Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Posts

OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#1

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Okay, so I have a Toshiba Satellite M35X-S111 laptop. Originally, it came with 256MB RAM, to which I added another 256MB PC2700 SODIMM module. Apparently, these days, PC2700 modules are quite expensive, so I was wondering if PC3200, PC5400, PC6400 or any of the other less-expensive modules would fit and work (well). I'm not 100% certain, but I think the XP SP 3 upgrade sent my laptop over the top, as it is now like me--very slow to wake up. From the time I log in to my Windows account, it can be up to 10 minutes before I am surfing the web, a process that use to take less than a minute just a few months ago. Not to mention, I often have to hard boot it when I open the lid because it won't wake up on its own, even though the power light is on. I have removed unwanted/unused programs, de-fragged the harddrive, run Spybot, Ad-Aware and AVG multiple times, and am convinced that half a gig of memory just isn't enough for this poor laptop any more.

BTW, Mark Goodall, if you respond, I don't have to take my keyboard apart to get to the second module--both are under a cover on the bottom of the laptop. One screw for the cover, two spring clips for each module.

Jason

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#2

JL

Been there, done that.. *LINK*

JL

>Try Crucial. They say you can have 2x1 GB.


Toshiba Satellite

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#3

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus... *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Crucial is good memory, so is Corsair, which I used on the last PC I built.

Image for your machine from the Corsair page is below, as is a link to the 1 gig module at NewEgg for $14.50/ea. I'd get 2 to give you 2 gig, which is a good amount for XP.

NewEgg is a great source I have used for years.


img

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N8

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#4

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Chuck W

>jason,

i would stick with the recommendation from the Corsair website which is for the DDR-333 (PC-2700) SODIMM. They have the the 1 gig module for $20 after rebate.

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#5

Misread your model number *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Here's the link to the Corsair info page:

http://corsair.com/configurator/system_results.aspx?id=48706

The link Newegg page is below.

Price is $19.99/ea after rebate with free shipping.

Hope this helps, sorry for any confusion.

Dan


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N8

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Thanks, but...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I appreciate the links to memory, the Corsair one might do the trick. But I really wanted to know if there were other ratings that would fit and work. For instance, the desktop from which I am typing this post has memory in it that is not the same rating. I think the computer is supposed to have PC2700 and has 1 gig of PC3200 in it or something like that, but this is a much faster desktop...

Jason

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#7

Re: Thanks, but... *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Not being all that familiar with laptops (I've built several desktops, but haven't done much with laptops) I'm not sure if DDR400 (PC3200) 200 pin modules would fit your machine or not. Off the top of my head, since both the Corsair product finder and the Newegg one (link below, it includes other brands) only returned DDR 333 PC2700, without further study, I would conclude "not". If they would work, they'd be faster (the 2700 & 3200 relate to speed). Would you notice the difference? I doubt it very much. I can tell you the Corsair 1 gig DDR400's are about 13 bucks more per stick at Newegg, with shipping.

With the rebate & free shipping, the Corsair DDR 333 PC2700 is a very good deal for high quality ram you know will work.

Dan


Newegg ram finder for Toshiba M35X

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#8

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Curly Smith

>Yes, the PC3200 memory should be compatible but the others won't be.

From the Crucial Website: Memory speeds and compatibility

"PC3200 (commonly referred to as DDR400) memory is DDR designed for use in systems with a 200MHz front-side bus (providing a 400 MT/s data transfer rate). The "3200" refers to the module's bandwidth (the maximum amount of data it can transfer each second), which is 3200MB/s, or 3.2GB/s. PC3200 is backward-compatible for PC1600, PC2100, and PC2700."

But I'd call first just to be certain that it will work in your specific machine.

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#9

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Tom

>PC3200 will work fine. It won't be any faster (probably) as the processor, bus and memory all need to work at the same speed. I'm not familiar with the specs of your laptop, but I'd guess the bus speed will be the bottleneck. The pc3200 will just clock down to pc2700 speeds. 2x512 would be fine, and not too dear. Ebay is good for stuff like this...

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Thanks again...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...those were the types of answers I was looking for. The tightwad in me saw the great disparity in list prices between the PC2700 and the faster memories and started to wonder. I don't care if the laptop clocks the faster memory down, I just couldn't see spending $60/GB for PC2700, if something that was $20/GB would work.

Looks like Newegg is the ticket...

Jason

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

#11

Re: OT--ATTN: Laptop Memory Gurus...

Will Abbott

>I have put SP3 on 3 different computers and promptly removed it from all three. It caused slow downs and major stability problems. Half a gig should be enough RAM unless you are doing heavy duty computing. Such as CAD work or video editing. Most likely you would benefit form a complete reinstall of Windows more that you would from adding more RAM.

Will.