Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

What finish is this?

Posts

What finish is this?

#1

What finish is this?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Hints:

1. Darkens and muddies woods� natural appearance

2. Gets even darker over time

3. Dries and cures slowly

4. Needs multiple coats

5. Always looks dull

6. Offers little protection or water resistance

7. Abets spontaneous combustion in wiping rags

Give up?

It�s BLO

Re: What finish is this?

#2

Ellis Walentine

Not much to recommend there

Ellis Walentine

>My grandfather used to use it on shovel and rake handles to keep them from drying and splitting. A lot of people like to use it under a varnish or lacquer finish to accentuate the figure of wood. And, it is used a lot in stains and other "oil finishes" that are really just mixtures of varnishes and long oils.

I'd be curious as to whether any of you use boiled linseed oil as a stand-alone furniture finish, how you apply it, and how you get around the negatives that Clint observed in his little quiz above.

Ellis

Re: What finish is this?

#3

Re: Not much to recommend there

ThomD

>The closest I come to it is Sam Maloof finish, where it is a 1/3rd component.

It is used in some of the highest quality gun stocks to spectacular result. In particular it has very positive shine and depth. More waterproofness can be achieved with additions to the mixture. Drying time can be pepped up through the addition of driers, that are responsible for the positive drying of all commercial preps, at least traditionally. Sure they are toxic, which is why we have toy finishes and salad bowl finishes.

Re: What finish is this?

#4

Re: Not much to recommend there

ThomD

>Taken in turn:

1. Darkens and muddies woods� natural appearance

Most finishes that soak in do darken a little, muddies sounds unfair to me particularly when it is known to depen figure. You always have to choose your woods.

2. Gets even darker over time

That's the good news, most other finishes will break down, we have stuff that was oilled that lasts hundreds of years. Old wood darkens anyway,

3. Dries and cures slowly

That's just a technique issue. And in any case, the weekend project crowd may not like this but a good oil job is just set aside for a week between coats, doesn't cost you anything unless you are down to counting inventory.

4. Needs multiple coats

Can't think of any good finish that doesn't.

5. Always looks dull

The opposite is true, it is added to finishes because it brightens them.

6. Offers little protection or water resistance

No good finish adds protection, it is contradictory to letting the wood speak for itself, We are in the range of poly or catalysing finishes. Water resistance is a toughie, it requires admixtures. However it's use on the stock of the finesh guns shows it is perfectly weatherproof under terrible conditions when properly done.

7. Abets spontaneous combustion in wiping rags

That's not a real problem, just something not to fall afoul of. Might as well say a chisel abets large loss of blood.

One could make the case that of the craft revolution writers and makers in the US, that the one with the greattest commercial success while staying within the bounds that brought his attention was Thos. Moser. I mean who knows, it's subjective, and who has real numbers, but I wouldn't be surprised. Moser advocated the use of linseed oil and used it on his popular furniture.

Re: What finish is this?

#5

rebuttal, at least partial

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The only thing I finish with only linseed oil is hoe, rake and canoe handles. However, that does not mean that this material has no place in high end finishing schedules. In this past year I have been instructed by two notable period furniture builders, Jeff Headley and Alf Sharp( 2007 Cartousch winner) and each used linseed oil as part of the finishing schedule for reproduction furniture. Alf in particular is noted for his exceptional finishes.

1. Darkens and muddies woods� natural appearance* This statement is in contrast to what I have experienced and what the above named finishing experts teach.

2. Gets even darker over time* All finishes darken over time. Especially so varnishes and nitrocellulsoe lacquer. Less so acrylics.

3. Dries and cures slowly* When used between a dye stain and shellac it is recommended to let the finish dry for at least a day and preferably 3.

4. Needs multiple coats* not when used as described in 3.

5. Always looks dull* Many people prefer the luster of oiled wood. In fact some modern finishes have been formulated to simulate an oiled finish.

6. Offers little protection or water resistance* many paddlers prefer an oiled canoe paddle handle. I have to add oil to my paddles every couple of years.

7. Abets spontaneous combustion in wiping rags* no disagreement here and so does varnish. However, the fires from lacquer are vastly more spectacular. This concern is hardly a valid reason to not use this material.

Re: What finish is this?

#6

so true

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I refinished the stock of my fathers Winchester 24 in 1957 with a multitude of coats of linseed oil. I have used the gun in all conditions on hundreds of days and it still looks good.

Re: What finish is this?

#7

why?

