Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Electrical short in my DC

Posts

Electrical short in my DC

#1

Electrical short in my DC

Joe Pack

>I had a serious short in my dust collector last night, but cannot figure out why.

My DC is 220 volts. It is on wheels, but I leave it in one spot instead of moving it around. The DC unit was turned on, but plugged in to a LongRanger remote. The remote box was plugged into the 220 line. This system has been in this configuration for a year or more with no problem.

Yesterday I had to reach behind the DC to get a piece of plywood. When I moved the DC slightly, sparks flew from behind it causing the breaker to throw. I made sure the breaker was off, then unplugged the DC from the remote box and the remote box from the 220 line.

I checked each cord and found zero indication of any wear, burn, short, etc.

I checked ground to the DC from the neutral of the plug to a bolt on the DC. I had continuity of ground. I also checked for continuity between each leg of the plug and ground and found none (which should have been the case, I believe).

I made the same checks on the Long Ranger remote box, with the same result.

Finding no problem with the cords, I looked farther. The problem was that, other than the cords reaching behind the DC, there was no other possible electricity source...or so I thought. Looking more closely, I found what I think was the site, if not the cause, of the problem...

The DC has an upright bag, supported by a steel rod. This rod is just high enough that, if the DC is pushed far enough, the rod will come into contact with the cold air return on my furnace system. What I found was an apparent burn spot on the rod at the exact height where it would have contacted my cold air return! There was a matching burn spot on my cold air return. In fact, there was a small pinhole burned through the cold air return.

I turned the 220 breaker back on and tried my bandsaw in the line, which worked. I was hesitant to plug in the DC until I figure out my exact problem.

Unless I can definitively figure out what is wrong, I will be calling an electrician tomorrow a.m. In the meantime, do any of our WC electricity experts have any ideas as to the problem?

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#2

Re: Electrical short in my DC

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Sounds to me like the DC chassis was "hot" because a broken ot loose, wire or some other part in the blower motor, switch housing, or junction box came in contact with the case or frame. You are lucky you did not get zapped!!! It hadn't been a problem before since there had been no connection to ground, until the rod came in contact with the grounded heat duct. Just a guess. Do not plug it in again until you find the problem. If you don't have a meter or are not good with wiring, take the unit to a motor shop to be checked out and repaired.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#3

Re: Electrical short in my DC

John K Jordan

>>I also checked for continuity between each leg of the plug and ground

>and found none (which should have been the case, I believe).

Remember that any short between a hot leg and ground might be intermittent and would not show up on your meter unless the movement or flexing is duplicated.

The problem could also be in the building wiring. Unless you are comfortable with working on wiring systems, you should contact an electrician and have the building wiring checked out.

Where I worked we nearly electrocuted a student in the optics lab when he touched a ground and a metal optical table at the same time. The equipment in the lab had been in use for many months since the last time the wiring was worked on and the problem did no show up until the chance contact. It's been a while but from what I remember a couple of moron electricians had both used the wrong plug and mis-wired a 220 cord that plugged into a 440v receptacle. This put 110v on the ground going to a high intensity lamp on the optical table. I did not trust those gentlemen to work on it again so I locked the door and fixed it myself. (They were union and I would have been in trouble.)

JKJ

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#4

Re: Electrical short in my DC

Rick Christopherson

>There is not enough information in your posting to say one way or the other, but before you assume this is a standard electrical problem, you should also consider if this is a static problem.

In any event, it is pretty clear that your DC is not grounded through the ground prong on the outlet. This needs to be fixed.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#5

Re: Electrical short in my DC

GalenV

>I may read more into this than I should.

You say the DC was ON but connected to the remote. When the DC arced was the remote ON to provide power? If the remote was Not on then the DC housing would to have no potential for being hot from a short in it.

John could be right on duct being hot. The fact you say the top bolt arced to the duct but yet you say sparks came from rear. What arc was created in the back? Could it be you provide a path from your furnace duct to say a metal conduit or even a water pipe behind your DC? May want to check the duct to ground with a volt meter and even the metal it may have touched in the back could be hot.

Confussed yet?

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Electrical short in my DC

Jesper, Denmark

>It sounds like you have a ground fault in the DC and the DC motor is not grounded through the cord.

The fault can be a loose wire or any other "leak" of a hot wire to the frame of the DC motor.

The missing ground connection can be either that it is not connected at the junction box or that the outlet ground has no continuity to the system ground.

You need to find the fault first and then fix the ground connection.

