Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

Posts

OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#1

OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

Hank Knight

>The recent cherry finishing threads have me going around in circles. I'm getting ready to finish some heavily figured curly cherry. The project is a hunt board I've posted about several times. The top, the drawer fronts and the door panels will be curly cherry and they are the focal points of the piece, so I want them to look good. I need to stain them to add some red - the cherry I'm using is too tan colored for my project.

As I understand the various posts, "blotchy" cherry is caused by grain reversal and/or different densities in the wood, both of which are factors - or the "cause" of curly figure. So, do I finish without worrying about a "blotchy" outcome because that's what I'm really aiming for to have the curl show up? Or do I need to be careful with the stain and the finish to keep from ruining an expensive piece of curly cherry - and my project? I haven't completely decided on how I will finish the piece, but my plan was (is?) to first use a very light aplication of Trans Tint dye in alcohol for the color, followed by BLO, sealed with shellac and then finish with a wiping varnish or perhaps some wipe-on poly for the durability since this is a sideboard or serving table.I would appreciate any suggestions of criticisms of my finishing plan. I don't want to screw this up.

TIA

Hank

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#2

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

Dick Coers

>I really dislike staining cherry. Be patient, it will get to the color you want without the pigment in a couple of years. Add pigment or dye now and it will be way too dark in 5 years. If you really can't wait that long, take it outside in the direct sun for a week. All this blotchie talk drives me nuts. If you want really even color, use Formica. I just had to say it, let Mother Nature set the color. Cherry is just too beautiful on it's own.

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#3

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I think that you'd want to read very carefully the FWW article on finishing cherry. What they portrayed seemed a very good place to start.

For me, for a project like yours, I'd use Waterlox Original, because it ambers nicely, provides a tough surface, applies easily and is pretty controllable.

When I did a maple & cherry bathroom a few years back, I did sample boards for three different approaches. A thinned wiping varnish won out.

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#4

Ellis Walentine

"FFF"

Ellis Walentine

>..."Finish Firewood First."

That's Michael Dresdner's perennial advice, and I can't stress how important it is, especially when you can't afford to make any mistakes. Cherry can blotch, particularly under oil-based finishes, whether or not it is curly. That's why they sell "stain controllers", which are mostly oil and solvent, to use before applying oil-based pigment stains to blotch-prone woods like pine and cherry.

In your case, I'd probably put a dilute coat of reddish brown dye stain on the raw wood, followed by your several coats of Waterlox. Remember that the cherry will continue to darken in spite of your stain, so the color you see now is not what you're going to see in a year or two. I'd skip the BLO and shellac. If you want to compare outcomes, prepare test finishes on a couple sample boards.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#5

Thanks all

Hank Knight

>I have never used Waterlox, so I hadn't considered it. This may be the occasion for it. I know cherry darkens with age, but this piece is light khaki color. I assume it will turn a darker brown. Most of the "red" cherry I've used in the past had red or pink tones in the newly cut surfaces and it aged to a very nice reddish brown, which is what I'm looking for in this piece. I thought if I started with a little red cherry flavored Trans Tint, I'd give the red a kick start that might last through the ageing process. I have a bunch of "firewood" set aside for test runs. I'll let y'all know how it goes. Thanks for the input.

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#6

some advice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is hard to type enough to describe a finishing schedule. It would be pages, not a note. But the bottom line is-develop the finish schedule on test pieces not the finished product.

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#7

Re: some advice

Hank Knight

>Thanks, Bill. Advice noted and incorporated.

Re: OK, I'm totally confused - I think.

#8

'nother no stain vote

paul in AZ

>Cherry is so gorgeous on its own and I think stains take the life out of the wood. You may get a [somewhat dull] "factory" color right away but will never get the rich color and wonderful glow of unstained wood.

I use a couple or three wipe on-wipe-off coats of BLO with several days in between. Then I put it out in the sun for several days to a week to accelerate the color change. It helps to have Arizona's intense sun with almost no prospect of rain. :-)) After a week or so to thoroughly dry/cure [whatever] the BLO I'd go to the varnish you mentioned.

With this procedure a cabinet I built this summer already has a beautiful color. Color continues to gradually get even better over a year or more.

If you are in no hurry try it on some scraps.