Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Usability of White Alder

Posts

Usability of White Alder

#1

Usability of White Alder

Dan Mitchell

>I have a tree growing on my property in a precarious place on a hillside, leaning quite a bit. I'm thinking of removing it. Leaves are pictured below. From doing a bit of searching, it appears to be a white alder. If I'm right about the species (Alnus rhombifolia) it's a member of the birch family. Tree is about 12" in diameter at its widest point near the ground, I'd estimate about 45' tall, trunk is very straight, with small lateral branches. I'm wondering if the wood is of any woodworking use. Seems like it could be worth resawing into boards. This would be my 1st such experience. Any thoughts?

TIA

Dan


img

Re: Usability of White Alder

#2

Re: Usability of White Alder

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Never heard of white alder, but that's not to say it's not a tree. I've heard of red alder though, and it's one of my favourite woods to work with. It machines beautifully, takes paint well, finished fine clear and is very stable. It also grows like weeds out here. In fact it's considered one.

If the tree is leaning (and a lot of alders are), the wood is probably reaction wood, meaning the underside of the lean has grown while in compression, and the top side wile it's in tension. When you cut the tree into boards, it'll tend to undo this injustice and the boards may well pretzel on you. Or not. But generally, as a rule, leaning alders become firewood (and they make fantastic firewood!)

Rob

Re: Usability of White Alder

#3

Ellis Walentine

I'd pass, unless... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>... you want to practice your resawing technique. White alder's only commercial value is reported to be firewood. I also have doubts about your ID. White alder leaves are usually between 2 1/2" and 4" long, and the tree is usually multi-stemmed.

Even if the tree happens red alder, you won't get much yield from a 12" diameter tree, and alder is a bland-looking, soft, weak wood, with low stiffness and durability. It is used as a secondary wood in furniture, particularly production furniture from the West Coast, but it is not generally prized for its appearance.

Ellis Walentine, Host


http://hort.ufl.edu/trees/ALNRHOA.pdf

Re: Usability of White Alder

#4

JL

Thank you for the tree ID link. *LINK*

JL

>That is a nice collection of fact sheets just above that.


U FL Tree Fact Sheets

Re: Usability of White Alder

#5

Re: Usability of White Alder *LINK*

Scott in MN

>Check this link out and work through the questions.


Tree ID

Re: Usability of White Alder

#6

Re: I'd pass, unless... *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>I do think the tree is an alder. I had gotten my ID from an Oregon State University site, link below. I was leaning toward white alder because the site says the red's leaf edges are rolled, which these are not. The leaf size is more suggestive of red, however.

Below is a pic of the cones, which also match the OSU site's description/images.

Also, regionally (Seattle area) it fits.

I was intrigued when I say alder was a member of the birch family, and my understanding is that red alder does produce a usable hardwood, used in flooring, among other things. I wonder if there is a definitive way to distinguish the red from the white. If it were red, would it be worth fooling with for furniture purposes?

Thanks all for the replies.

Dan


img

http://oregonstate.edu/trees/broadleaf_genera/spec

Re: Usability of White Alder

#7

Re: I'd pass, unless...

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>What's interesting is I grew up thinking all the alders around are red alders. Now I find out that they're all white alders. I'm not sure it really matters though, as long as the tree is millable.

Alder IS being used a lot more. It's still got it's place as a secondary wood (it's used a lot for couch frames etc.) and I'm sure it always will. It's also being used a lot more for flooring, and for cabinets, either in clear form, or knotty form. Ive made several projects out of it and when you want a project to be about the project and not the wood, it's one of the better choices. It's not a good choice for outdoor projects though, but for home-grown millwork etc. it's a very good alternative to poplar.

In terms of density, it runs about 33lb/cubic foot which makes it a medium density hardwood. And while not as hard as some woods (on the Janka scale it runs at 590 compared to 660 for Doug. fir), I've never found it's "softness" to be a problem (pick your projects for it). As indicated, as a species it's prone to reaction wood, but if you get a straight tree the wood mills and dries very nicely. And it's extremely nice wood to work either with machine tools or hand tools. It's sawdust is benign and there's no odor to the wood once it's dried (it has a faint but distinctive odour when it's fresh cut and dripping wet green)

Alder has it's place in the woodworking world. It's not an oak, or a maple or a cherry. But it's economical, it's plentiful, it's versatile and it's a completely sustainable fast growing product that's suitable for many building projects; either as a primary wood or as a secondary wood. Don't be so quick to knock it.

And when it's green, you can stack three rounds on top of each other and split all three with one axe blow. :)

Rob

Re: Usability of White Alder

#8

Alder and price

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>Knotty Alder (the old #4 firewood grade) seems to have become the darling of the designers. About half the high end homes in last summer local tour had Knotty Alder cabinets. Locally Alder is more expensive than Red Oak of the same grade. go figure

Personally I like to work with Red Alder, for all the reasons Rob mentioned, plus the scraps go in the BBQ

glc

Re: Usability of White Alder

#9

Rob, You've Enhanced Its Alder Ego..

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Usability of White Alder

#10

Re: Alder and price

Dan Mitchell

>Yeah, in researching this I've seen mentioned Alder is great for smoking meat.

And the tree in question stands only a few feet from my BBQ...

Re: Usability of White Alder

#11

Re: cuz alder other woods are too expensive!

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>

Re: Usability of White Alder

#12

Yikes! Colonel outpunned, history is made

John K Jordan

>