Stupid drill question
wilbur
>What's the difference between a drill/driver, impact driver, and hammer drill?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Stupid drill question
wilbur
>What's the difference between a drill/driver, impact driver, and hammer drill?
Re: Stupid drill question
JL
>IMO, when I think of Drill/Driver - I usually think of something like the Dewalt, Hitachi, or whatever - battery powered drill/drivers that are usually used to drill (rarely) or drive screws.
An impact driver (at least the ones I'm familiar with) - twists as you hit it. I.E. when you hit it on the striking point, it twists.
A hammer drill is a drill that is capable of delivering an impact as it rotates. My hammer drills can be switched from the hammer/drill function to just a drilling function by moving a switch.
My $0.02.
Re: Stupid drill question
Tom MacGregor
>The hand-held, hammer-struck impact driver is for breakinng loose stuck or rusted screws without having the bit "cam out" the slot and making drilling & extraction necessary.
The rapid impact/drill action of a hammer drill will penetrate concrete or masonry far faster & easier than a regular drill when setting anchors & etc.
Secondary question
wilbur
>Forgot to include this: does an impact drill, like the Panasonic, have enough oomph to drill holes in concrete/cinder block for anchors or screws (using an appropriate masonry bit, of course)?
The real low down: LONG
Grant in Iowa
>Drill Driver: A drill with a standard drill chuck that can not only drill holes, but is rated to have high enough torque and a low enough gearing to drive fasteners. This tool excels at drilling, but can also drive fasteners in the right hands. Tends to strip fastener heads when used on larger sized fasteners. More fatiguing when driving large fasteners. Can overheat when asked to drive large fasteners due to the high torque/ low RPM of the tool preventing effective cooling.
Impact driver: This tool looks like a drill, but that is where the similarity ends. These usually have a 1/4" collet system that receives specialized drill bits and fastener bits. Given a set of 1/4" hex drill bits, this tool can drill holes up to about 3/8" in diameter, but that is not the tools strong point. An impact driver is similar to the pneumatic impact wrenches that a mechanic uses. It rotates normally until a certain amount of resistance is met, at which time an internal mechanism begins hammering the bit in a rotary fashion. This motion is radial (or around and round), and differs from the motion a hammer drill makes, which is up and down. This tool excels at driving fasteners with less effort and tool wear than a drill/ driver. Indeed, I have seen a 12V impact driver drive screws faster than an 18V drill driver. When using one, you'll notice that they can develop a large amount of torque without placing the opposite amount of torque on the users arm. Further, the hammering action tends to reseat the bit in the screw upon each blow, which all but eliminates cam-out and greatly reduces the amount of pressure the user needs to place on the tool to keep the bit engaged. There are a number of tool bits and adapters available to allow the use of the tool on everything from automotive socket sets to torx, phillips, square drive, etc. When in operation on a large fastener, the trigger control can be held wide open, allowing the motor to run at full speed and proper cooling to take place. A judicious amount of trigger control allows the user to carefully drive small fasteners such as #6 screws, for example, without overtorquing. "The faster you run the tool, the more torque it develops". Current 12-14V models develop up to 80-90 foot pounds of torque and full speed....enough to work on cars or drive deck hardware.
Hammer Drill: Often a function that is combined with a larger drill/ driver, this feature allows the user to drill in masonry. As the name implies, the drill chuck vibrates or "hammers" up and down as the drill motor rotates the bit. This motion is sufficiently effective to drill up to about 3/4" holes in masonry for the installation of anchors or tapcon type fasteners.
If you are in the market for a new cordless tool, you should consider the work you will be doing with the tool(s). I suggest for most homeowners and woodworkers a Cordless drill/driver and Impact driver combination in about the 14V range. Kits are almost always available on Amazon for about $200 which have both...handy for when you need to drill a pilot hole and then drive fasteners because you have two tools so no bit changing will be needed. Makita, Milwaukee, DeWalt, and Bosch all make good quality combo kits for your consideration.
Hope that answered your question!
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
I should add....Follow up *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
>An impact driver can NOT drill holes in masonry effectively. Its hammering mechanism is a rotary hammering, while a hammers drills hammering motion is up and down to plinter and pulverize the masonry being drilled under the bit.
If I were to recommend a set of drills that can fill most do it yourself and light construction needs, I'd recommend the following three tools:
A combination impact driver and drill driver kit from Makita in either 12V or 14.4V cordless. These are very capable, yet light enough to provide the finesse needed when woodworking. Here's a link to the model I own... http://www.amazon.com/Makita-6935FDWDEX-14-4-Volt-Cordless-Fluorescent/dp/B000ASE2YM/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=hi&qid=1222452674&sr=8-1t
A heavy duty workhorse corded 1/2" variable speed high/ low range hammer drill. This is a lifetime tool in the right hands than can drill large holes through construction material and can drill up to about 3/4" holes in masonry. It can also be placed in low range to mix paint, drywall mud, etc: (see below link)
I am not affiliated with either company, just a happy owner!
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
Milwaukee 1/2" hammer drill
Re: Secondary question
John K Jordan
>I used to tryy drilling holes in masonry with a low-end drill driver. What a pain. Then I bought a professional grade hammer drill and there is NO comparison. It will drill a 1" hole better than the little drill with a 1/4" hole. I use both drill bits and chisels for drilling and cutting away concrete.
JKJ
Re: Secondary question
Dan Donaldson
>Wrong type of drill. An impact drill hammers in a rotary direction, think putting a tire iron on a lugnut and hammering on it to loosen the nut. A hammer drill is what you need for holes in concrete. It impacts the end of the bit like you would take a star drill and hit it with a hammer. Completely different types of impact.
One more tidbit
Barry Irby
>Grant 'plained it very well. The only thing he did not mention was the clutch mechanism on the Driver drill. This is a handy feature that allows you to set the amount off torque you want and the drill will slip at that point, limiting over driving or snapping off screw heads. If you have to drive thirty similar screws into similar wood, once you set the collar to what works, you can drive the rest of the screws with fair confidence you won't ring one off or drive it out of sight. This can be very handy. No such feature exists on the impact drivers, so, while they are wonderful for driving screws, you have to pay attention or you can drive the head a deck screw all the way through a deck board. Can be a problem if you zone out on the 999th screw.
I wondered what the No. 1 setting was for on the torque setting. You can stop it with your fingers. My electrician friend thinks that's the best one. Perfect for cover plate screws. Silly until you have to do house after house of them.
And they are all correct. Hammer drill for drilling concrete or masonry. Impact driver offers NO advantage over a regular drill for that. (I tried.)