Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT - eBay feedback changes

Posts

OT - eBay feedback changes

#1

OT - eBay feedback changes

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I'm posting this here because I know we've had some good conversations on this topic several times in the past.

I just saw that eBay has changed their Feedback Rating system. I went to leave positive feedback for a seller on an item I bought recently and saw this message:

"Important changes to Feedback : Buyers, you can no longer receive negative or neutral Feedback from sellers. You should leave honest and accurate Feedback without the fear of receiving negative or neutral ratings."

That's very interesting. It looks like they are trying to solve the Seller Bullying that happens so much.

Happy Woodworking!


img

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

#2

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>As primarily a seller on eBay I feel it is totally stupid to allow buyers to leave negative feedback and not allow sellers to do so.

I am lucky and deal mostly with woodworkers in most of my transactions on eBay and as we all know they are almost all very honorable, trustworthy people who make the transactions enjoyable.

But occasionally I list non woodworking items and on a few occasions I have encountered deadbeats and idiots.

To solve the problem I leave positive feedback but add the comment "Positively a deadbeat".

I have never bullied anybody with the threat of negative feedback and it the past rather then leave negative feedback I would leave none.

Under this new system I will get my pound of flesh any way possible.

"Do unto others, as you would have them do to you"

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

#3

Re: feedback changes on eBay

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>As a person who has bought and sold on eBay I find that both parties should have a say in the overall transaction. Why limit it to positive, neutral and / or negative.

Personally, if you don't have anything nice to say, than do't so it. Why not take the "opinion" or message option out and go with standardized questions based on a 1-10 scale with 10 being the best.

Ray

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

#4

why have feedback at all?

john in NM

>Ebay is pretty stupid anyway, far to complex for what it needs to be. A friend of mine had an ebay store selling metal forming tools he made. Ran a couple auctions figuring it would be a loss leader to get people into the store. Auction items sold for more than the store items. I don't think anyone would pay more if they'd looked at all the links, visited the store, etc, etc. I've also had a lot of trouble figuring out how to view completed auctions. I'm sure there's a way, its just not intuitively obvious to me.

By comparison, I've had several very successful auctions on a site that is specific to firearms - which ebay forbids. That site is simple and obvious. They don't appear to have feedback wars and attempts at intimidation, though I do see negative feedback left now and then. Perhaps the site admins take a more active role. Perhaps everyone there is just trying really hard not to emulate ebay.

I'd like to see more independent special interest auction sites like this. Maybe one for tools, one for antiques, one for car parts, whatever.

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

#5

Re: OT - eBay feedback changes

Tom

>That change came about some time ago. Along with that change, there was a very highly publicized lowering of their initial fees. You had to search real hard to find the fact that they also raised there final value fees to more than make up for it. Because of that, I rarely use ebay now. As for the feedback, people seem to think that only sellers are dishonest. I've had 3 cases of buyers wanting their money back for things that I know were new and/or in working condition when shipped. When it comes to computer components, I think there are a lot of people that buy without checking to see if the part is compatible, or don't know how to install it. As a seller, I see no reason why a buyer should be allowed to get their $ back for either of those cases. Selling on ebay is my last resort now. I used to do it fairly often. I buy occasionally though. As a matter of fact, I just left negative for a seller who wasn't happy with the final price in an auction and just didn't ship the item...so I waited and waited...and finally got an email that my $ was being refunded.