Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question:Mechanics Lien

Posts

Question:Mechanics Lien

#1

Question:Mechanics Lien

howard

>Ready for this - electrician who did my shop addition verbally quoted one amount and then invoiced $75 more. No change orders, he did the work described. Told him that he quoted me one number and that's what I should be billed. He was very unpleasant but dropped the issue. Just got a certified letter with bill for $75 saying pay in 10 days or legal route and line on house. Here's my question - can a line be put on withot my being able to go to court first? I know it's $75, but the principle of this is what's driving me. Thanks for your thoughts.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#2

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>"verbally quoted" is the weak link in your chain here.

And practically speaking, $75 is a whole lot less than fighting this. A complaint to the local Better Business Bureau and a "friendly" warning to your friends about the guy's business practices may be all you can effectively do. Just phrase your anecdote in the form of personal experience from your point of view. That is not slander. That's opinion.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#3

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Don at Central Illinois

>Always remember a verbal contract isn't worth the papers it's written on. You can fight, etc. but I think Carols advice is good. BBB and word of mouth to friends and neighbors.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#4

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Part of my day job involves construction management for a University. Trust me...pay the $75. I know it stinks but you do not want to get mired in a mechanics lien!!

Tom

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#5

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Dave LaPine

>If you don't mind me asking, what was the total bill amount?

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#6

Call his bluff

Tom Dunlap

>First, document everything as you go. Reconstruct what was said, dates, times, etc.

Was the cert. letter from an attorney? If not, he's bullying you more than likely. His hope is that you'll payup. It costs him time and money to file a lien.

If it was from an attorney he likely paid more than $75 for the letter and service. You may be better off paying him because he doesn't understand the value of his own time.

If you decide to pay him...setup a convenient, to you, payment schedule. Say, a dollar a month, as a check not cash. Be a pain in the butt.

Ask the BBB what the procedure is for filing a lien. Make sure that it's done correctly. At some time, refinancing or sale of the house, you'll have the opportunity to defend your position. I don't think that he can accrue interest or extra charges. Liens have to be filed in a timely manner and then refiled every few years too.

Was there an explanation about the overage? More work? difficulty that wasn't forseen?

After running my tree care company for 25 years I never asked for more unless the job changed nor did I give any rebate if things went better than I expected. Characters like this give service people a bad name. Grrrr...

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#7

In a word, No.

Neal in San Jose

>Addy protocol: Speaking as a former general contractor in California (your state may be different, but I'd bet not very much), unless the electrician has a written quote signed by you for the full amount, or a change order signed by you for the additional amount, AND proof of a pre-lien notice filed BEFORE he STARTED ANY WORK, he doesn't have a leg to stand on. A call to your state contractor's license board (or equivalent) should help you straighten everything out. Further complaints to the BBB might make you feel better as well. HTH Neal

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#8

First: Don't Take Legal Advice From

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>From non-lawyers over the Internet. However well-meant, persons untrained in the law that applies to such matters in your state have no place giving you advice as to how to proceed in this particular situation. Many states have very different rules regarding such liens.

Second: Start by contacting your County Clerk's office regarding procedures (and costs) for filing and/or disputing such liens.

Third: There are often local legal aid offices or pro bono law firms that can and will assist you in such situations. Many use this kind of silly/small case to train their new/young attorneys.

Fourth: Most County court systems have small claims divisions from which you can get information. While many court clerks have large amounts of experience [they'll be the first to tell you they actually run the joint |;-}} ], you should not take what even they tell you about the merits of any claim as something you can rely upon.

Fifth: Take my first real-world lesson in contract law (from my father after my 1st year of law school) and have it printed on a T-shirt as follows: "The Only Value Of A Written Contract Is To Keep Honest People Honest"

mm

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#9

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Fred Davis

>Howard in California where I worked as a General contractor fo many years the Loan and Lien laws were fairly simple .

In the case of General contractors who were working as the Prime con tractor their use of the Lien was not as restricted as in the case of sub contractors or specialty contractors suce sas Electrical firm.

Subs in general and material suppliers had ten daus after the job started for thme or the material was dropped and in no case before any construction loans were recorded.

If your Electrician was simply just that and did not have a Electrical contractors license and did not have a written contract, then hecould not file a lien on your property, in California which most states use as a model for consumer oriented laws.

Since I don;'t know the state or the law where you live if it is outside of California , a call made to your state's consumer affairs dept. would readily inform you what was right.

What I suspect is for that small amount of money you recieved a bluff in the mail and the Electrician would probably not wnat to pursue it , because you are allowed everywhere in the country to contest the validity of a Mechincs Lien and the person filing it against you has to go thru a process caled "perfecting the lien" which in California would be a hearing in Superior Court of the county you lived in.

All that being said , if it turns out that he has the right to file the lien and does so, you will need to remove the lien by paying him plus costs if you lose the legal arguement , and if you didn't , in the event you sold your home , that lien would take presidense over all liens expect tax liens.

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#10

Re: First: Don't Take Legal Advice From

Fred Davis

>Damn it, I have to start reading my own rhetoric before I post it.

