airflow, but you will not double it. You'll also take that net total airflow and roughly split it between two fans meaning each fan will see something over 50% of it's intended airflow. Fans have a floe curve and ar a rule they are not at all efficient if you place them into a situation where they run off their curve. This means neither fan will be performing to it's expectations and in fact, it's highly probable that neither will be performing at all.

2) Air will take the path of least resistance meaning that unless your two fans are perfectly sized (extremely unlikely), one will be stronger than the other. This means that when both fans are running the stronger one will take air and the weaker one will be idling. If the fans are totally our of shack with each other it's conceivable that the weaker unit could actually have air flowing backwards through it (this is extreme, unlikely, but possible).

3) You will not be able to maintain a decent temperature control as you'll have one furnace pushing heated air, and the other one pushing air at whatever temperature it's receiving.

4) Your elec. energy bill will go up but you won't benefit from the use of that extra power.

Based on these reasons (and a few more), I think it wise to abandon the concept of "AND" when it comes to running these units and instead concentrate on a concept of "OR". In other words, you'll either have furnace #1 running OR furnace #2 running but you'll never have furnace #1 AND furnace #2 running at the same time.

In order for this to occur (and assuming you have one set of ductwork), you'll need to isolate one furnace form the other one as far as the air paths are concerned. As someone mentioned here, that means dampers. Depending on the duct configuration you'll need two four of them. If the duct work is configured as a "Y" (the sheet metal fitting for this is commonly called a "pair of pants") and you're having it made up, they can sometimes put a flapper-style damper at the junction of the "Y itself. This can flip one way or the other to close off one of the paths. This sounds cool, but is $$ and rarely works properly.

More than likely you'll need four dampers. One for each furnace's return air path and one for each furnace's supply air path. On these dampers you'll have 24VAC motors (on/off) and you'll want them to have a spring return (remove power, a spring will swing the dampers to their default position. On your primary furnace, these will be set up to spring open (to ensure one set is always open). On your secondary furnace, they'll spring closed.

Now your furnaces are able to be isolated and ready to be controlled.

For control, I'd be tempted to use one thermostat and instead of hard wiring it to your primary furnace as it is now, I'd wire it to a small relay bank (one for power source, one for heat, one for fan etc.). This relay bank can be controlled by a simple toggle switch for Primary System or Secondary System. The signal for heat from the t-stats would then be diverted to the appropriate unit (depending on your selection on the toggle switch), and parallel with that call would also be a signal to your dampers. This can further be wired (with additional components) for an auto-changeover in the event of a unit failure, but that's more than I want to go into here.

So there you have it. It's not a simple as you'd like it to be, but it's also not that complicated and if it's important to you, I'd take the time, spend the $4 and do it properly so you have a safe installation and an efficient heating system.

Rob

Re: OT Relay Switch

#6

Re: OT Relay Switch *LINK*

GalenV

>Think we all are concerned if you are trying a do-it-yourself install are you using a commercial alternative fuel furnace? A unit made by Yukon Eagle has pretty clear information on installation as a stand alone, series or parallel flow to you existing furnace. It shows the dampers or ducting needed for each application. They have a control system that allows connecting to your existing furnace blower and wiring diagram to show same.

If you ae making up a sytem of your own I would suggest you compare to a commercial setup.

Think everyoen has god comments we just do noto know the rest of the story as Palu Harvey would say.

Hope link will give you some ideas.


http://www.yukon-eagle.com/Portals/0/bigjack.pdf