Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Table Top Finish advice needed

Posts

Table Top Finish advice needed

#1

Table Top Finish advice needed

Howard in Bethesda

>I�m making a kitchen tabletop and have a choice of using any of the following finishes:

Deft lacquer spray can

Barleys Gel Varnish

Or

General High Performance water based topcoat

Is any one significantly more durable than the others?

I do not mind doing 10 or 15 coats of the gel varnish.

Thanks

Howard

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

#2

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>IMHO,

"86" the Deft. It's a very low solids lacquer that will not hold up.

A good varnish properly applied with take a lot of wear and tear because its film is flexible. 3-4 coats, dried and sanded between, should be enough depending on your wood.

That said, I'd go with the General Hi Per. Great stuff, KCMA approved, levels beautifully. Best applied by HVLP, but brushable so long as you don't overwork the wet film.

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

#3

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

Dick Coers

>I agree completely with Mark on the water base. Deft would be an absolute disaster. I've seen that stuff melt into a desk saver! It would water mark very easily, and getting a good finish from a spray can is next to impossible.

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

#4

Another brushable alternative

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A waterborne poly floor finish. Varathane and Benjamin Moore both work well. Tough enough to walk on.

Clint

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

#5

Re: Table Top Finish advice needed

Pete LaBelle

>Have 5 coats of Minwax semi-gloss polyurethane on my oak dining room table. Holding up fine. No finish will stand up to sharp objects pulled across it though.

You can brush it on with good results. Don't let your shop get too warm. Warm & dry shops speed up evaporation of the solvents. Use a large brush and work quickly to spread the varnish, then leave the room. A smaller brush, slow work speed, and warm shop will allow the varnish to start to thicken, thus brush strokes become permenant. Work from one end of the table to the other. Don't go back.