Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Posts

Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#1

Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

charlie belden in san jose

>In an earlier thread about a table saw kick back I posted a link to some stuff I put together on the subject. I subsequently received an e-mail from a guy in Poland named Niki who noted that I'd overlooked the Long Fence vs Short Fence question (as well as the potential value of a blade guard).

Now one of the problems Euro table saws have in the United States market is the fact that most euro table saw fences are the "short" variety while in the U.S. the Long Fence comes standard and there are three or four after market fence systems - Beismeyer (sp?) being the perceived standard against which others are measured.

Niki questioned the assumption that, when it comes to table saw fences, longer is better. Just because something is familiar, doesn't make it better than other alternatives.

So what's your take on the Longer vs Shorted table saw fence? Is a short fence safer? If so why?

Attached is one type of table saw cut where the Short Fence is safer than a long fence. Can you think of some others?

The U.S. market table saws are FINALLY getting riving knives instead of the old Tried and True (though not as effective) splitter, with or without the PITA "anti-kickback pawls. Are you aware of any other safety features common to euro machines that haven't made it to U.S. market table saws?

charlie belden

ps. Niki in Poland - I accidently deleted your e-mail message. Please e-mail me again


img

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#2

Re: Lg Fence vs Shrt on T.S. - makes sense to me.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Good points Charlie.

Ray

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#3

Re: Lg Fence vs Shrt on T.S. - makes sense to me.

Chuck in ND

>If this is something that concerns you, a Unifence would be the solution. Interesting article though.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#4

long vrs short.

McKay Sleight

>I teach at a school where I have used almost every fence available. However, I personally use a long uni-fence in my own shop because I work alone and need to cut sheets of ply by myself. I pull the uni back so that I have a long edge to start the cut. When ripping solid lumber, the fence is set pretty well even with the front edge of the saw like a accufence/besimeyer etc. In my application, I do not care for a short fence because I want that stability when cutting.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#5

Another kickback potential

Curt Harms

>Have you ever ripped stock that turned out to be reaction wood, the kerf spreads as soon as it's cut? I have, and it pushes the piece between the fence and the blade away from the fence and into the rear of the blade. Not a good thing. Mule used to sell an add-on subfence which enabled a long fence to function as a short fence. It was a shorter 1" thick extrusion which can be positioned like a shorter fence. You could make up something to accomplish the same function but it should help prevent kickback from reaction wood. Another good option is to rip potential problem wood on a bandsaw which I've done more and more lately.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#6

JL

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

JL

>I use my fence for a number of things.

When I am rabbeting an edge, I put a sacrificial fence on my fence. This is easier to do (IMO) with a longer fence.

I have a number of jigs (tenon, beveling, etc.) which "ride" on my fence. I usually need a long fence to guide the jig. Sometimes follow-through is important.

As far as the kickback prevention? You may be right. I still like having a long fence though.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#7

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Brent in Montreal

>I'm a long fence kinda guy. I like the stability it gives me. I have some concerns over the hypothetical cut you pictured. First of all, I don't cut anything against a fence that does'nt make it to the splitter before clearing the front teeth of the blade (I use a bandsaw for those kind of cuts). Secondly, the push stick positioning is wrong in the picture. Placing a push stick that close to the fence is asking for the piece to rotate into the blade at the rear end. I place my push stick to the left of center on any piece I am cutting against a TS fence.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Charlie,

Thanks for reopening a valuable discussion. I have always felt the main reason for a short fence was to allow room for reaction wood to bend away from the blade without interference, thereby limiting one possible kickback cause. I'm sure there are other reasons, but I am a little worried about the example you've posted. I think it could lead people to try this operation with a false sense of security. If anything, I would qualify your observations by saying that the short fence will not automatically or necessarily prevent kickback in this situation, but it may reduce the likelihood. I think the reality is more complicated, though.