But anyhow Howard , for the record, employees of city and county goverments are not permitted to hand out legal advice , because this pisses off the local and state Bar associations.

General Contractors in the state of California such as Neal and myself , have a section of Loan and Lien Law they have to know and are tested on it in their contractors license test.

I read what Neal said and it conforms exactly to what I know about Loan and Lien Law in CA which is like I said, fairly simple .

If you can find a pro bono law fim or legal aid, they might be will ing to tell you what the practice is in your state.

Certainly the Consummers Affairs divison of the state and their version of the consummer Fraud Squad is the place to contact , which I certainly would.

One caveat about BBB's , they are funded and equipped by small business owners and are slow to respond to complainta against one of their own , which I was by the way.

What we said in addition to being true is fee free. ;-))

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#11

Agree about the BBB

Dan Mitchell

>They are a business advocacy group, not a consumer advocacy group. You always here them mentioned in discussions like this, but as the consumer, they are not on your side.

Dan

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#12

Re: First

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Fred,

Your and Neal's recitations may be just fine in California, but I can tell you they don't technically float in my ponds. That's OK, except at the core of my original premise is this thing about "Where's Howard?". Then, too, what don't we know that Howard may have left out of his post [as in small factual details] that could make a world of difference in his state and situation merely because he doesn't understand them to be important?

Howard needs to contact someone in his own area who knows what's up. I too have some construction experience in New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, but it's been many years since I practiced in that area, so if he had walked into my office here, I wouldn't attempt to give him advice until I actually checked the current statutory provisions in force.

While in law school, I worked two summers in a "real estate/land use" law firm, and Howard's little $75 dispute would be just the kind of thing they would welcome as a real-world training exercise for a law clerk or new, wet-behind-the-ears lawyer to teach him/her how to conduct a client interview, develop the factual and legal principals to be applied, structure the case file, etc. etc.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#13

Re: First

Fred Davis

>Mark ,

not put too fine of a point on it ,you just proved that only a Lawyer,could attempt to answer a simple question with a page of ambiguity that would do any politician proud.

With just two summers of "real world practice" at that.

If you had really read what we said , it conveyed on several levels what any contractor is required to know and Howard was advised to contact his state's consumer affairs department which in California also oversee's the licensing of Contractors.

Beyond that I believe that most people dealing with these types of disagreements know that the law in their respective states more then likely was modeled on California's.

What Howard choose's to do about it is his decision and his willingess to ask here for approaches on how to handle it says something for this Message board in a postive way.

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#14

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Richard Jones

>OK, building official here with a different perspective............

Got permit?

Electrician got contractor's license? If so, then.........

Call your state Department of Professional and Occupational Registration, (that's what it's called in VA) and file a complaint with them. Doesn't cost you a thing, they do the investigation and will usually follow up with you on their findings. If I'm not mistaken, contractor's (at least here in VA) are SUPPOSED to use a written quotation for any work. Without it, there's no legal paper trail.........

If no permit, and if you do the above, local building department (usually kept informed by DPOR) will probably make you get one after the fact, which you should have had anyway for wiring your shop. Our permit fee for wiring a shop like this is usually about $75... :)

If the guy doesn't have a contractor's license, then your DPOR and local building department, along with the county/city attorney may/can/should serve a warrant on him. Our judges here take a VERY dim view of contracting without a license, and several folks have gotten very active jail time........

Common sense tells me that if there is no written quote on the work, then there is no foul. Have also been in court enough to know that you never know what a judge will do until he/she does it.

I'd probably fight the guy if it came to that, even over $75, which may very well turn into more. I guess it comes down to your deciding which is more important, principle or dollars.

Good luck, would be interested in learning the outcome.

Rich

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#15

Real World

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sorry Fred, didn't wish to mislead you.

My "real world" experience has been 30 years in commercial litigation in a dozen states at both local and federal trial and appellate levels as well as the U.S. Supreme Court.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#16

How ironic Fred...

John in NM

>Your opinion of lawyers is roughly the same as mine of contractors.

Cut Mark some slack, I'd bet he understands his profession about as well as you understand yours, and the discussion is in fact about his profession.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#17

Contractors? The Beat Goes On . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A man is flying in a hot air balloon and realizes he has become lost. He reduces height and spots another man down below. He lowers the balloon further and shouts, "Excuse me, can you help me? I promised my friend I would meet him half an hour ago, but I don't know where I am."

The man below says, "Certainly. You are in a hot air balloon, hovering approximately 30 feet above this field which is located between 40.30 and 40.45 degrees North latitude, and between 58.75 and 59 degrees West longitude, at about 435 feet above sea level."

"Ah. You must be an ARCHITECT," says the balloonist.

"I am," replies the surprised man on the ground, "How did you know?"

"Well," says the balloonist, "everything you have told me is technically very correct, but your information doesn�t bear on my current problem. While I have no reason to doubt you, the information is not in a form that is usable, I have no idea what to make of what you have given to me, and the fact is, after receiving the information, I am still lost."

The man below says, "Oh. You must be a CONTRACTOR."

"I am," replies the balloonist, "but how did you know?"

