Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

Posts

White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#1

White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

Randy Stukenberg

>I have some white oak (actually burr oak) that has been air drying for a little over a year now. Most of it is qtr. sawn, 4/4 & 5/4, a few 4x4's as well. I need to make a 4' x 8' table for our local Hospice house. Should I get it kiln dried, or will it be stable enough now after 13+ months of air drying? It will be a trestle style table with a qtr. sawn top. The wood was dried under roof, loosely covered with a tarp to keep rain off, but plenty of air flow otherwise.

Thanks!

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#2

an unanswerable question and why

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Ideally, when you build the table the wood should be at the mid range of the moisture content that it will experience during its life as a table. The is the target the furniture factories use with success in shipping their product across the land. To answer your question would require knowing the humidity conditions where the table is going to live as well as the current moisture content of the lumber(which is easy to measure reliably with a scale and oven).

To make some guesses:

In your favor is that the lumber is quarter sawn, which is the most stable configuration. Not in your favor is that oak does not dry as fast as most furniture wood. Unknown is how you intend to use the lumber. Some table constructions will be more forgiving than others. Also unknown is where you live, for this will determine how dry it is now and how dry it needs to be.

Recommendation: bring a piece into your house, if you have the heat on or the humidity is otherwise low , and lay it on the floor somewhere. If it hasn't warped up in a few days it may be ok. Or, measure the moisture content. If it is more than 12% you are at great risk. In my climate I would not use it over 10%. When you plane a piece, if the shaving feel damp or they smell "raw" don't risk using it.

If it is too wet and the heat is on, bring it into the house and stack it under the bed, behind the sofa or in the spare bedroom for a couple of weeks, or in the shop if the shop has low humidity.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#3

Re: an unanswerable question and why

Randy Stukenberg

>I am located in Northern Illinois, 90 mi. west of Chicago. Logs were sawed in August '07, dry fall, cold winter, average rain this summer.

The top will be simple - 4' wide, 8' long, edge glued, no breadboard ends.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#4

Re: an unanswerable question and why

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>You need to get a moisture meter. Most commercial white oak is first air dried then put in a kiln to bring it down to 6-8% MC. There are a lot of good books and USDA Forrest Service Wood Products Laboratory pubs out there on wood behavior and drying wood. Google Dr.Eugene Wengert.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#5

Kirkland?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Just curious if that's where you got your lumber. We former Ponders had a couple of visits to the mill there several years ago.

My son lives fewer than a dozen (crow) miles from it, now, in Belvidere.

Rod

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#6

moisture meter is unnecessary

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, let me admit that Alton Brown is my cooking hero and I subscribe to his philosophy that tools should be multitasking, in the kitchen or in the shop.

The most reliable means of determining moisture content(MC) is by drying to constant weight. One will need an accurate scale, like a scale used to reliably measure components for cooking, especially baking, or a postal scale.

Weigh a test piece, put in oven at 220 F and dry for an hour. Take out and weigh. Repeat until the test piece doesn't loose any more weight. Total weight loss divided by dry weight X 100 is the percent moisture content. Spectacular smoke events can be experienced doing the heating in the microwave. I have been banned from using it, but I am allowed to use the oven.

So instead of buying a moisture meter, which can be unreliable at low moisture levels, buy a multitasking scale instead, and for less money.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#7

you are in no man's land

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your construction is favorable, your climate is not. I can't predict if your lumber will work without further drying. I fear it is not, or at least I would not risk it. Move it indoors for a while where the humidity is lower to be sure it is dry.

The peril of assembling if it is not sufficiently dry is that the glue joints will take days to dry to full strength, the top may cup and/or the ends could check. The ends will definitely check if it is too wet and it gets moved to where it dries quickly. If the lumber is too wet, the joints will break if the top is constrained so it can't shrink after assembly. A cup is the least problem, as once dry the cup can be pulled flat on the table frame.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#8

oven drying

John K Jordan

>For the most accurate results, don't cut a piece off the end of a board where the moisture will certainly be lower.

Info from Dr Wengert as in the knowledgebase on the Wood Web: Cut a piece the full width and thickness of a board but just one inch along the grain. The piece should be free of knots, cracks, bark, edge splinters, loose slivers. Weigh the piece immediately to the nearest 1/100th of a gram to get the wet weight. Write that weight on the sample. Heat to around 215 deg F in an oven until the weight no longer changes. This will often take 24 hours but can be longer, seldom is shorter. A convection oven works best. Write down the oven dry weight. Subtract the two, multiply by 100, and divide by the dry weight to get the MC.

I have used the microwave oven for this and have never burned the wood. I used a low power setting and took the wood out of the oven each time to cool and disperse the moisture then weighed on a triple-beam balance. I heated for just a few minutes at a time but it took many cycles. Dr Wengert suggests heating 20 minutes at a time at 200 watts power. High power and long times will certainly convert some wood to charcoal or ashes and ruin the test. I know other people who have been banned from the kitchen for this. An inexpensive microwave oven in the shop could serve multiple functions.

A meter is a lot quicker. The accuracy is good unless the moisture is very low, but drying to below 7% is uncommon. I use a good pinless meter and it works well unless the wood is too thick, but even then it gives me a rough idea of the drying progress. I think a meter is a good tool to have around a shop if you work with green and air-dried wood. I justified mine as a necessary accessory to my sawmill.

JKJ

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#9

Ellis Walentine

It's not dry enough

Ellis Walentine

>That's my gut reaction; I'll be contrite if proven wrong. I agree with everything you've been told here, but never in my experience has wood left in an unheated outbuilding in a temperate climate zone stabilized at a MC I would use for furniture unless it was outdoor furniture. Whether you use a meter or the drying/weighing methods discussed here, I predict you will find the MC to be in the 12% - 14% range. Put it up in the rafters of your garage or attic or in a solar lean-to for a couple weeks to stabilize at a lower MC. Don't forget to use sticks to separate the layers and allow for air flow. A fan will help expedite matters.

Let us know what you find out about the moisture content.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#10

Re: It's not dry enough

Dick Coers

>I agree with Ellis. I don't think anyone has brought up the fact of how difficult it is to dry white oak. It's even tougher as quartersawn. The good condition you have is that almost any heat will not bother it now. We don't have a lot of good attic drying left in IL., but there probably is enough. If you get it up in the attic for a month or so it will probably be okay.

All that said, I am a fan of using air dried wood. I've had very good luck with coffee tables, end tables, and beds. I just build with the idea that sucker is really going to shrink that first winter.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#11

Re: Kirkland?

Randy Stukenberg

>these logs actually came from near Byron - about 25 miles west of Kirkland. they were sawed onsite with a portable sawmill.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#12

Looks like a trip...

Randy Stukenberg

>to my local sawmill to put it in the kiln. I need to have the table done by Jan. 1. The mill said 6-8 weeks which will give me just enough time to get it home and build a table.

Thanks for the advice. I will let you know what the starting MC was.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#13

Re: moisture meter is unnecessary

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>The oven method is fine and accurate, if a bit time consuming and a little complicated and . . . . if you are drying a quantity of your own wood and you can cut it up to cook and weigh samples. But, if you don't own the wood and/or are headed out to look at some air dried wood for sale, you won't likely take your microwave and scales. In that case a moisture meter is a much better option. You can get a simple, accurate pin type for likely what it will cost for an appropriately accurate scale.

Re: White oak: Air dry vs. kiln dry

#14

Right on the money

Randy Stukenberg

>Ellis, you wre right on. The 4/4 boards were at 13%, thicker stuff at 14%. They said I should have it by mid-late November. Then the real work begins!