Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Doug Fir Flooring

Posts

Doug Fir Flooring

#1

Doug Fir Flooring

Bob Boswood

>I have recently acquired some 5/8ths thick x 10" wide by 18' long clear doug fir from some old bleachers. I was thinking of using it in as flooring in an area in my house. The room is 24'x24'. Is the fir a good choice for flooring? Is it thick enough for flooring? By the time I plane it down, it will probably be 1/2". What would be the best joint for the flooring? Should I t/g it os shiplap it or what? I'm a decent woodworker but I have never made my own flooring before. Any help would be appreciated.

Bob in AK.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#2

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

Jim Dillon

>Bob,

While I have no experience with 1/2 inch flooring (only normal 3/4 inch), my gut reaction is that you may be pushing the envelope a bit with 1/2 inch flooring. A lot depends on how good your underlayment is. If it is good and solid, then you probably will be OK. And by solid, I mean a MINIMUM of 3/4 inch decent plywood on top of floor joists 16 inches OC. Then you have to decide on how you are going to fasten the stuff down. Normal hand and pneumatic nailers are, I believe, set up for 3/4 inch flooring. As far as the joint, a normal tongue and groove wouldn't leave you with much stock, so I vote for a shiplap as you suggested. Perhaps you could add a slight chamfer for decoration and to hide possible gaps along the edge. Just my 2 cents. While I have put down a bit of normal 3/4 inch flooring, I have no direct experiencewith 1/2 inch flooring and defer of other WC folk who are much more experienced. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#3

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

Justin Szeliga

>There is still Oak flooring available that is about 3/8" thick & is face nailed w/blued brads. The edges are square, just butted to each other. I've repaired & replaced a bit of it in houses from the 20's & 30"s. The width of the boards may make it difficult to keep the boards flat, but you could rip them down if the width would present a known tendency to warp the boards.

Probably make a beautiful floor if you're OK with face nailing.

Peace

Justin

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#4

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

Fred Davis

>The Oak flooring (so called) Justin refered to is called strip flooring and is 5/16ths" thick.

It was a cheap subtitute fo T @ G flooring and has not been used in subdivision work for quite some time.

Rows of nails every 16" held it down and you could see the puttied nail holes from the street.

About your question on Doug Fir flooring , it was a popular inexpensive wood flooring in homes and front porches thru about two thirds of the twenetith century and has the drawback of the older it gets , the more splinters you get from the edges breaking down from lack of strength compared to a hardwood floor such as Oak.

if you plane it down much thinner then 3/4ths then the advantage of T @ G joints becomes lost , shiplap joints with chamfered edges still give a weak edge.

If the room size is large, then the work required to make the Fir a fairly decent flooring ,far outweighs any cost savings getting it for free.

One approach , if it would fit your decor , is make it into a plank flooring like the older Pine floors tht are still in service and give a unqnie look to as room. That wpild be square edges and butt ends

Whether then completley planing both faces , flatten the best side of each board for the face and put it down with PL 400 or Pl 500 construction adhesive and hand driven deformed head antique nails on the end of each board.

Just an idea mind you.

FredD

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#5

Ellis Walentine

Thinking out of the box

Ellis Walentine

>The short answer is yes. Even 1/2" is not too thin for flooring. The issues are how to lay it in a reasonably cost-effective way and how it will perform once down and finished. There are a ton of variables involved.

First, regarding joinery, let's consider tongue-and-groove (T&G) for a moment. The reason people prefer T&G for floors is that it facilitates alignment and keeps the edges flat and flush with each other (unlike shiplap joints, which always have a loose edge). It also gives you a visual and debris barrier in the gaps. Mechanically, my rule of thumb is that T&G joints shouldn't be proportioned with the tongues longer (wider) than they are thick. This makes the edges of the mating board structurally weak and susceptible to curling up. For 1/2" stock, your tongues would have to be about 1/8" thick, which is strong enough for a passive joint like this, but, since your boards are 10" wide, the tongues would have to be at least 1/4" long to account for expansion and contraction, which would create the condition I just described. So, I'd choose not to use T&G with 1/2" x 10" boards. This said, if you rip your lumber down to 5", I think you can get away with it. Make the tongues 1/8"T x 3/16"L and the mating boards will have 3/16" x 3/16" of material flanking the groove. Kill those edges lightly with a block plane or sandpaper or a chamfer bit, and you should have a serviceable floor.

