In the end it's tuning and user preference
Forrest Addy
>In the end it's tuning and user preference that makes a plane a sow's ear or a silk purse.
Some time ago when I was pursuing the Perfect Plane, A friend of mine and lover of the Bedrocl line challenged me with an Anant, an Indian made junker or the day. Since I am a metalworker having skills and resources for some fairly fancy metalwork I rose to the challenge. In about 12 hours (as I recall) I had machined, scraped, abrasive sheet lapped, sharpened, honed, and polished until I thought the miserably constructed Anant was a least competetive with the Bedrock it would meet in competition.
Well, it was almost a draw. It lost a few points because the Anant was a bit homely alongside the classic lines of the Bedrock. Otherwise they performed about equally in dry hard maple, yellow pine, and in figured walnut.
The tuning process is the whole key. Buy a Lee Nielson and you won't have to tune it much but you pay $300+ for a really magnificent tool. OTH, a $2 rusted yard sale find will take some time and skill to restore to function includign maybe a new iron.
A hand plane is a collection of parts that when properly fitted and assembled produces a tool capable of becoming the heart and soul of the work bench. When improperly fitted or neglected, battered, abused, and allowed to rust, even the finest hand plane will eventually become junk.
In art, it's not the paint and canvas, it's the artisty that makes the great painting. In a hand plane, its not the castings and parts, it's the fitting and assembly. And like art, knowing when to stop fiddling with the work is probably half the battle.
The brand loyal and the collecters may scoff at this concept but if you are merely looking for user planes, most anything will do for a good user plane. You will need some basic skills for metalworking and hav access to good advise. Hint: a pefectly flat sole may not be the best configuration for a working hand plane.