John K Jordan

>>The only thing I finish with only linseed oil is hoe,

>rake and canoe handles

Why did you choose this? I've started using spar varnish and it seems to hold up well. Is there an advantage to BLO?

JKJ

Re: What finish is this?

#8

Re: Not much to recommend there

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>And taken in return:

Taken in turn:

1. Darkens and muddies woods� natural appearance

Most finishes that soak in do darken a little, muddies sounds unfair to me particularly when it is known to depen figure. You always have to choose your woods.

**Anything that "wets" the wood emphasizes the figure. FWW did comparisons that concluded BLO was no more effective in that regard than anything else

2. Gets even darker over time

That's the good news, most other finishes will break down, we have stuff that was oilled that lasts hundreds of years. Old wood darkens anyway,

**I'm not aware of any current finishes that "break down" or continue to darken the wood. Oil finishes were rarely used on antique high end furniture. More likely it was shellac or varnish.

3. Dries and cures slowly

That's just a technique issue. And in any case, the weekend project crowd may not like this but a good oil job is just set aside for a week between coats, doesn't cost you anything unless you are down to counting inventory.

**Why not a finish that accommodates the craftsman, rather than vice versa?

4. Needs multiple coats

Can't think of any good finish that doesn't.

**But it doesn't improve with more coats.

5. Always looks dull

The opposite is true, it is added to finishes because it brightens them.

**False, it's added to finishes along with matalic driers to bulk up the product at low cost

6. Offers little protection or water resistance

No good finish adds protection, it is contradictory to letting the wood speak for itself, We are in the range of poly or catalysing finishes. Water resistance is a toughie, it requires admixtures. However it's use on the stock of the finesh guns shows it is perfectly weatherproof under terrible conditions when properly done.

**There's that pesky admixture thing again. Out of the can, it offers hardly any resistance to the adherence of dirt and grime, and none to a sweaty glass.

7. Abets spontaneous combustion in wiping rags

That's not a real problem, just something not to fall afoul of. Might as well say a chisel abets large loss of blood.

One could make the case that of the craft revolution writers and makers in the US, that the one with the greattest commercial success while staying within the bounds that brought his attention was Thos. Moser. I mean who knows, it's subjective, and who has real numbers, but I wouldn't be surprised. Moser advocated the use of linseed oil and used it on his popular furniture

**The widespread use of BLO, with or without additives, on studio furniture emerged with the mid-century craftsmen like Nakashima, Maloof, Krenov, et al. It was chosen for its failure proof characteristics. Anyone can produce what appears to be a flawless finish, with inexpensive material and no equipment. It has now become the ubiquitous affectation of hand craft work.

Re: What finish is this?

#9

yes indeed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the oil is easy to renew. The varnish disintegrates over time and has to be removed before re-coating. If not removed, there will be blister forming rough spots that will chafe delicate hands. At least on canoe paddles I have convinced myself that the oil is easier on the hands than varnish. We sometimes paddle most of a day on a trip and the hand thing is not irrelevant.

Re: What finish is this?

#10

some errors in point #2

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>2. **I'm not aware of any current finishes that "break down" or continue to darken the wood. **What finish do you think does not darken (yellow) over time? Try some nitrocellulsoe lacquer on ash sap wood and set it in a sunny room for a year. Aromatic urethanes are as bad or worse. Aliphatic urethanes are sold as "water white" but they have yellowed in my sunny kitchen. CAB is better but it to will yellow some, according to the technical service expert at the company just down the road that makes this stuff. Acrylics are best in this regard for they stay nearly clear.

Oil finishes were rarely used on antique high end furniture. More likely it was shellac or varnish. ** I attended a lecture on period furniture finishing recently. Early finishes were oil. Next came shellac. Later came varnishes which are mixtures of oil and resin. Contrary to your notion that oil is added as an adulterant, the oil contributes plasticity to the film. In most, if not all, applications, period varnish would be too brittle to be of use without the oil.

If one likes the look of oiled furniture then there is no reason not to use it. On the other hand, it fell out of favor for much of the past 300 years as a furniture finish for some good reasons. I would agree that it is over used by persons not willing to learn to finish with something better.

Re: What finish is this?

#11

Re: yes indeed

John K Jordan

>Thanks. I just put the spar varnish over what is there and haven't yet had trouble with blistering.

In the days when I spent nearly every weekend on some whitewater river or another, my best wooden kayak paddles seemed to have 300 coats of some amazingly tough and deeply transparent finish. Seems like THAT would be great for tool handles.

