Re: Not much to recommend there
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>And taken in return:
Taken in turn:
1. Darkens and muddies woods� natural appearance
Most finishes that soak in do darken a little, muddies sounds unfair to me particularly when it is known to depen figure. You always have to choose your woods.
**Anything that "wets" the wood emphasizes the figure. FWW did comparisons that concluded BLO was no more effective in that regard than anything else
2. Gets even darker over time
That's the good news, most other finishes will break down, we have stuff that was oilled that lasts hundreds of years. Old wood darkens anyway,
**I'm not aware of any current finishes that "break down" or continue to darken the wood. Oil finishes were rarely used on antique high end furniture. More likely it was shellac or varnish.
3. Dries and cures slowly
That's just a technique issue. And in any case, the weekend project crowd may not like this but a good oil job is just set aside for a week between coats, doesn't cost you anything unless you are down to counting inventory.
**Why not a finish that accommodates the craftsman, rather than vice versa?
4. Needs multiple coats
Can't think of any good finish that doesn't.
**But it doesn't improve with more coats.
5. Always looks dull
The opposite is true, it is added to finishes because it brightens them.
**False, it's added to finishes along with matalic driers to bulk up the product at low cost
6. Offers little protection or water resistance
No good finish adds protection, it is contradictory to letting the wood speak for itself, We are in the range of poly or catalysing finishes. Water resistance is a toughie, it requires admixtures. However it's use on the stock of the finesh guns shows it is perfectly weatherproof under terrible conditions when properly done.
**There's that pesky admixture thing again. Out of the can, it offers hardly any resistance to the adherence of dirt and grime, and none to a sweaty glass.
7. Abets spontaneous combustion in wiping rags
That's not a real problem, just something not to fall afoul of. Might as well say a chisel abets large loss of blood.
One could make the case that of the craft revolution writers and makers in the US, that the one with the greattest commercial success while staying within the bounds that brought his attention was Thos. Moser. I mean who knows, it's subjective, and who has real numbers, but I wouldn't be surprised. Moser advocated the use of linseed oil and used it on his popular furniture
**The widespread use of BLO, with or without additives, on studio furniture emerged with the mid-century craftsmen like Nakashima, Maloof, Krenov, et al. It was chosen for its failure proof characteristics. Anyone can produce what appears to be a flawless finish, with inexpensive material and no equipment. It has now become the ubiquitous affectation of hand craft work.