Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Wide White oak boards

Posts

Wide White oak boards

#1

Wide White oak boards

Allan D

>Last weekend I picked up some freshly sawn Oregon white oak lumber from a sawyer. I normally limit the widths I accept to 8 inches because that's the size jointer I have. I couldn't resist picking up a couple nice wide boards though - 16 inchers - because its hard to find nice clear long stock (10 foot). I'd like to leave them wide to have the most options but I fear they are going to warp badly.

Is it going to be a losing battle trying to prevent them from cupping by weighting or clamping them down while they season? Or should I just rip them into smaller widths? I just don't have a project in mind for them yet.

Re: Wide White oak boards

#2

Re: Wide White oak boards

John K Jordan

>>Is it going to be a losing battle trying to prevent them from cupping...

Allan,

From what I know of white oak from my own sawmill - how much they will warp (cup, twist, bow, crook) depends on several factors. True quartersawn will be the most stable but you wouldn't normally find QS boards that wide. If the log was not straight and/or the tree grew leaning, combinations of warp are likely. If the log was straight and the board sawn at an angle instead of straight down the grain, the boards will twist. If flatsawn (likely for such wide boards), you are almost assured of some cupping.

As you mentioned, constraining the boards while drying will help a great deal. Sticker them well off the ground, making sure the stickers are all aligned, and put as much weight on the top as possible. I don't think you can add too much weight. Parking your truck on top would probably help. Clamping has also been used successfully where the stacks are small. Well tensioned cauls would probably help, perhaps made of steel if you have any on hand. Note that drying stresses may cause the boards to crack instead of warp, but in that case you can rip and join.

I've nailed up wide green oak boards on the side of the barn and outbuildings so the boards were restrained from cupping and while they shrink considerably across the grain, and as a rule 4/4 boards do not cup if put up green and are well nailed. It's hard to stop 8/4 and thicker from warping.

JKJ

Re: Wide White oak boards

#3

Re: Wide White oak boards

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you put enough weight on the properly stickered lumber it will dry flat. We sold hundreds of feet of 12" and wider oak when we had the business. Customers paid a premium for it so they could build with the beauty of wide lumber.

It was unclear what your jointer had to do with the width of lumber you bought. So long as you can find a planer wide enough, get lumber as wide as the logs will allow.

Re: Wide White oak boards

#4

Question about Wide White oak boards

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If the logs were plain sawn, wouldn't there be two or three boards right at the center of the log that would be essentially quartersawn and wouldn't these also be the widest boards from the long and least likely to cup?

Lee

Re: Wide White oak boards

#5

Re: Question about Wide White oak boards

John K Jordan

>>If the logs were plain sawn, wouldn't there be two or three boards

>right at the center of the log that would be essentially quartersawn

Absolutely, the boards through the center are the widest and least likely to cup. However, all would have juvenile wood and at least one would contain the pith and may well split during drying. I've got two 20" boards now that I "quartersawed" this way. Both boards split from either end a quarter or more of the way down the board. Sometimes they do better, it's pure speculation about what a particular board will do. I have a 24" wide board that I air dried without even stacking and it didn't split or cup significantly.

The best quartersawn boards (IMO) are from the center out to the bark.

Fortunately, I use most of my lumber around the farm and a few splits and warps usually don't matter. (It does seem like a shame sometimes to use curly cherry in a barn!) I mostly cut oak, pine, y.poplar, cherry, and e.r.cedar logs that people give me. There's nothing like "free" wood. Good clean fun!

JKJ


img

Re: Wide White oak boards

#6

Re: Wide White oak boards

John McGaw

>If they were sawn well and dried well and stored well then you might get away with little to no warpage. On a whim I bought a small stack of 4/4 white oak at an auction for an amazingly low price (I'm not an oak furniture fan). The narrowest board is around 15" and the widest is over 18" IIRC. They were all close to dead flat when I bought them and after five or more years in my stacks they still are.

Re: Wide White oak boards

#7

No

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Lumber is never commercially sawed that way. I suppose someone might saw a log that way but I can't think of a reason to do so. See my article on hardwood lumber production in the Articles Section for a discussion of how logs are sawed for optimum yield of useful lumber.