Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

Posts

Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#1

Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

Dan Mitchell

>Was just resawing some 3/4" x 3.5" poplar (see tragic post below for outcome) on my new Grizzly 14" bandsaw. I'm planning to use the bits for the bottom of a box I'm making, but the resaw part was as much for practice as anything else. Anyway, it smoked like hell. Smelled just like microwave popcorn (not my favorite). Is it supposed to do that? I'm using the OEM 6 TPI 3/8" blade. I've ordered some better blades from Hastings, including a 4 TPI 3/4" one I'm guessing would be more suited to this task, but I still haven't received them yet.

One question: Is there any chance the smoldering bits sucked up by my DC might set the contents of its bag on fire?

Dan

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#2

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popco

kirk constable

>OEM blade might be a factor... but is there any chance you had the blade on upside down? DAMHIK to ask...

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#3

Funny you should ask...

Dan Mitchell

>No the blade's right side up. I DID have a similar experience with my TS right after I got it though, and had put the blade on BACKWARDS.

Smokes like mad/not nearly as effective that way ;-)

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#4

Re: Resawing... long.

Tom MacGregor

>I bought a Grizzly GO555 14" bandsaw & like it, but the OEM blade was junk. A Suffolk Timberwolf resaw blade improved things dramatically. Double check all of your alignments and clearances - wheels, guides & etc. Use a fence that allows you to adjust for drift easily so you're not fighting the machine at all. Make sure you're not applying too much pressure and let the blade cut at it's own pace. My one complaint is that the model I got is slightly underpowered, but it's a home shop so speed isn't an issue. My DC is grounded & I would not allow any source of sparks to remain uncorrected. My small shop also contains two large fire extinguishes, one at each end. Compare the cost of extinguishers (good metal head models, not Walmart specials) against the value of your shop, what's in it & what's attached to it.

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#5

Ellis Walentine

Fire hazard!

Ellis Walentine

>Not to sound too alarmed, but fire is something I'm hypercautious about. I remember once many years ago when I was cutting plexiglas on the tablesaw. For whatever reason (too many teeth? slow feed speed?), the blade heated up and a couple flaming drips of plastic landed in the saw cabinet. A few minutes later, I got a whiff of smoke and found the fine sawdust smoldering. If I had left the shop before discovering it, there would most certainly have been a fire.

I guess the rule of thumb apropos of your experience is that smoking is not a normal by-product of cutting operations and should be corrected before proceeding. In the case of resawing, your 6-tooth blade is the most likely culprit. Those are meant for cross-cutting and scrolling in reasonably thin material. Try a 1/2" x 3-tooth blade and you will see a world of difference.

Ellis Walentine

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#6

6 tpi is your problem, explanation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Analogy: Have you ever force drilled a long hole in wood with a twist drill? The flutes become packed with chips, the drill heats up and it starts to wander off course. If you haven't, go try it so you can understand the fate of the fine toothed blade. If the gullet in front of the tooth becomes impacted with sawdust the same thing happens. Now imagine that tiny tooth having to travel 3.5" through the wood before it can eject its load of sawdust. It can't take much of a bite or it will clog, heat and wander.

For resawing choose the coarsest blade your saw will accommodate. Also, wider is better for stiffness. I never could successfully resaw on my 14" saw with a 1/4" blade even if it was 4 tpi. When I put a 1/2" 3 tpi blade on the saw it saws perfect. The bottom line is that blade width and tpi is vastly more important than what price you pay for the blade.

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#7

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popco

Ray Binnicker

>Dan,

Everything they said, especially about the 1/2", 3tpi blade. I vote for the silicon steel (low tension) blades. Your saw, decently tuned with one of these blades (Oh, and they aren't that costly; 25.00 )will do most, if not all your re-saw needs.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#8

bandsaw blade *LINK*

John K Jordan

>I too, prefer a 3tpi blade. For resawing, I like to put on a new blade (or resharpen) to make sure it's as sharp as possible.

Recommendations vary on the number of teeth, but it is often suggested to have no more than 6-10 teeth in the wood at one time. I think the problem is not so much the number of teeth but the size of the gullet that removes the sawdust. With 6tpi, the gullets are too small and the sawdust will cause the blade to bind in the cut and burn the wood. This can ruin the blade as well and stress the saw. This is a real problem when resawing very wide lumber or cutting green logs for turning blanks. I often cut 12" lumber on my 14" Delta with riser and usually use 3tpi which would put 36 teeth in the wood. This works OK if I don't try to cut too fast. Sometimes I modify a blade as per Brian Hahn and break/grind off every other tooth for a 1.5tpi blade and that cuts better.

You can buy blades made specifically for resawing. For good advice, blades, and parts, try calling Itura Design (888-722-7078), widely acknowledged as bandsaw experts.

