Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

helical cutters

Posts

helical cutters

#1

helical cutters

mike mcnerney

>I did a search but one question still remains. If one of these is installed on a thicknesser, how thin can you go on fiqured hardwoods.

I am hoping to make it to 1/8 " or less?

Mike McNerney, Ottawa

Re: helical cutters

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: helical cutters

Ellis Walentine

>Mike, I don't think you'll get anything but a wild guess on this question. When wood gets that thin, it is subject to all kinds of things that could blow up your prized workpiece. I used to keep an Inca jointer/planer with carbide knives for gnarly and thin woods. At 7000rpm with straight knives, it routinely planed rosewood and curly maple to less than 1/8", but when it caught some uphill grain, all bets were off. More than a couple pieces never made it through.

Helical heads have carbide cutters, which I regard as part of the success story. I think the final verdict will depend on the cutterhead rpms as well. And, not being a helical head user myself, I don't know that I could even give you a percentage of your chances of thinwood success.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: helical cutters

#3

Need more than rpm...

HC Sakman

>Hi Ellis, Mike,

I use Byrd Shelix in my MM FS-30 and regularly plane very figured and/or dense exotics down to 3/32"+ (>2 mm.) with success 98% of the time. There are a few boards that only an infill or sander can deal with. That's inevitable.

So, the answer to your question is: Yes, Helical head works wonders in my planer with stock thickness from >1/8" to 8".

FS-30 has an adjustment for feed roller pressure and I reduced it to prevent marking the wood with infeed/outfeed rollers when making very light cuts. When the pressure is medium, success rate of planing thin stock goes up without marking the surface with feed rollers when taking 1/64" off.

Besides that, some planers' feed rollers are closer to the cutterhead and/or have spring loaded chipbreakers to push down the wood, thus preventing thin stock getting chewed up. I think this design feature is the key for planing thin stock with no problems. More important than rpm/hp etc. (Although I know where you're coming from with "rpm" issue Ellis. It's a valid point. Too slow may cause tear out, too high may cause flutter, lift and sudden death of a board!)

e.g. Dewalt 733/734 (old design) planes thin stock better than Makita 1012. Dewalt 735 is even better. (From personal experience w/ lunchbox planers.)

Also by experience, General 130 planer is good planing down to 1/8" but MiniMax FS-30 is better.

Unfortunately one will not know this configuration unless the planer is used for planing thin stock.

Chico...

Re: helical cutters

#4

Ellis Walentine

Other keys to success

Ellis Walentine

>The infeed roller on my old Inca jointer-planer was very close to the cutterhead, so there wasn't much unsupported stock to catch and blow up as it reached the knives. Good point.

I still think that higher cutterhead rpms improve the chances of success and the quality of the surface. Hand-in-hand with that would be feed speed. The slower the feed speed and the higher the rpm, the smaller the bite and the less wrenching shock to the wood surface. While I'm on a roll here, I might as well mention slightly dull knives work better for me than sharp ones. When I switched to carbide-tipped knives, which don't take or hold as sharp an edge as tool steel, my success rate went way up.

Anecdotes, to be sure.

Ellis

Re: helical cutters

#5

Re: Other keys to success

mike mcnerney

>yes, dull knives, that makes me think of back bevelled knives where the angle of attack is almost 90 de. to the surface of the stock; more like a scraping action. I've just got a delta lunch box planer so on one hand it seems crazy to buy a head that cost nearly twice as much as the planer and on the other I think it's a virtual miracle the

machine does such a great job at such a low price. Kind of like hamburger, it just never got that expensive when you count inflation.

Mike mcnerney