Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Table Saw Bite

Posts

Table Saw Bite

#1

Chet Kloss

Table Saw Bite

Chet Kloss

>Well, as difficult as it is to admit, and in spite of the fact that I take reasonable (but clearly inadequate) safety precautions, I had my first serious accident in the shop yesterday.

I was ripping an 8 foot long, 6 1/8 inch wide piece of 3/4" plywood into two 3 inch wide strips. I had just put in a rip blade and squared it to the table. Since it was up at full height, I lowered the blade to about 3/4" above the stock and began the cut. When I got to about a foot from the end of the I grabbed my push block and continued feeding the stock.

Then it happened...

For some reason, my push block (an 8" long, 3" high piece of 1/2" plywood with a little notch on the end) tipped to the left and my thumb crashed into the blade.

The blade cut through the middle of the nail on my right thumb and into the bone. Fortunately, it didn't cut all the way through. If it was just a bit lower it would have destroyed the joint.

So, what did I do wrong...

Well, as I reflect on the accident, three things stand out:

1. Blade too high over the stock. Though I had lowered the blade, it really could have been lower.

2. Used a Push block when my fingers would have been better. I had three inches between the blade and the fence and I could have easily used a hook grip to push the stock through safely.

3. My Push block was too narrow (and old). 1/2" plywood doesn't give a lot of surface area and since the side edges had rounded a bit over the years (10+), and given that it is 3 inches tall, it was just too tippy.

Please note that I purposefully left out the fact that I don't use a blade guard. Until I saw the new Unisaw blade guard, I considered all stock guards useless. I do use an after-market splitter.

So anyway, that's it. It was clearly my fault and I have paid a price for the knowledge. I hope that someone out there finds it valuable.

The good news is that the bone guy and my hand surgeon say in about a years time I'll be good as new (though it will look, well. let's say, unique). In the meantime I can still work in the shop and do my real job (though I wouldn't have minded a break from that...)

Perhaps it's time to re-consider a Saw Stop...

Regards,

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Table Saw Bite

#2

Ellis Walentine

Push sticks

Ellis Walentine

>Wow, Chet, sorry about your accident. I'm glad the prognosis is good. I hate to hear about mishaps like this. In hindsight they're all preventable.

We've had a lot of discussions over the years about push sticks, one not too long ago. Without seeing your push stick design, it seems to me that it may have instilled a false confidence. If tipping the block to the left puts your thumb in the line of fire, you need a taller push stick. I've always used one like the one in the sketch below. I usually make mine about 6"-8" tall and a foot long, but I have a lot of smaller ones for more delicate work. They put pressure down on the work while you push, and they keep your hand further from the blade.

Ellis


img

Re: Table Saw Bite

#3

Re: Push sticks

John E in SC

>I had the same thought - I have both kinds of push sticks, but the one like Ellis illustrated is the one I usually grab, and I think is an inherently safer design. You also get downward pressure, which, particularly for shorter pieces, keeps the board from riding up on the back of the blade and kicking back. Glad to hear it wasn't any worse. Thanks for posting - we can all learn from others mistakes.

Take care and heal fast,

John

Re: Table Saw Bite

#4

Re: Table Saw Bite

Craig in Silverdale

>I picked up two of the Grr-Ripper push blocks last year at the woodworkers show. Their a bit spendy, but what price safety. I really love them. Even if it does slip, my hand is still farther above the blade than it protrudes through the table. Sorry about your mishap. Seems the thumb usually pays the price. Mine was the pad of the thumb up through the bone. That was years ago. Good luck and have a speedy recovery.

http://www.microjig.com/GRR-Ripper.htm

Re: Table Saw Bite

#5

Re: Push sticks

Bart Leetch

>Sorry to hear about your injury.

I have a couple of push sticks like Ellis uses & I also have a set of 2 Grippers that I really like to use. Also I limit my blade protrusion to approximately 1/8" for the very reason your accident demonstrated.

Yes I've sliced into push sticks & even Grippers but I still have all my fingers.

�Used a Push block when my fingers would have been better. I had three inches between the blade and the fence and I could have easily used a hook grip to push the stock through safely.�

Oh & a 3" space between the blade & fence is still way to close you only need to have something go wrong (& you know all about that) & your hand is right there ready to by injured again & the saw is only to ready to accommodate you, it has no feelings one way or the other.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#6

JL

Sorry to hear about this - best wishes

JL

>for a more or less complete recovery. Maybe I should get some new push sticks and insist that they be used at the theatre also.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#7

Re: Table Saw Bite

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Hope you heal quickly and well. I've been bitten by my jointer, so I know how easily a routine operation can go sour. My injury was not too severe, with minimal permanent damage but a long recovery. Thanks for posting, we need the saftey reminder.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#8

Re: Push sticks

Dan Donaldson

>I use one similar to the one Ellis posted, plus I run it next to the fence and hook a finger or two over the ledge to help stabilize it a bit more. (bies fence)

Re: Table Saw Bite

#9

Re: Push sticks

Tom Rex

>My push block for my table saw is a foot long 2" X 6" with a notch cut in the bottom and the top.

That way I can use both sides of the push block.

How many times have you grabbed the push stick only to find that you have it upside down?

It's wide enough that it will not tip and it puts my hand well above the blade.

If the distance from the fence to the blade is less than 1 1/2" I let it cut the push block.

2X6's are pretty cheap.

And on top of that it is very comfortable.

My 2 cents.

T Rex in Tex

Re: Table Saw Bite

#10

Chet Kloss

Re: Push sticks

Chet Kloss

>Hi guys,

Thanks for all the kind words.