A ground fault interrupter would be a safe addition to your installation. The newer types, which are less prone to be activated during thunderstorms are preferable.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#7

Re: Electrical short in my DC

Barry Irby

>Having read through the other posts I have a couple of thoughts.

While it is possible thsi was caused by static, I doubt it. No real info to offer, but I doubt it. My DC shocks me occasionally with static and it is annoying, but not enough to burn a hole in a duct.

I would check both the duct and the frame of the DC for live current. It seems to me that either could have been hot for a while and you would not have known because you never touched either while grounded. I have a tester that alerts when a wire or peice of metal is HOT. Its about the size of a fat Magic Marker. I think you can get one at Lowes for about $20. If you have a Meter, you could touch the duct and a known ground and see if the duct is HOT. Then you could turn on the DC and touch the rod and the known ground. Don't touch either the duct or the DC with your hand until you are sure they are not HOT. Then you could touch the DC and the Duct with the meter leads to see if there is potential between the two.

As everyone else ahs correctly said, you should not do this if you are not comfortable. If either the DC or duct is HOT, you have to track down the connection between the Hot wire and the unit.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#8

I agree!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It sounds to me like the problem is in teh ductwork and not your dust collector. If the unit was not running, the ground path would still be connected through the long ranger. I would definitely recommend checking the voltage between the cold air return and a known ground with a meter. It is entirely possible you have a problem in your heat system or a wire that crosses the cold air return has worn through the insulation.

A static discharge would not have been powerful enough to leave a burn mark on metal!

You should also check the connections for the blower motor where the cord enters the junctuon box on the side of the motor or where ever the cord goes to the switch. You could have a loose wire inside the box that could short out when the cord is moved just right.

Lee

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#9

Re: Electrical short in my DC

Tony - Memphis

>I have no idea, but please let us know what you find out so that we all may learn something!

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#10

Problem found

Joe Pack

>The electrician just left. The problem was not with incorrect wiring, but too much muscle on my part.

When I installed the wiring I used romex clamps to keep the wire stabilized so it would not move and rub through the insulation. It appears that, in my mighty quest to stabilize the wire, I cranked the romex clamp too tight and managed to cut the smallest slit in the white wire. This tiny little slit allowed the energized, exposed wire to contact the bare ground wire. So, instead of having two hot leads and a ground, I actually had THREE hot leads and no good ground.

Because the ground wire was actually energized, and because the ground is a continuous feed not interrupted by a switch, electricity was being constantly fed through the remote box to the DC even when the remote and/or DC were not turned on. It was only luck that had the DC upper bag support contact my furnace cold air return and set off a mini-fireworks display. Otherwise, I might have been seriously injured if I had been touching the metal of the DC and touched a ground at the same time.

I have learned my lesson...snug is good, tight is okay and overcranking on anything just gets you in trouble. Really, I never, ever, thought about a romex connector clamp being so tight that it would cut or pinch through insulation on 12/2 wg romex.

Thanks for all the tips. You were right on when you advised to have a pro look at it. Even he took a while, and a lot of head scratching, to find the problem.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#11

At least you are here to tell us & not toasted!

GalenV

>

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#12

Same thing goes.

Dan Donaldson

>For staples when installing romex. I used to work with my FIL, who is an electrical contractor, and I have fixed several wires that were broken at the staples in the same way because they were too tight (as you can imagine, it is a bit messy to get to these repairs. ;-). The purpose of the staples is to prevent the wire from moving around when drywalling etc. and not to hold it solidly to the stud. You only need it tight enough that it doesn't fall out easily, not down totally against the wire.

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#13

Re: Problem found

mdclor

>Joe,

Thanks for the education. I, too, am someone that tends to over tighten things, so this will be very helpful to me going forward. I am also impressed that you got an electrician in 1 day. :)

Merle

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#14

Re: Problem found

Tony - Memphis

>Thanks for posting. I tend to over-tighten too. I just installed a 220 circuit for a TS and I checked and double checked. I hope I don't have any similar issues. What a way to find oout though! Who'da thunk it?!?

Tony

Re: Electrical short in my DC

#15

Re: Problem found

John K Jordan

>Another thing to keep in mind when running cable of any kind - don't stretch it too tight anywhere! I saw case where the insulation on a long run of wire was completely worn through due to, guess what, temperature changes! When the temperature got warm, the wire would relax; when it got cold, the wire would contract. Everytime it contracted it rubbed on a rough edge.

JKJ