Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

Posts

What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#1

What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>So far I've mostly been learning machine-based wood working. I thought it might be fun to pick up, refurbish & learn to use a vintage jack plane. I have a Dunlop my father bought 40-odd years ago, but I have been told it's not the best. Below is a link to a Stanley on ebay, being sold by someone who's within driving distance.

I have to say, based only on the pictures, it sure looks like my dad's old Dunlop ;-/

What are some really sweet vintage planes of a type that would be a good addition to a machine-based shop?

TIA

Dan


http://cgi.ebay.com/Stanley-5-Jack-plane_W0QQitemZ

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#2

I don't believe it!!!

Dan Mitchell

>The auction in the link I just posted ENDED while I was writing my post!!!

Oh well, question still stands!

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#3

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>The same guy has another one for sale-


Stanley #5 Jack Plane

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#4

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Neal in San Jose

>Dan, ya might want to wander over to the hand tool side. You will probably get more information that you want! Neal

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#5

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The hand tool guys might actually tell you that Stanley may have made the Dunlap plane you now have, too.

eBay can be an 'interesting' place to start buying used hand planes. But they'll tell you that, too, and offer alternatives.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#6

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. I've posted the same inquiry on the hand tool forum (my maiden post there, wish me luck... ;-)

Yeah I'm not saying ebay is the best place, I was just poking around there. We'll see what the experts on the other side have to say.

Dan

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#7

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Dunlop was a brand sold by Sears Roebuck along with the Craftsman brand. I do know that Millers Fall made Craftsman for many years, I have been a big fan and user of Millers Fall planes and I feel they maybe a better plane than Stanley. I have all four brnds in my collection and the only differance I find between the Millers Fall and Cratfsman is the name stamped on them. My $0.02

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#8

-lop or -lap *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

>Since my branch of the family tree is connected to the Scottish Dunlop's I get a chuckle seeing the name in print. The American spelling of the name is Dunlap. The second line Sears tools were labeled Dunlap for many years. A friend of mine found a double bit ax head with Dunlap on it for a gift. Makes me fell like I'm connected to some important clan :)

Dunlop is a family disease...where the belly done laps over the belt :)

Tom


Tom Dunlap tools

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#9

Re: I don't believe it!!!

BILL White

>Dan, the plane should be examined closely for any problems on the castings, sole, frog, chip breaker, etc. Heavily rusted sole is bad.

You will need to tune, sharpen, and wax it up.

Much more than $35.00-$40.00 is too much unless it is pristine.

Bill

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#10

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

steve mackay

>Six days left and already $20.00 plus shipping ? Seems like a lot. $10.00 plus shipping is reasonable. I'd keep looking.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#11

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>The reason people jack up their shipping charges do so to avoid paying eBay higher commission on final price. No commission on shipping charge. Legal-yes, Ethical-?????.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: But...

Dale Lenz

>PayPal still charges the seller about 3% of the shipping chargers.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#13

In the end it's tuning and user preference

Forrest Addy

>In the end it's tuning and user preference that makes a plane a sow's ear or a silk purse.

Some time ago when I was pursuing the Perfect Plane, A friend of mine and lover of the Bedrocl line challenged me with an Anant, an Indian made junker or the day. Since I am a metalworker having skills and resources for some fairly fancy metalwork I rose to the challenge. In about 12 hours (as I recall) I had machined, scraped, abrasive sheet lapped, sharpened, honed, and polished until I thought the miserably constructed Anant was a least competetive with the Bedrock it would meet in competition.

Well, it was almost a draw. It lost a few points because the Anant was a bit homely alongside the classic lines of the Bedrock. Otherwise they performed about equally in dry hard maple, yellow pine, and in figured walnut.

The tuning process is the whole key. Buy a Lee Nielson and you won't have to tune it much but you pay $300+ for a really magnificent tool. OTH, a $2 rusted yard sale find will take some time and skill to restore to function includign maybe a new iron.

A hand plane is a collection of parts that when properly fitted and assembled produces a tool capable of becoming the heart and soul of the work bench. When improperly fitted or neglected, battered, abused, and allowed to rust, even the finest hand plane will eventually become junk.

In art, it's not the paint and canvas, it's the artisty that makes the great painting. In a hand plane, its not the castings and parts, it's the fitting and assembly. And like art, knowing when to stop fiddling with the work is probably half the battle.

The brand loyal and the collecters may scoff at this concept but if you are merely looking for user planes, most anything will do for a good user plane. You will need some basic skills for metalworking and hav access to good advise. Hint: a pefectly flat sole may not be the best configuration for a working hand plane.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#14

Agree 100%

John E in SC

>About a year ago, I took a woodworking class (my first) that was basically how to sharpen, tune, and use handplanes and chisels. I bought a new Anant bench plane, and spent several hours flattening the sole and sharpening the blade. (Keep in mind, this was my first time EVER tuning a handplane - but I had excellent instruction.) When it was all said and done, I could take "see-through" shavings from hard maple just as easily as the instructor with his Lie Nielsen plane, which cost about 10X more. Yes, his Lie Nielsen was a joy to look at, hold, and use, and performed great right out of the box, but the point is, a little effort on a "lower end" plane can give equal performance to the top-of-the-line. You pay your money, you take your choice.

John

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#15

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Fred Davis

>So you could offer a #5 Jsck plane for two bucks and charge 25.00 shipping and handling?

Now that would be sneaky and appeal to the larcenous hearts of used tool dealers.

FredD

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#16

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. It probably does make sense to begin with the old Dunlap. I've already sharpened the blade quite nicely using the HF wet grinder I mentioned in another post, this turned out so well, I thought I'd consider a "better" plane. This old tool isn't really in too bad a shape, just a bit of surface rust. I do have some FWW vids on plane tuning, I'll pull one out & go from there.

Dan

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#17

Re: Agree 100%

Thomas S Stockton

>Years ago the first class I ever took on furnituremaking was at College of the Redwoods it was tools and techniques class where the main focus was to make 3 handplanes in the style that James Krenov uses. The Irons they gave us to use were dirt cheap stanley block plane irons and you know what they work really well. They don't hold an edge like a Hock iron will and they aren't a thick but they are completly servicable and I still use my first three planes I built over 20 years ago. I would say tune that bad baby up and use it, if the iron is too pitted to use you can probably get a replacement, but unless needed use and learn from what you have. Once you figure out how a plane works you will be in much better shape to figure out what you want next.

The thing about old planes is that there are some minor companies that made nice stuff, there is also some junk out there so the more knowledge you have the better.

Tom

Re: What's a good, used jack plane? *LINK*

#18

Re: What's a good, used jack plane?

BILL White

>Dan, You will be very proud of the well-tuned results. Kinda like, "Look what I did!".

Bill