My personal preference on the tablesaw is to avoid cuts where the workpiece is short, like the one in your example, and not just because of the long fence issue. Short workpieces cut on the tablesaw, particularly if they are wider than they are long, are accidents waiting to happen in my estimation. The correct way of pushing borderline pieces like this through the saw is to make sure you are applying continuous, pressure on the workpiece against the fence. I don't use push sticks like the birds-mouth stick you have drawn for exactly this reason. They really are only good for pushing, and only at one point on the workpiece. I greatly prefer a push stick that resembles a hobnail boot in profile, as it allows me to exert downward pressure on the leading edge of a short board and also a modicum of uniform side pressure to hold the piece against the fence. On really short, wide pieces like in your example, I'd probably use a jointer-type push block to hold the piece down and offer plenty of friction for that lateral force component. In any case, I'd prefer a long fence for short-stock operations since I don't want the fence to disappear with only a couple inches of the workpiece bearing on the fence. That, to me, seems like it is still a kickback situation, or at least likely to result in less than a clean cut as the piece rocks off to the right, pushing the tail end of the cut against the front teeth of the blade. On pieces that are longer than they are wide, the short fence works fine.

Ellis

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#9

Re: makes sense to me......

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Well...I always worry about it. I have a Beismeyer and it's a 110% better than the factory fence that came with my 199_ Grizzly 1022Z.

I really appreciate the story and the graphics though.

Ray

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#10

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I have used both types on my current saw. An older saw I had years ago (oh it was an antique!!!) had a short fence on that saw because that is how it came. I learned to use it and discovered that, generally, it worked well. After all, as our comrade Sgain Dubh has pointed out, such fences are used elsewhere and are standard. When I purchased my current saw I made an attachment for a short fence. It worked reasonably well, but no better than the OE Delta fence it was attached to. I have since purchased an aftermarket Delta fence. I also have used both types of fence with the new one. My reaction? I now prefer the standard American full fence . . . . provided the fence is kept adjusted.

The advantage of trhe short fence is that it allows for "slop" and misadjustments because the because the cutting edge of the saw and the end of the fence are so close - there is little chance of a kickback. As far as I can tell, that is the major reason for using a short fence.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#11

Re: Another kickback potential

charlie belden in san jose

>While a short fence won't help with "Crossed Leg" reaction wood, it does keep Wishbone reaction wood case from closing the kerf at the back of the cut.

The problem with reaction wood is that, unless you are a sawyer or were there when the board was cut from the log, it's difficult to recognize if a board contains built up internal stresses and strains.

As noted, ripping with a bandsaw is far safer than ripping on a table saw using a fence. But at some point you need to get two edges straight and square to a face - and parallel. And a rip fence on the table saw is the easiest and perhaps safest way to do that.

Re: multi-tasking the fence

Tenoning jigs that use the fence rather than the miter slot, sacrificial fences for dado blade cuts, a connection device for afeatherboard, anti-kickback devices, a place to attach a stop for a stopped cut etc. may be an advantage for the long fence over the short fence.

But when it comes to rip cuts - on a table saw - the short fence seems to be safer than a long fence.


img

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#12

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

charlie belden in san jose

>OK - so my crosscut/rip example - part shorter than the length of the exposed blade - AND - a worse case push stick location was a bit over the top. For that kind of a cut I personally use a GRRRRIPPER though Ellis's Boot Push Device - which both pushes AND holds the part down on the table - provides good control as well.

One advantage I see for the short fence - specifically for a rip cut - is the Parallelling The Blade thing. With a short fence, a little "toe in" (back of fence close to the blade than at the rear of the blade) isn't really as significant as it is on a longer fence. A few thousandths off at the back of the blade probably isn't important. But with a long rip cut, that few thousandths at the back of the blade may be two, three or four times that at the back end of the long fence. THAT would be a safety issue.

Seems like in an ideal world, a fence that could be slid to make it longer, or slid back to make it shorter to accomodate the specific type of cut would be advantageous. Keeping it parallel to the blade - well that would be an issue.

As for using the rip fence for cutting up full sheets of ply - clearly a sliding table, which requires no fence, is easier and, if the table tracks parallels the blade, safer.

Euro table saws - Felder, Hammer, Robland, Rojek, MiniMax etc. - all have either a sliding table or a linear bearing slider right up against the saw blade - have been around for quite a while. U.S. after market sliding tables are available for US market table saws - but as an afterthought.

In addition to riving knives as standard on euro table saws, other basic machines are different in euro versions. On euro joiners the ends of the infeed tables (at the cutter head) a) are aluminum and b) notched sort of like dental molding. Aluminum can be cut by a joiner knive without significant damage. Cast iron on the other hand is pretty hard on cutting edges. The "notching" also cuts down on the decibel levels the joiner produces.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Jesper, Denmark

>The short fence works well when you are ripping boards with reaction wood. The long fence is better for sheet goods. The Delta Unifence is easy to adjust for both.

