Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Posts

OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#1

OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

riley01

>Oh wise Woodcentral: Can anyon tell me why I can't get a thermostat for my house that maintains a continues temperature whether it has to turn on the heat or A/C. My truck does it... why can't my house, it seems like it should be simple.

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#2

JL

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

JL

>It may be that your air handling unit is the wrong size. You may not have enough insulation. You may not have "thermopane" or the equivalent windows. All sorts of reasons. How old is your house?

Might I suggest that you have a licensed home inspector or a heating and air specialist give you a visit?

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#3

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Don_S

>I think he wants to set a temp I.E. 73� and the thermostat takes it from there either using the heating or cooling as needed. Even with my electronic programmable thermostat which keeps the house at �1� I have to manually switch from heat to cool.

I don't know of any. It will be interesting to know if anyone else does.

Don

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#4

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Bill Howatt

>Is your question about availability of a thermostat that automatically switches back and forth or the fact that your house seems uncontrollable regardless of the thermostat?

I have a Noma thermostat that I think does that. I never use it because our seasons are very distinct. I also think it has safeguards so it isn't continuously cycling between A/C and furnace (furnace made it too hot so better turn the A/C on).

Bill

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#5

You can!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>My new Climatemaster thermostat has an Auto mode that will run both the A/C and heat system as needed to maintain the temperature. I wouldn't

advise running your house that way as your utility bills would probably be higher than you are used to. The system will heat if the temp drops even a few degrees below the set point and will cool just a few degrees above. Normally you would tolerate swings of 10+ degrees before needing either system.

Lee

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#6

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

riley01

>Hi Bill,

My question is about availability the house is comfortable if the thermostat is in the correct mode but at this time of the year the house is hot in the day due to the east west exposure and then late night early morning its cold when the outside temperature drops 30 degrees...

I will reserach Noma.

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#7

JL

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

JL

>But why? I mean I've got a nice programmable. The heating program is very different from the cooling program. I'm too cheap to heat to 73 degrees (or cool to 73 degrees).

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#8

Re: You can!

riley01

>Thanks Lee

I will research Climate Master, The house is hot in the day due to the east west exposure which pushes the temperature up and then late night early morning its cold when the outside temperature drops 30 degrees outside... I think my wife and I are fine but I worry about my 7mo son. (paranoid first time parent)

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#9

Re: You can!

Phileas

>Thermostats that switch automatically between heat and cool and back again are readily available. Do a google search on programmable thermostat and pick your favorite.

I've been very satisfied with my Honeywell FocusPRO TH6000. It was ~$150, controls dual electric heat pumps (which I required), and is energy star compliant.

Happy woodworking!

Phileas

------WebKitFormBoundary7zr6iy41+99nc8Mf

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#10

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

riley01

>Hi JL,

At this time of year in Washington D.C. The temperature in the day will swing 20-30 degrees. Due to the East West exposure of the house if I leave the A/C off the upstairs of the house will get into the low 80's and then at night when it gets cold outside it will drop into the low to mid 60's. If I leave the AC on it takes care of the highs but not the lows. My wife and I are much more tolerent of the lows then my 7month old son.

Thanks,

Lary

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#11

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I heat and cool my shop/studio with a heat pump. The programmable thermostat can be set to automatically heat or cool per the temperature set point. It also has separate modes for heat or cool only. If your furnace is separate from the air contioioner there may not be such an animal.

Clint

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#12

Pretty sure ours does . . .

steve mackay

>but SWMBO is in charge of that. Honeywell from Lowes. Has a digital display thingie.

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#13

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Howard Norman

>Kids and babies are a lot more tolerant than first time parents think they are. When three of my four children were young we didn't have any thermostats in our house. You opened or closed the valve on the gas heater for heat. The house was cooled with an evaporative cooler (swamp cooler). Never any problems with the kids due to the temperature of the house. Of course that was over forty years ago.

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#14

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>You can do this, In fact most programmable electronic t-stats do this. Make sure you look for a heating/cooling unit that has auto-switchover (or auto-changeover)and you'll be fine.

