Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Need advice on an oak stain

Posts

Need advice on an oak stain

#1

Need advice on an oak stain

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It has been many years since I needed to finish an oak piece and I have nothing on hand or recent experience. I would like to stain the trunk I have built with something that might be called "light golden oak:" I would like the pores to take stain and stand out from the nonporous parts. All the stains I have on hand for walnut, cherry and mahogany are too dark and/or too red- I've tried them all on test pieces.

Does anyone have a nice golden oak stain they like and could recommend? I will top coat with varnish of some kind, to be decided. This trunk will be a toy chest so that use will dictate the finish.

BTW, I bought some Mosher's water soluble stain called "golden oak". Gag! It appeared a greenish gray to me, just like it shows in the color chart that I couldn't believe. So much for what is in a name. Believe the color chart. The failed plan was to base coat with a golden brown, seal and then fill pores with light brown filler or glaze. The other problem was micro grain tears(or something) around the pores that absorbed the stain and make specks. The test piece was ugly!!

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#2

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I've like the result of Minwax' Golden Oak Stain. YMMV

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#3

Concur With Carol.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#4

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

Fred Davis

>Because my wife likes Golden Oak appearance , I have lately been using Porter Paints Teak stain, doesn't look anything like Teak but gives the look of McCloskey's Oak Stain when it was a dye stain and not the crap they substituted for it.

FredD

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#6

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>Bill,

Watco's golden oak is more yellow than Minwax's golden oak. I recently had to finish an oak piece to match another piece and what I ended up doing was 1 coat of the Minwax, let dry, and then 2 coats of the Watco. It yellowed up the redness of the Minwax and made it more golden and matched better. The Minwax darkened the pores for me...I don't know if the Watco would have or not.

Sue

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#7

I really like.....

HC Sakman

>Mohawk's "Medium Dark Walnut" on oak. Also filled pores gives oak a totally different look.

Stain/shellac/glaze/finish also very effective, but very time consuming.

Chico...

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#8

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

steve mackay

>Love MinWax "Wood Finnish" oil base. Its worked with great, consistant results for years. I use, mostly, jacobean but LOTs of flavors on the shelf. The best I can say about it is that this GI has never been able to screw it up. Try as I might. And thats saying a LOT ! And poly goes on over it with "never-fail" results.

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#9

Re: I really like.....

Ray Binnicker

>If you can't find the Mohawk, consider Watco Medium Walnut.

Ray

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#10

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Bill, just to add more confusion, I was able to match some antique qolden oak french doors from a a 1920 craftsman house with Deft's fruitwood stain.

John

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#11

Four steps

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bill -

I'm unable to find my source for this technique so I'm going from memory.

First, undercoat with a yellow waterbase stain.

Second, seal the stain with lacquer or shellac. The object is to get a smooth surface for the next step and to keep the stain in the next step from soaking into the wood.

Third, wipe on a dark oil base stain. It has to be oil base so it gets into the pores. Wipe off until you have the effect you are after. You may have to thin the stain so it goes on and off easily.

Fourth, topcoat with lacquer or shellac.

Ed


img

Re: Need advice on an oak stain

#12

Re: Tung Oil

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I love the way Tung Oil colors up Oak.