Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Bed slat thickness?

Posts

Bed slat thickness?

#1

Bed slat thickness?

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Folks -

I'm finishing up a twin size bed for my daughter, and am up to making the slats to support the mattress; I've decided to try going without a box spring. The slats will be 4 inches wide, an inch apart. The width to be supported is about 37 inches.

I'm making the slats from flatsawn red oak, since that's the least popular constituent of my lumber, um, stores (Like I keep telling my wife, it only _appears_ to be a collection!).

Most of my "4/4" red oak is a little thick, around 1 1/8 thick. It'll probably dress out at close to 1 inch thick. The various bed plans I've been consulting call for 3/4 inch thick slats. So: will the extra thickness make much difference in how the bed feels? Will it be too firm? Or is the feel mostly up to the mattress firmness, and the slat thickness isn't going to make any difference? If it won't matter, I'd like to spare my planer and save the time taking it down to 3/4 inch thick.

I've not made or even sat on a bed without a box springs, and I don't want to have to re-plane a bunch of slats after I've finished making and assembling the thing. Anyone got some experience on this they'd care to share? Thanks -

Ken

Re: Bed slat thickness?

#2

Re: Bed slat thickness?

Dick Coers

>The beds I made for the kids years ago were more of a platform style, but I used 3/4" plywood for the mattress to sit on. When they were less than 12 years old I didn't think their weight would require the use of a box spring either. I say go with the 1" red oak and it will be great. Unless of course you want to keep the oak, then get a piece of cheap ply from the Borg. No, nix that idea. Don't expose them to that much formaldehyde from the glue.

Re: Bed slat thickness?

#3

Re: Bed slat thickness?

John McGaw

>In my experience modern "box springs" are just boxes -- no spring involved. Try sitting on one and you'll see. As mere supports for the mattress they don't have a lot of say in what goes on other than one that is totally collapsed will dump the occupant on the floor.

On my queen sized bed I used three 7/8" poplar plywood pieces which bridge the bed frame from left to right, and each of these had a tapered rib added to the bottom as reinforcement (in case of enthusiastic use) With a 14"-thick pillow top mattress sitting on the platform that is entirely high enough but with the box spring, as originally set up, the bed was at a height so as to induce nosebleed.

For something as narrow as 37" almost any thickness slat would work but since there will be gaps between the slats which would wreak damage upon the mattress fabric I'd suggest you forget that and make a solid 3\4" platform instead in one or two pieces. The feel should be exactly the same.

Re: Bed slat thickness?

#4

Ok, 1 inch thick it is...

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Thanks guys. I'll go with the 1" thickness. I think I'm going to use the red oak, since I have quite a lot of it, and no suitable plywood around at the moment. Plus, if I use the red oak, I can maybe mill those cherry trees I've had my eye on, but haven't had any room to dry or store...

I looked back at the plans in FWW, and they called for 1/4" spacing of the slats, not the 1" I apparently pulled out of nowhere. So hopefully sanding and rounded edges will go easy on the mattress. Thanks, John, I'd not thought about that aspect.

Ken

Re: Bed slat thickness?

#5

Re: Ok, 1 inch thick it is...

Chris Friesen

>Spacing shouldn't be a problem. The Ikea slats that I've seen are anywhere from 1-2 inches apart and it doesn't seem to cause any problems.