>What looks right with your design? I usually sketch my work on graph paper (11" x 17") at the largest scale that I can fit on the pad. I let the proportions of the sketch point me towards a rough idea of what the taper angle should be and how small I should make the base or foot. The height or leg length is also important. I usually end the taper anywhere from 1-3" below the apron.
>As JL said, it all depends on what looks right. If you're building this table for yourself, then it's you that needs to like the look. Scale drawings are a great way to visualize the exact proportions, but you need to have a personal design frame of reference to evaluate the possibilities. Often, our tastes are "built-in," that is, conditioned by our experience to the point of being instinctual. In our culture, most of us have been conditioned by classical proportions that have been with us since the time of the ancient Greeks. What looks good to us might not look right to someone from, say, an African or Indonesian culture with different historical and cultural antecedents. But I digress.
The exact measurement of your taper isn't as important as the overall appearance. If you look at Shaker tables, you'll see that most of them had very graceful, slender-looking tapered legs. Rarely were they 2 1/2" thick at the top --usually 2" or less for most table sizes. They tapered to a rather small footprint, usually less than 1". The tapers usually began right at the point where the apron begins, and that is most appealing to me as well. But the exact sizes are relative. They depend on the look you want, and the proportions will vary with the length of the legs and their visual relationship to the rest of the table. What you want to avoid is the appearance of being overly thick at the floor. This defeats the primary visual effect of the taper, which is to visually thrust the table off the floor.
Sorry about all the fuzzy language. I hope it helps you somehow. Why don't you draw some possibilities and post them here for critique?
>Maybe this answer will sound like it isn't an answer.........There isn't one answer. Draw a scale drawing of various options. What looks best on paper will most probably look good when you make it. At least his approach works for me in making these decisions.
>The width of your apron and thickness of the top will also control the amount of taper. If you have a 1 1/2" thick top and 4" aprons (rather extreme), you will want the taper to start at maybe 2" below the apron and end up, maybe 1 1/4 square at the floor. 2 1/2 apron and 7/8 top, start the taper 1 or less below the apron and 3/4 square at the floor. In the first case, the table would look like it's on it's toes because of the mass on the top of the table.
Also remember that you will be seeing the table leg from a much different angle when you are standing up. I suggest you cut up a cardboard mockup of a couple different legs and aprons, and tape them to an existing table to judge your design.
I usually start the taper about a half inch or an inch below the rail. This may be a lack of confidence on my part, but it leaves me a little wiggle room if I have to sand or fiddle with the taper more than I thought. If the taper is a half inch below the rail or apron, it looks fine, but if you get it a half inch up into the rail, it looks like crap. (You can cheat a little here. If your blanks are an inch too long, leave them. Taper them, leaving the top part straight for an inch more than the rail. Once they are cleaned up and sanded, you can cut the top off if you prefer, or the bottom, But don't hack too much off the bottom, it reduces the taper.)
I personally like the taper to be on the inner sides of the legs with the outside faces left vertical. Sometimes it looks better to taper all four sides. I also have the "Engineering Brain" and tend to make things too heavy and thick because it appeals to the "sturdiness factor". Takes discipline on my part to make the legs as slender as they might aught to be to look graceful. Recently I have started to make full sized mock ups. In you case, I might get apiece of framing lumber such as a 4 X 4 and saw it down to a 2 1/2" blank and then taper it. Then I would look at it for a day or two. Also, Attach a rail piece to it and maybe a little hunk of top. Sit it up and walk back. Look at it from the perspective the real piece would be viewed from.