Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Wood ID / Confirmation?

Posts

Wood ID / Confirmation?

#1

Wood ID / Confirmation?

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hello,

My wife and I recently visited Vermont (Manchester area) and we were staying at my Boss's house. I noticed he had downed a few trees. I can't say how long the pile of logs had been there. As a possible Christmas gift and thank you for letting us stay there, I brought a log home that sounded solid upon thumping it with a hammer. (very high tech stuff) I checked as best I could for cracks, splits, etc.

I think this log is from a Maple tree. I didn't have any leaves to post, sorry. Anyway, after halving the log and taking a thin slice, I noticed some radial cracks. I started second guessing myself on whether I should risk turning this. The sample is laid out on a Maple cutting board I am working on. It looks similar to it. I'll post a couple of PICS.

Questions:

1) What kind of wood does this look like to all of you?

2) Should I turn it?

Thank you,

Ray


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#2

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation? #2 

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#3

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation? #3 

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#4

Sorry gang, I should've posted on 'Turning'

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I'll post over there too. Unless of course, the "powers above" can move this thread over to 'Turning'...........:-)

My apologies,

Ray

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#5

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

Ronald

>Looks alittle like butternut to me? And yes i would turn it.

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Doesn't look like maple

Ellis Walentine

>The rings are too distinct and the color is too dark. Plus, the bark looks like butternut and so does the wood. If you cut that slice off the end of the log, the radial checking you see might not extend much further up the log. I'd take another couple slices and see if the check gets smaller or disappears. If it does, paint it right away with Anchorseal or melted paraffin.

Butternut makes lovely salad bowls.

Ellis

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Not sure, myself... *LINK*

Dale Lenz

>but if it's butternut the log(s) will have a chambered pith as in the picture, in the link below. Dale


Chambered pith

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#8

Re: Doesn't look like maple - Thanks to..

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>everyone who posted. The dark color seems to be from, lack of a better word, oxidation or aging. Kind of like when maple gets that grayish-graphite look in some spots. Maybe I'm thinking of Birch....??? Whom I'm kidding, I'm no expert. :-)

I would have never guessed butternut and I am still cautious / curious about proceeding with this log.

Maybe I can get a mini bowl or cup out of what's salvagable.

Thanks again,

Ray

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#9

Looks like soft maple

JohnM in mid-Mich------WebKitFormBoundary+2yQJLsB2

>Maybe silver or red. I've seen it get a bit dark as it dries/ages. Just a thought.

John