"Well," says the man on the ground, "you don't know where you are, or where you are going. You have made a unqualified promise which you had no idea how to keep, your ability to keep it is subject to factors beyond your control, and you expect me to solve your problem merely because I happen to have more familiarity with this particular place into which you have dropped yourself. The fact is, you are in the exact same position as you were before we met, but now it is somehow my fault even after I have given you the precise information you requested."

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#18

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

Fred Davis

>Richard ,

it is refreshing to hear a opinion from a another professional in the contruction industry who actually walks the walk.

Your point about requiring the Electrican to be a licensed contractor is well taken and directly to the point of the discussion.

It is interesting to note that the Electrician needs to be licensed as a contractor , not as a legal beagle and the home owner needs to have the appropiate permit which is enforced by a Building offical , not a Lawyer.

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#19

Legitimacy versus Ability

Rick Christopherson

>The one thing that I have not seen anyone point out is the ease and ability to file the lien versus actually contesting it. Anyone can file a lien on a piece of property, regardless whether it is legitimate or not, and that lien will sit there quietly until you need to gain clear title of the property. Even if it is a fraudulent lien, you will still need to address it and clear it legally before you can obtain clear title.

Even if it is a fraudulent lien, it is still a lien until you prove it otherwise. Even if the contractor is fully wrong, he is still in the driver's seat because it will cost you time and/or money to dispute the lien. Granted, if it is willfully fraudulent, then you could go after him for costs, etc.

On another note, since it will likely cost him $25 or more to file the lien, there is actually a good chance he is just bluffing, and a well written response to his threat is probably enough to get him to rescind his threat.

I had a General Contractor fail to pay me, so I threatened to file a lien against his customer's home. That would have ruined his reputation, so he did not want that to happen. In response, he threatened to file a lien on my own home for work we traded months earlier. I told him that this was a fraudulent lien and I would pursue criminal charges if he filed it. There was a lot of legal posturing on the topic, but because I knew more about the law than he did, he finally backed down at the 11th hour and drove to my house with a cashier's check.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#20

Re: Legitimacy versus Ability

Fred Davis

>Rick ,

knowledge is wonderfull thing , sometimes a well worded reponse to abogus claim is all that is necessary, then somtimes a different approach is indicated .-))

But I did mention that a lien once filed on his home had be removed ,before he could for instance sell it and if he waited for years it still stayed there.

Personally I would do to that Electrician the same thing I did one here after we had moved and before I had scouted out the right guy to go to.

I had a Electrician with a Masters license (here in Kansas, that is what is required to contract as a Electrical firm,) correct the first guy's mistakes, then sued the first guy in small claims for 2,500.00.

I won and then approached the City Engineer who had prior knowledge of this guys deficiencies as a Electrician ( he scored 69 on the Block test, therefore was not even a qualified Journeyman) and pointed out that any Electrical permits this guy pulled were issued under false pretenses and asked him to require the guy to get a Masters certificate or I would mention the cities possible exposure to a damaging lawsuit when one of his jobs burned or killed someone to the City manager.

Needless to say , the guy flunked and is now a Maintence man for Russells Chocolate company.

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#21

Re: Legitimacy versus Ability

Fred Davis

>addendum to above:

The filing fee for small claims was eight dollars and one of the beauties of that forum is ...no Lawyer can plead your case or defend the defendant . ;=))

FredD

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#22

Re: In a word, No.

Mike Fitterling

>This is my understanding in Florida, also. I did a huge whole house cabinet job in 2006-2007 and after getting the last of the cabinets the client declined to pay the balance. I could not place a lien because I had no written contract outlining that option. He was a friend and I thought I could trust him, and the whole thing was very informal, although I kept track of every expenditure and labor hours. I am having to sue to make him pay what he owes and the attorney will get a third of that! In Florida, too, there are provisions against placing a lien on "Homesteaded Real Property," but only an attorney in you location can tell you whether that threat carries any weight.

Good luck,

Mike

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#23

Hi All Please Read ON..........

howard

>First, I had no idea the amount of responses I would get to this and I thank all of you for your input. I have been swamped so did not have time to come back earlier. I am in NY and I did not get a written contract from the electrician, just his invoice. I've spoken to my general contractor and asked that he talk to him to get him to drop this. $75 is not big, but it's the principle, I work for my money also. I will also check with my consumer protection office to get my local details.

But - thanks again, it's this kind of response that makes this site so meaningful.

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#24

Re: Hi All Please Read ON..........

Richard Jones

>Fred,

Per my previous, your licensed electrician is legally required (at least here in VA) to provide you with a written quotation that spells out certain items. Any change orders to that quotation/contract must be agreed to by both parties prior to the beginning of that phase of the work. If he didn't do this (and is indeed required by your state to do so), then he's in violation of a state statute. Maybe he would be willing to compromise, say to the tune of $75, in order to avoid that hassle.

Good luck, let us know how this all turns out.

Rich in VA

Re: Question:Mechanics Lien

#25

Re: Hi All Please Read ON..........

Richard Jones

>Howard,

Not sure where I got Fred from, my apologies..........

R