I've been buying fiberglass and metal handles when I can find them, but I discovered a dirty little secret - at least one mfgr uses a wooden connector between the waterproof handle and the metal tool. I've had this piece of wood rot away and break the same as an all wood handle. Fortunately, the repairs were quicker than making a new handle.

JKJ

Re: What finish is this?

#12

Thank you, Gentlemen...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have sincerely enjoyed the discussion and will make one final comment before my wife and I make an early departure manana for Chicago to deliver a dresser (finished with alkyd lacquer) to my 6 year old grandaughter, then a leasurely drive across the top of PA on US Rt6.

Many posts refer to using BLO without additives as part of their finishing schedule. That is the product I was takling about in this thread. The contradictory responses all altered the subject to chemically modified BLO or BLO in combination with other hardening oils.

That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Don't worry, be happy.

Clint

Re: What finish is this?

#13

Re: Thank you, Gentlemen...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I use linseed oil occasionally. When I read stuff like your original post I wonder about two things. First, does the guy really know how to use linseed oil? Second, what kind of garbage does he use instead? You answered the second question.

Re: What finish is this?

#14

Re: rebuttal, at least partial

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>with respect to #2 (all finished darken over time).......

Linseed oil was/is used as a traditional finish for the interior of small wooden boats. Often times when you see an old boat today the interior is almost charcoal black. This colouring is linseed oil.

Garden tool handles treated with linseed oil will do the same thing.

Not sure if BLO will cause the same colour shift so radically, but the evidence is pretty clear about the relationship between linseed oil, UV lights and the elements.

Rob

Re: What finish is this?

#15

Re: rebuttal, at least partial

John K Jordan

>A little OT, but I discovered the a similar darkening affect with oil on cocobolo.

I turn many small things from cocobolo. I usually finish them with a shellac-based friction polish. Once I put Watco oil on one with strilking colors. A few months later it looked almost like ebony while another with the shellac still had bright colors.

JKJ

Re: What finish is this?

#16

Turning black

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>So linseed oil turns black? I have a piece of maple furniture that I finished with linseed oil in 1980. Very nice color. Will it turn black suddenly or do I have to wait for the fourth millennium to see it happen? Or does it have to be in a boat in order to turn black?

Also checked a cherry piece I made in 1973. Could it start turning any day now?

Re: What finish is this?

#17

Opposing Views

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Disagreements with positions on this board are always welcome, Warren, but are expected to be expressed with respect to the original poster. Sarcasm, however, is useless to most everyone other than the one posting it, and is contrary to the spirit of WoodCentral.

If you wish to refute Clint's or others' posts in this or other threads, please do so with the same respect you wish others to treat your opinions. If, however, you wish your contributions to elicit the kind of sarcastic remarks you've made here, I have no doubt that there are other Internet forum sites where your preference will be welcomed.

Re: What finish is this?

#18

BLO - Outside

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rob,

I once made the "mistake" of adding 2 qts. of BLO to the 5 gal. can of oil-based deck finish I used one year. My mix gave the deck a lovely golden color but by the following April, my honey-colored deck was quite black. When I mentioned this to a coatings company rep during a presentation at the paint store he informed me and the others present that what I had done was to make my deck coating a nearly ideal home for "deck" molds of several varieties. It was not the BLO that went black, but rather the even layer of mold spores which find the BLO a tasty treat that colored my deck.

He did mention one benefit, however, in that the action of the molds and the resulting weakness of the finish would make the coating fairly easy to strip with a pressure washer and deck brightener. He was correct in that as well; stuff, black and all, came right off.

Re: What finish is this?

#19

I didn' t find your post offensive

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Warren and I have bashed each other worse than this regularly on the Hand Tools side and I would buy him a beer( or tea) in a minute should I ever meet him. I think he would do the same and risk further criticism of his wimpy blue handled chisels.

Fretting about linseed oil turning black on a piece of indoor furniture because it did so on a boat (it hasn't on my canoe paddles yet) deserved a spirited response so that less experienced by standers don't get confused. Warren provided sound data.

My wife has a 1920's high end commercial mahogany desk finished with ??(certainly not linseed oil) and the outside is now black while the inside looks like bright mahogany. Which illustrates a point I made early on that all finishes darken, more or less, depending on their environment.

Re: What finish is this?

#20

Re: I didn' t find your post offensive

Fred Davis

>Fair and Balanced ....;-))

FredD