As per the 3/4" blade, I don't think I would use it. Regardless of what the manufacturer says and even if they do put a 3/4" mark on the tension gauge, 3/4" may be too much blade for your saw - it is for mine. The problem is in the tensioning. Tension is in pounds tension per square inch of blade crossection, regardless of the size of the blade. To properly tension a 3/4" blade will likely require more tension than your saw (and mine) may be able to support. If you do not tension enough, the blade can bow and destroy the resaw. If your tension spring is strong enough to tension properly (unlikely), a lot of stress is applied to the saw frame, bearings, wheels, the tension screw threads, and other components and can likely cause damage and premature failure. I purchased an extra strong tension spring for my bandsaw and a top-of-the-line Starrett tension gauge because I was tired of guessing at the tension. I found that I could not properly tension a 3/4" blade without feeling I was about to overstress the saw. I gave up on 3/4" blades and now stick to 1/2" for almost everything.

The idea that a wider blade will help keep the cut straighter doesn't entirely make sense. I think what keeps the cut straight is the alignment of the saw, the fence, blade sharpness, proper tension, and the operator. If you call Iturra, ask about using the wide blades.

JKJ


resawing info

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#9

Fully Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#10

Re: Resawing... long.

Dan Mitchell

>I dumped the DC bag last night in the container at the curb, fortunatley today was pickup day.

I definitely need to add some fire extinguishers. Also need to ground the DC.

Dan

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#11

Re: Fire hazard!

Dan Mitchell

>I think this OEM blade is junk, it even smells a little hot on less demanding tasks. I have set the guide rollers, but I do need to make one of those jigs to make sure the wheels are coplanar.

I did order a 3tpi 3/4" from Hastings for resawing, should be much better.

Thanks for the reply.

Dan

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#12

Re: 6 tpi is your problem, explanation

Dan Mitchell

>I have a 3tpi on the way, can't wait to try it!

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#13

Re: bandsaw blade

Dan Mitchell

>JKJ - Thanks for the in-depth reply. My particular 14" is pretty beefy, the model G0457. For instance, it comes with a 2 HP motor. I'm hoping the saw will tolerate a 3/4" blade, since I have one on the way, I guess we'll see ;-)

Thanks including that link, looks like there's some great info there!

Dan

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#14

How to test resawing

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If at the end of your cut gobs of sawdust fall out of the kerf it shows that the teeth didn't rake it out of the kerf because their gullets were clogged. The cause was teeth too small for the feed rate and it can lead to blade heating and wandering. So even with a 3tpi blade you can clog gullets if you feed too fast.

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#15

Re: Fire hazard! *LINK*

Curly Smith

>Your blade may or may not be junk but it is dull -- hot blades become dull very quickly. Before you consign it to oblivion, try sharpening it with the easy steps listed in the link.


How to Easily Resharpen Bandsaw Blades

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#16

Re: bandsaw blade

John K Jordan

>Dan,

I forgot to mention one thing. If sawing green wood or wood with sap or pitch, the blade may get gummed up on the side. For me, this ALWAYS happens on the inside, the tire side of the blade. This causes increased friction and heat, poor cutting, and wandering and bowed blade. I do have brushes on both wheels and a vacuum connected right below the table but the stick dust still gets compacted on the tires and blade.

Some people recommend spraying the blade with Pam or something similar to prevent buildup. This didn't work for me. What I do is keep an eye on it and clean as necessary, even in the middle of a cut. I use a piece of 1/4" square brass tubing and push it against the side of the blade while running. This will clean off most of the gunk and the brass will not hurt the blade teeth if accidentally contacted there. For stubborn gunk I use a small flat-bladed screwdriver. This requires caution to keep from touching the teeth and destroying the sharpness. This procedure is not recommended for someone with shaky hands. BTW, I do the same thing with a big screwdriver at my bandsawmill (from behind) when cutting particularly sappy pine that even a heavy stream of water won't keep off.

You still may want to call Iturra for advice and to check their blade prices. I never ordered blades from them before yesterday but they carry a wide variety at good prices. They carry the popular WoodSlicer blade which is very popular for resawing. Note that Highland Hardware has a tradmark on the "WoodSlicer" blade but the Bladerunners that Iturra sells are the same blade from the same production line.

You happen to live anywhere near E.TN? If so, drop by and I'll throw a poplar log or cant on the sawmill and in five minutes cut you more thin boards than you can use in a year. Poplar dries very quickly and almost always without warp if the tree is not too small and pretty straight. I've cut boards as thin as 1/4" when shaving something to size and I know of others who have cut much thinner. (It's sort of a contest with sawmill operators.)

JKJ

Re: Is resawing supposed to smell like burnt popcorn??

#17

Thanks for the great offer...

Dan Mitchell

>We live in the Seattle area, so it might be a bit of a drive ;-)

I appreciate all the terrific info, John.

Dan