But be aware that a thermostat needs to work with a temperature deadband. By this I mean the system won't call for heating or cooling if the temperature is within allowable temperature limits when compared against the temperature setpoint you've chosen.

Having a deadband prevents your equipment form short-cycling. If you did not have a deadband and had the setpoint at 73�F and it was cool in the house, the heat would come on and at 73�F the heat would turn off. But there's always residual heat in a system that would continue to be delivered and that would cause the temperature to go over 73�F. If there was no deadband, this rise above the setpoint would be an indicator cooling is required, and your AC would then be called.

As you can imagine, this type of sequence would cause a ping pong effect with the temperature in your house, falsely created by the equipment doing what it was told. And yes, this would also be very hard on the equipment.

I do commercial temperature controls, and as a generalization, we run a deadband of approx 4�F between heating and cooling when a new system is set up. Inevitably after time goes by, some areas have these deadbands tightened up, but we never run with less than a 2�F spread and even that's too tight for my liking. Conversely I allow the temperature in my own home to float about 6�F off setpoint before the heating system kicks in.

Hope that helps

Rob

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#15

Re: You can!

Curly Smith

>I'd put an oil-filled space heater equipped with a thermostat in the nursery. You don't really want to pay to heat the entire house and then pay to remove all of the heat you added. Besides, you may want to set the heat low in the house during the winter nights but still maintain a warmer temperature for the tyke. I'd also investigate planting some trees on the east and west to provide shade during the A/C months.

Note: oil-filled space heaters are the only space heaters that are safe to run unattended. They don't get hot enough to ignite paper, carpet or drapes. Don't buy one of the cheaper alternatives.

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#16

A cheap alternative

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>If you turn your fan on low all the time, it will move the air around the house and even out the effects of heat gain from the sun.

My new system has a variable spped fan that ran all summer and only kicked up a bit when the A/C actually ran. Every room in the house stayed pretty much the same temperature. We also used less kilowatts than the previous year when we were running a dehumidifier in the basement and several box, ceiling and window fans attempting to keep the house cool.

Lee

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#17

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Jim Dillon

>Riley,

The point raised by Rob Stokes is one that I would be concerned about. If I remember correctly, the AC portion of the heat pump should not be operated when the outside temp is below a certain temp (55 degrees ?). At this time of year (I also live in the MD/VA area), temperature lag in the house can be 10-20 degrees, especially if you have windows pointed toward the rising and setting sun. Personally, during these few weeks, I just manually run the AC/heat when needed - open a window, and enjoy the wonderful respite from summer heat prior to winter's onset.

Jim

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#18

Our furnace couldn't handle it

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I guess it also depends if your furnace could handle it.

Ours has a manual pilot light, which requires lighting in the fall.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#19

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Jim - it's not so much that an heat pump should not be run when the Outdoor Air Temp is below 55*F, it's more that the heat pump begins to lose it's ability to discard the rejected "cold" as there's no more warm outdoor air to absorb it. As such, there's not much point in running it.

What eventually ends up happening is the condenser coil will frost up and this has a snowball effect (pardon the pun) of making the unit even less efficient. Today's heat pumps have the ability to know when their coil is iced and will actually reverse the refrigeration cycle of the heat pump to place heat into the outdoor condenser. Yup - this means that in the middle of winter, when you need the heat most, your unit will automatically go into air conditioning mode. And this is exactly why, when you bought the unit, I really hope you said yes to the auxiliary heat option.

Aux heat is usually an electric strip coil that's the last thing the air crosses as it leaves the heat pump and begins it's journey to your home. This coil is sized to warm up air being cooled by the unit (as it defrosts) to a temperature close to 72*F and yes, it means that for a short time you'll be running both heating and air conditioning at the same time. But only for as long as it takes the outdoor coil to defrost. Then the unit will revert to whatever mode is being called for.

(Note that this sequence is a function of the heat pump itself and not a function of the thermostat.)