I heartily suggest using flooring mastic to bed these boards, though. The mastic will give the boards a solid feel, stop squeaks and prevent any cupping over the 5" widths of the boards. You should be able to toe-nail the boards using regular flooring nailers, although you might need to shim the sole of the nailer to position your nails accurately where the tongue meets the shoulder. In the case of Doug fir at this thickness (and assuming you use mastic or PL400), you probably don't need all the pulling power of standard T-nails, so you could get away with a lighter gauge tacker to hold things down while the mastic sets.

In short, it will be a careful job, but it can easily work out for you. I'd try it on a sample area first and make sure you're comfortable with the procedure and the results.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#6

Re: Thinking out of the box

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I'd use it for wall paneling and get some full-thickness hardwood flooring.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#7

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

pecker

>Most of my old house has oak flooring, but one room was done in fir, for some unknown reason. That floor has the most dents, scratches, and splinters...fir is quite soft and more easily damaged.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Not suitable for flooring

Jim in Burlington On

>Fir is very soft for flooring. I have it in the main 2 rooms of my house. It was installed sometime in the 1920's. You'll need to sand it level after installing it. Fir is very tricky to sand after install due to the soft nature of it. It does look fantastic for the first few weeks but after that your fighting a uphill battle to keep the surface unbroken. Personally I'd install it as fake beams or a ceiling beadboard.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#9

Re: Thinking out of the box

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>The following link is to a flooring vendor who sells 3/8" T&G flooring. I've installed it, without problems, in my home. The site has an installation tutorial but it's basically 1" brads and construction adhesive. My only concern is that fir may not be durable enough to give you a lasting floor.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#10

Re: Thinking out of the box

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Seasoned Douglas Fir is plenty strong. Gets harder each year.

It's not something I'd use for a heavy wear zone, like a commercial foyer, but ...

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#11

Re: Thinking out of the box, sorry, no link posted

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I tried to post the link but it doesn't show up in my original message. Do I need to preceed the URL with http:// to get it to post?

Well, I guess you can cut and paste:

www.launstein.com

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#12

Ellis Walentine

Yep, can't win

Ellis Walentine

>For several years we had the "http://" right there in the Optional Link URL box, so all you had to do was type the rest of the link address. Only trouble was that 9 out of 10 people just highlilghted and pasted the URL from their browser address bar, and that broke the link, too. Anyhow, yes, you need to type or cut and paste the entire URL.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#13

Re: Thank You very much

Bob Boswood

>After weighing the advice I think I will not use the fir for my flooring. I will find some other use for it. I have so much of it I'll probably never use it all in my lifetime. I like the idea of fake beams if I ever build another house that is. Once again thank you for the good advice. I knew someone with some experience could help me out.

Bob in Ak.

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#14

Re: Thank You very much

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Well, fir was the wood of choice for a lot of floors in BC back in the early/mid part of the last century. Maybe it's the quality of wood, but most of those floors are still going strong. I myself have sanded/refinished more than one and never had a problem.

Rob

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#15

Re: Thank You very much

Fred Davis

>Well Rob ,

your right , Doug Fir VG wood was a popluar flooring choice for those who didn't want the expense of hardwood, the house I grew up in was built in 1905 and floored thru out with Fir flooring.

In this area alot of the Victorian homes , farmhouses and now some new ones going retro, have porches and verandas and the 1x4 T&G clear Doug Fir porch decking is available at all lumber yards and costs far more then flooring grade Oak.

Now ain't that a switch ? ;-))

FredD

Re: Doug Fir Flooring

#16

Ellis Walentine

Agreed

Ellis Walentine

>Doug fir was even used in industrial buildings. Like yellow pine, the soft spring wood is indeed soft, but the hard summer rings help it to bear up under foot traffic. All the floors in my house are softwood -- the original red pine, which is very similar to Doug fir, and white pine of all things in the kitchen addition. As long as I keep a sturdy film finish on the pine, it holds up fine under normal traffic. Not as well as hardwood, though.

Ellis