The example you show with a short wide board is a no-no on the tablesaw against the fence. You are performing an unsafe operation. A better option would be to use a sled with a holddown and cut on the other side of the blade.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#14

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Sgian Dubh

>Charlie, I find it interesting that I sent you an email about exactly this issue several years ago, including a link to an illustrated online discussion on the subject written by Barb Siddiqui with a it of commentary from myself. I was prompted to do so after reading your online discussion on table saw safety; I never heard anything back from you about it, nor spotted any changes in your online discussion.

I assumed at first that you weren't impressed with the short set fence idea. Later it occurred to me that perhaps you never received my email so naturally you'd know nothing about it.

In any case I'm pleased to see yet another US based saw user taking notice of the advantages of the short set fence, even if it is nearly ten years after I started banging on about them in woodworking forums, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#15

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

charlie belden in san jose

>Sgian Duhb wrote:

Charlie, I find it interesting that I sent you an email about exactly this issue several years ago, including a link to an illustrated online discussion on the subject written by Barb Siddiqui with a it of commentary from myself. I was prompted to do so after reading your online discussion on table saw safety; I never heard anything back from you about it, nor spotted any changes in your online discussion.

I assumed at first that you weren't impressed with the short set fence idea. Later it occurred to me that perhaps you never received my email so naturally you'd know nothing about it.

In any case I'm pleased to see yet another US based saw user taking notice of the advantages of the short set fence, even if it is nearly ten years after I started banging on about them in woodworking forums, ha, ha. Slainte.

======================

I don't recall getting an e-mail from you about long vs short fences with a link to Barb Siddiqui's info on the subject. I did include contributions to a discussion on kickback from posts to the usenet news group rec.woodworking.

It's not that I have a personal bias. I do have a euro combination machine. The euro version had a short fence. The "upgraded" version I bought has a long fence. I hadn't even considered fence length as a parameter for kickback until Niki from Poland e-mailed me about it. I accidently deleted his e-mail while deleting a bunch of junk e-mail (I get fifty or more a day). I would like to hear from Niki again.

As for updating the info I put together on the subject of kickback, I'm working on a page on the long fence vs short fence issue. I've got a start on it but will be revising that based on what I've learned here. Please be patient - doing decent illustrations take time, as does the accompanying text. And, in addition to working on my web site's info, I also actually do some woodworking - the current project mentoring a newbie make a four door, raised panel floor to ceiling linen cabinet.

I'd appreciate it if you'd post your views and the link to Barb's info - or e-mail them to me - again. My apologies for not responding to your earlier e-mail.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#16

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

>Charlie, the link is below.

In truth the rip fences on European saws aren't short at all; they are simply pulled back so that the front end of the fence is in line with a point just beyond where the downward chopping teeth of the sawblade disengage with the wood being dimensioned. This does mean that there is a lot of fence extending backwards towards the operator, and this helps control the wood on the infeed side.

I know exactly what you mean about the time required to prepare texts. I've been working on a book on timber technology for three years now. It's not as if I'm inexperienced at writing for publication; I've been doing it for a long time, but I'm very busy doing other things so it is hard to find time to work on side projects. Slainte.


Barb Siddiqui- ripping with a short set fence.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#17

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

Hamish

>Jasper made a reference to hold downs. Although he was referring to ones mounted on a sled. I seem to remember seeing adds years ago for hold down, one direction, rubber wheels that attached to the top of the fence, that drew the stock in towards the fence and away from the back teeth of the saw blade. Has anybody had any experience using them and have they been helpful to avoid kick back?

My TS came with a short fence which has the disadvantage of being only held or fixed to the saw table at the in put side of the table. There are times when I am cutting sheet material that I feel the end of the fence moves slightly as I'm pressing the board against it while cutting, so losing in accuracy and creating a potential problem of jamming the wood. Perhaps I could modify it by adding on a support fence ALONG THE BACK of the original one, so that it can be firmly clamped at the out feed end of the table. This would make it more ridged and keep it working as a short fence. Another modification that I think would be useful at times would be to extend the fence back towards the operator to give support while I am cutting long pieces.

A very interesting thread. Hamish.

Re: Long Fence vs Short Fence on Table Saw

#18

Niki is Niki Avrahami

Don in Northern Arizona

>He hangs out over on familywoodworking.org where he is the resident jigs and fixtures genius. You can send him a message there.

Don