This is also why a heat pump is a really really good choice for some climates, and not a good choice for others. If you only have a few days where it's cold enough outdoors to eliminate a heat pumps ability to shed it's excess heat (cold), you're fine. But in climates where it's below 50*F for a long time during winter and the shoulder seasons, it's often beneficial to have another primary source of heat that uses the most efficient fuel (natural gas or ???) instead of relying on the electric strip heat. This is why, in homes that are in cooler climates, you often see a heat pump's interior coil built into a forced air furnace, instead of into it's own cabinet for example. And (at the danger of over simplifying) in these situations there's an Outdoor Air temperature sensor that switches a homes primary heating source from the heat pump to the furnace as it gets colder outdoors.

I know - probably WAY more than you wanted to know!

Rob

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#20

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Jim Dillon

>Rob,

Many, many thanks for taking the time to flesh-out your original post. I really enjoy learning how things work the way they do, and your post sure helped me understand (well, sorta 8-)). And yes, we did get an auxillary heat strip, which fortunately, only seems to run when the house is quite cool and I am turning on the heat for the first time. All in all, we are pleased with our system.

Jim

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#21

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Barry Irby

>Riley, as lots of people have told you, most programable thermostats will do what you want. As a Home Inspector, I have witnessed a change in how people operate their houses over the last twenty years. It used to be the "norm" to set your heat at something like 68 to 72 Degrees and cooling may have been set at 78 to 80. So In winter, the house would be held near 70 and in summer closer to 80. 80 degrees, with the humidity reduced seemed to be quite comfortable when it ws 90+ and humid outside. Now what I see is people set the stat to "Hold 72" and leave it year round. Air conditioners are trashing themselves to death trying to keep houses to 72 when its really hot and humid outside.

My point is that if you get a programable stat suitable for your system, you could set the heat to 70 and the AC to 76 or 78 and the system would cycle back and forth as necessary. You may wish to look at shade screening on the east and west windows to reduce the unwanted gain. You have learned why it is better to have a house that has the long sides to the north and south and some thought given to the position of the glass and over hangs, etc. Much too long a topic for this areana.

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#22

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Larry Shapiro

>Hi Rob,

I failed to give some vital info it appears which is that I have Natural gas forced air furnace and a seperate A/C unit. Will this configuration still work with an Auto Thermostat? I'm fine with the deadband its the big swing I want to avoid.

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#23

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Larry Shapiro

>Thanks Barry,

The afternoon is brutal on the front of our house. If only I could get my shade tree to grow faster :-)

Larry

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#24

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Hi Larry - yes, it "should" work fine. In many applications like this the heat pump will only be used for air conditioning and not at all for heating. If so, a regular auto changeover t-stat will work fine, calling for the hp for AC, and the furnace for heat. But sometimes a system is set up to run in stages, meaning the heat pump MAY be used as first stage heating and the forced air furnace can then come on if low outdoor air temp reduces the efficiency of the heat pump. I have a hunch you may fall into this second category because you indicated you have electric strip heat.

Unfortunately there's no real way for me to know how the system was designed and if it was designed to operate using the second sequence of operations I mentioned, it may have some other switch-over controls behind the scenes. If I could, I'd understand what you have before you made changes.

See if you can contact the original installer, if only to have a phone conversation to see how they do things. You may be able to get a fast answer to help you figure out the best plan of attack.

Rob

Re: OT: Heating and AC Thermostats

#25

Howard is right

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We've all been there (first time parents) and we all pretty much act/think the same. And when an older parent tells us something like this, we're rightly a little skeptical and certainly don't want to take any chances.

Baby #1 - sterilize the pacifier for 20 minutes after it has dropped on the ground

Baby #2 - rinse the pacifier in the sink after it has dropped to the ground

Baby #3 - wipe the pacifier on your shirt after it has dropped to the ground

And of course Baby #3 grows up to be the healthiest, most well-rounded balanced child.

;) ;) ;) ;)

Happy Woodworking!