My push block is not that far from the one you show Ellis. I'm not sure what caused my force on the push stick to make it fall to the left but I don't think it would have been a problem if I had a thicker block. I could be wrong but it seems logical to me.

Either way, I'm making some new push blocks this weekend.

Back on the horse!

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Table Saw Bite

#11

Re: Push sticks

John K Jordan

>Could a wide push "stick" also have a tab that wraps over the fence so it slides along and cannot move otherwise? If possible I hook a finger over the fence when ripping to keep my hand close to the fence, but I've wondered about adding this to the stick. More like a sled, then, I guess.

JKJ

Re: Table Saw Bite

#12

Re: Table Saw Bite

Dan Mitchell

>Chet - Sorry to hear about your accident, sounds pretty painful, but also like it could have been a lot worse

I would be curious to know what kind of saw you were using. My last saw was a Unisaw (not the new one, of course) I agree with you, the guard was, if not an outright ill-designed after thought which clearly revealed what Delta thought of safety gear, it was at least a PITA to deal with. I use the much better designed guard & riving knife on my PM2000 with all but through cuts, or ones where the space between the blade & fence simply won't allow for it.

As others have said, I'm also a big fan of the GRRRIPPER, though at this point I only have one.

Dan

Re: Table Saw Bite

#13

Re: Table Saw Bite

David C. Lykins - Dallas GA - guitardude

>Been there done that, but I wasn't as fortunate as yourself. About four years agoe I was working around 7:00-7:30 at night, I was cutting a peice of maple for a guitar body. I was also using a buddies tablesaw "WITHOUT" the blade guard on it. Well, nicely cut the chunk of maple and reached over to move the other peice out of the way and that was all it took. I hardly even felt it, looked down and there was the end of my thumb on the table of the tablesaw. Needless to say what went through my mind........

Cut my left thumb completely off from the fingernail forward, they didn't want to re-attach the tip as they indicated that I'd have more issues with it since the nerve endings would never mend properly. Every day my thumb bothers me in some way or another and it still has a couple of small areas that are VERY sensitive to touch.

I'll NEVER use my tablesaw without the blade guard on.....

Re: Table Saw Bite

#14

Re: Push sticks

Brent in Montreal

>Hi Chet,

Sorry to hear of your accident. A couple of things occurred to me while reading your first post. Did you have adequate support under the ends of your piece? If not, possibly the added pressure trying to keep the sheet to the table, coupled with the rounded edges of your push stick, could have caused your leaning to the left. Another thing that hit me was how were you keeping the sheet to the fence? Were you using a featherboard or your left hand fingers to keep the piece against the fence? A featherboard set to tightly could cause you to push just that bit harder, which again could have caused the rounded push stick to tilt. Basically, what I'm saying is, the rounded push stick belongs in the round file.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#15

Chet Kloss

Re: Push sticks

Chet Kloss

>"Basically, what I'm saying is, the rounded push stick belongs in the round file."

Amen to that brother!

Re: Table Saw Bite

#16

Re: Table Saw Bite

Alex Grigoriev

>"I considered all stock guards useless".

This one time, it would be useful...

All safety things are useless. Except when they save your ass.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#17

Chet Kloss

Re: Table Saw Bite

Chet Kloss

>Hi Dan,

I have a Delta Contractors Saw that I bought new about 8 or 9 years ago. I've got the money saved for a new saw and I had been toying with the PM 2000 or the Saw Stop - but now the new Unisaw looks really good too. I'm looking at the possibility of a move in the next two months so I don't want to buy anything just yet (only to have to move it cross country).

With regard to the Gripper Push block, I actually own one. I've just never been comfortable using it. I find the wood ones (like Ellis showed) to be much more comfortable. But who knows, maybe I should re-visit the subject.

,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Table Saw Bite

#18

Chet Kloss

Re: You lost me there...

Chet Kloss

>With the Theatre reference...

Did I miss a joke somewhere??

,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Table Saw Bite

#19

Re: Table Saw Bite

Jim Dillon

>Chet,

Sorry to hear about your close-call to having a really serious injury, although what you went through sounds bad enough to me. I think your point #3 - too narrow a push stick was a key factor. My push sticks range from 1/4 inch to 3 inches wide. Even with my commonly used 3/4 inch wide plywood push sticks, I have had the push stick suddenly tip to the left (toward the blade) if I am not careful to keep the downward force exactly centered over the push stick. Less often, it has tipped to the right. Anyway, thanks for posting and heal fast!

Jim

Re: Table Saw Bite

#20

JL

Set building in a Theatre

JL

>I do a lot of set building in our local community theatre. We have an old Ohio Forge (think of a Grizzly contractor's saw) table saw.

Let it suffice to say that the blade gets abused and that safe practices are not always followed. I've got a pair of Grippers at home - I'm thinking the theatre should afford the same.

Re: Table Saw Bite

#21

Re: Table Saw Bite

Fred Davis

>Chet ,

now that you have had the incident and survived, it would be a good time to redesign your "push stick".

IF your fence will accommodate it , make a saddle out of 3/4" hardwood , using the wood for the top and right side.

If you make the top piece thicker , like a inch or so , then you can, using 1/4" Masonite, screw the left side to the top and when that eventually wears out , remove it and put on a new side.

Make the rear finger on the bottom edge a inch long , so that it will last longer.

If your hand is small enough that gripping that wide of a saddle is uncomfortable , attach a forward leaning handle to the top rear of the saddle.

All the best to your poor old thumb.

FredD