Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Posts

Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#1

Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Barry Irby

>I have been using a router to cut oak flooring to make patches. Made a template I can kneel on that allows me to cross cut the flooring so I can "tooth" the floor back together with staggered joints. I have trashed two carbide 1/4" bits at $14 each hitting nails. So I went to Harbor Freight and bought 3 packs of spiral bits for $6.79. (HF did not have single or family packs of regular bits.) They are HSS and about 3" long with about half of it fluted and 1/4" in diameter. I don't have experience with spiral bits. Are they prone to break? I am making three passes of a 1/4" depth each time, not trying to cut the full 3/4" floor in one pass.

Should I set the bit deep into the collet? Or just up to the flutes? Seems that deeper would support the shank better, but the flutes might damage the collet.

If one breaks, do they fly around like bullets or just snap and sit there.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#2

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

john lucas

>Barry I would not bury them in the collet. You want the full round support of the collet to prevent slipping. I've never had one break but have broken a number of drill bits. They just stop as soon as they break. I would be nervous about a panel raising bit breaking but not small spiral bit.

The only problem I've had with HSS spiral bits it that they get dull and then you have to force the cut which heats the bit up. It won't hurt the bit it's just annoying. That's why I changed to Carbide bits.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#3

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Some things to think about, Barry. Based on my personal experience only.

The less total length of the bit past the collect reduces the chance of snapping one. Less leverage.

Collects are consumable items on a router. About $20. You'll just have to deal with it.

HSS is not carbide - much 'softer.' May only trash the bit without snapping it when you hit the nails.

Where will it go when it breaks? Anywhere it wants to. Think shrapnel. I've only ever gotten hit by one. It nailed me in the leg. I was wearing Levi's. Still needed a band aid on the scratch. Makes a lovely argument for a leather work apron! Or chain saw chaps. :-)

I've commented on some of your concerns. I think the underlying concern was, "Is there another way anyone would recommend?" Sorry, can't help you there.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#4

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Jim Dillon

>Barry,

I think you hit the nail on the head (couldn't resist) when you say the bit breaks when it hits a nail. IMHO, that is probably something to avoid 8-). I use spiral bits, whenever I can, varying in diameter from 1/4 to 1/2 inch. I actually broke the tip on my most expensive carbide 1/2 inch bit doing a plunge cut into some jatoba. Made a loud noise and I never found the smaller piece. For that reason, I ALWAYS wear safety goggles (nice ones that came with my pneumatic nailer) when I use the router - either handheld or in the table. Returning to your question, except for that one incident, I've had good luck with my spiral bits (mostly CMT, Whitesides HSS and carbide). But then I've never tried to rout nails either 8-).

Jim

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#5

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Yonak

>Barry, I've had them snap while routing and they never flew .. no place for them to go, really. I, personally, would feel safe routing in a material which is securely anchored.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#6

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Barry, try using a metal detector and mark the floor with some chalk where the nails are... first...then gouge the nails out as best you can.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#7

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Follow-up....after you mark the location of a nail, run the router around the location down to the underfloor and then you can see the nail head and do what is necessary to remove it without damaging the boards that are going to stay in place.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#8

Thanks Everyone, And about that metal detector

Barry Irby

>I considered a metal detector, but I don't have one. I'm working on 2 1/4" oak flooring that is nailed at random. Blind nailed in the edge. Under it is the 1 X 6 diagonal sheeting boards, but the nails in those were fairly predictable, into the joists. I'm just not sure the metal detector could be accurate enough to sort out all the nails. OTOH, If I had one, I would try it, but since I don't, I will throw cheap router bits at the problem. I have to tooth out the ends of flooring all the way across a 13' wide room.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#9

I am worried about "whip"

Barry Irby

>I started with a carbide tipped bit that had about an inch of cutting length. Since I was cutting through 3/4" flooring I though I needed more than 3/4" of cutting edge, but it has occurred to me that I am doing it in three passes of about a 1/4" each. So a bit with a half inch or even three eighths might be good enough. I am concerned that the first 1/4" of the bit will get dull, because that part will do essentially all of the cutting. As the bit gets dull, the side to side pressure will increase to make the bit cut. That's where the whip comes in. We shall see.

It did dawn on me that the cross section of a spiral bit may be stronger than a straight bit, just curved.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#10

Re: cheap metal detector

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I got one at Toys'r'Us for around $10 a few years ago. Prbably $20 now, but still...

Works just fine on wood.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#11

Re: Thanks Everyone, And about that metal detector

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Barry, isn't there a Harbor Freight store near you? I found five detectors at a very reasonable price you could buy. Seems to be a lot cheaper to buy one than to just go willy-nilly and ruin some router bits unnecessarily. Costs run from $10 to $50.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#12

Duhh!! Flash of Inspiration!!! Free!!!

Barry Irby

>Even before I opened your messages, I knew how to find the nails. I have several very powerful magnets left over from a project. All that is required is to slide them along the joints until they "jump" to the nail and sit there.

What bothers me about this is I have used them as a Home Inspector to prove or disprove that hardwood is nailed properly. Apparently that tidbit was in the Home Inspector file in my brain and not the Wood Worker section. Required Trashing two bits and trip to Harbor Freight and Wood Central to dredge it up. Age Related?

Thanks for all the help.

Re: Spiral Router Bit Questions.

#13

Re: Duhh!! Flash of Inspiration!!! Free!!!

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Agree...we all get the "DUHHH' at times