Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Dust collection saga

Posts

Dust collection saga

#1

Dust collection saga

Guy

>OK, It is finally almost at an end. My wife and I have settled on either the 2hp Super Gorilla from Oneida or the 2hp cyclone from Grizzly. Specs are virtually identical (14 inch impeller, metal gauge thickness, air movement, etc). I know the Oneida is American made but with shipping there is a palpable difference in price with the Griz being much much less (almost $900 vs about $1600). I also have a spare motor, a Leeson that I have had so i am not worried about motor burn out issues. It is going to be hooked up via 15 feet of flex ( 6" ) directly to our machines, one at a time, reduced at the machine for the appropriate ports. So, for anybody that has one or the other is the price difference truly worth it considering the one machine at a time hookup, and I don't need the ducting planning?Any opinions, etc are greatly appreciated. Also we plan on pulling the trigger by the end of this week either way. Thank you all.

Re: Dust collection saga

#2

JL

Re: Dust collection saga

JL

>Guy, whichever way you choose - you are not getting a "portable" machine. I mounted my 2 hp Super Dust Gorilla (SDG) on the outer wall of my shop. I also installed ducting - but I could easily install it between my joists and suspended ceiling.

Some thoughts - which could be implemented after the purchase also. The SDG cyclones require a length of straight piping coming off of the cyclone for a particular length (several feet). If you choose a SDG - mount it high. If you mount either cyclone near a corner - how about running a length of ducting the entire length of the shop? You could run it up high on the wall and have "Wyes" every five or so feet. You could have blast gates on the wall and then have your smaller flex hose coming from the blast gates.

I ducted my old shop in a similar fashion. I had my old DC in a corner with a main running the length of shop.

As far as which one to buy, I bought a SDG and I've been quite happy with it. I've seen the Grizzly at a show, but I didn't really inspect it as I already had a cyclone. I've been fairly impressed by some other Grizzly products though. I don't know as if either choice would be bad.

Re: Dust collection saga

#3

Re: Dust collection saga

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>I have a 2 HP Grizzly DC that I have worked pretty hard for 11 years. Not a problem.

Re: Dust collection saga

#4

Re: Dust collection saga

Tony - Memphis

>I think mine is the equivalen in a Delta (850) and i use the long hise from machine to machine. I have no complaints. I'm not real anal about dust collection, so consider that with this response. I do trip over the hose once in a while and moving the hose gets old, but the setup as served me well. Much better than using my old shop vac via a really small hose! I added the Highland Hardware bags and those made a huge difference. I have had issues with the one Griz machine I own and have sworn to never do business with them again, but, my 6" jointer has been running for over ten years and has never skipped beat. So, I can really complain about that.

Tony

Re: Dust collection saga

#5

Re: Dust collection saga

Bob Powers

>My Oneida System is now thirteen years old. Other than to dump the barrel periodically, it has seen maintenance once. That was to install the external filter upgrade. I used Oneida's expertise to lay out the system. It performs flawlessly. Want to take a guess as to my recommendation?

Re: Dust collection saga

#6

Re: Dust collection saga

Chuck in ND

>Penn State Industries also sells a wide variety of cyclones.

Re: Dust collection saga

#7

noise

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>determine if noise is significant to you. I have worked in shops with DC that made my head hurt from the blower noise.

Re: Dust collection saga

#8

Re: Dust collection saga

Fred Davis

>Just a observation or two or more, about DC brands and ducting.

Oneida makes air handler systems, that's all , not saws , boat anchors or what have you.

That being said if your trying to bite a cost bullet , lean toward a company that is expert and a acknowledged leader in the field, you will never be sorry.

According to the engineer at Oneida and some other Dust Collection experts, corrugated duct runs should never exceed eight feet, that is a subject where less is better.

For years I installed mostly Jenn-Aire ranges for the clients that preferred electric cook stoves and Jenn-Aire would void their warranty if you vented one with corrugated ducting.

A foot of Flex ducting is equivalent to 2 1/2 feet of smooth duct air drag wise.

So for a fifteen foot run of Flex, you can do the math.

Hope this helps.

FredD