The utility of linseed oil in a finish
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I agree with the start of this discussion, which raged earlier, that some people use an oil finish not because it is best for an application, but because it is easy. However, that does not mean that linseed oil has no utility in a finishing schedule, as illustrated in the picture.
I did not have any experience finishing mahogany. I needed to finish a piece made with some crotch veneer and I sought the opinion of many people as to how to do it. I followed the advice of Alf Sharp, 2008 SAPFM Cartousch winner. The steps recommended were- shellac wash coat, stain, linseed oil, shellac.
However, his most sage advice was to practice on a piece first. The picture is the test piece of crotch mahogany. The right side was finished as described above, while the left side omitted the oil step. I think all can see that the oiled right side is deeper and richer, as Alf said it would be.
There is also a top to bottom variable in this test piece. The bottom half, both sides, was a combination of a yellow and a reddish dye while the top half was just the reddish dye. For reasons that are not apparent to me the combination dye brought out the grain more as I was told it would.
The main moral of this story is "seek reliable advice and follow it". Alf is noted for his finishes so I am not surprised it tourned out well.



