Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

When is a motor too hot?

Posts

When is a motor too hot?

#1

When is a motor too hot?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Been a while since I've been on the "bright side" :-)

This afternoon I was milling a bunch of maple for a project I'm working on. This involved going from the bandsaw to the jointer, back and forth, to get the dimensions I needed, with the dust collector working all the time. At some point, I touched the DC motor (think Harbor Freight 2 HP with a different color), and it was hot to the point where I could barely keep my finger on it.

I would assume that these machines, while working hard, are designed to withstand continuous use, although in this case (made in China machine) I'm not so sure. I also know that heat is a motor's worst enemy, and I doubt very much that this one is a class F motor...

So the question is, how long (or how hot) can I run a motor before I start damaging it?

TIA,

DC

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#2

Re: When is a motor too hot?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Denis,

It's the insulation on the wire that the coils are wound with that determines how hot the motor will get before the insulation breaks down. The insulation that is used on copper wire can vary from motor manufacturer to another. We really don't know for sure what the Chinese use. Try putting a fan that will move a lot of air aimed at the motor. If the motor feels like it could fry an egg, it's too hot. If the outside is that hot, just think how hot the copper wire is.

Marv

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#3

Re: When is a motor too hot?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Standard quality motors are rated for 40� C/104�F rise during normal use. If it starts at 90�F, add 104�, for a total of 194�. You can hold 125� for only 30 seconds. There may not be anything wrong. Just be sure you don't let all the smoke out of your motor!

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#4

Re: When is a motor too hot?

Galen V

>If the motor is nameplated as a continuous (cont) duty motor then it can run 24 hours a day 7 days a week as long as the ambient temperature is not exceeded. Most motors are nameplated for a maximum ambient of 40C (104F). The cheaper motors are many times only Class A insulation that have a 20,000 hour life at 105C (221F) and allows for a 65C temperature build during operation from the 40C. If you let the ambient temperature exceed 40C by poor air circulation, direct sun outside or nearby heat source then you shorten the hour life. No formula is given for what the life reduction would be.

Frequent starting and stopping can quickly lead to premature failure as the heat cannot disapate fast enough.

Imagine there is no thermal protection to the motor of this type. If there is it is probably not auto reset and the motor is dead, but should be no fire!

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: When is a motor too hot?

Jesper, Denmark

>If you can barely keep your fingers on it, it ia about 40�C or 105�F. This is not a problem for regular squirrekcage motors.

The determinig temperature is in the windings, which you cannot measure by touching the motor.

Letting the DC run continuously is better for it than starting and stopping.

Finally, check the Amps on the motor leads - if less than the motor rating, forget it, you have no problems.

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#6

Re: When is a motor too hot?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Dennis, motors are normally stamped on the nameplate with a "rise above ambient rating" temperature. My memory is sometimes faulty, but I believe the minimum motor design is 40 deg C rise. Add your ambient temperature to the "rated rise" temperature and you will find the safe/normal maximum operating temperature for the motor. Almost all motors can run forever at temperatures that will boil water. (Usually the failure mode is bearings first as the lube degrades and/or runs out of the bearing). - If a motor has sleeve bearings and oil ports, always oil with 30 weight non-detergent motor oil.

However if you want to insure you don't overheat a motor - leave it run rather than stopping and starting. Motors draw a large inrush current when starting and the cooling fan is not up to speed - this can, if repeated too often cause the motor to rapidly build up heat. If I am going to jump between machines in less than a minute or two, I often let them idle. This allows the internal fans to cool the motor, and avoids the high starting inrush current. Of course only do this if it is completely safe. As an aside, I worked in a motor repair shop when I was a lad. I had rebuilt a small motor and had it idling on my bench for about a half hour while I did other tasks. I reached up and put my hand on it to check for heat and vibration - and it just about raised a blister. I did some inspection and determined it had a 100+ deg. C temperature rise. The motor was designed to run at around 300 deg F.! I did look at the nameplates a little more carefully after that.

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#8

Ambient temp @ 115 . . .

steve mackay

>in the shop (El Paso) and EVERYTHING is HOT from the get-go. My concern isn't really with the temp of the motor (I'm sure its fine) but with the sawdust (and other things) laying on it or near it. Seems that bad things rarely happen due to "big things" as opposed to the little things we tend to overlook.

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#9

An easy thing you can do is

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>to Paint it black. Black is the best at giving up heat by radiation.

If it is a light color, all of the heat must be given up by conduction into the air. This may not make the windings any cooler, but it will help dissipate the heat in the rest of the motor.

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#10

Re: An easy thing you can do is

Alexander Grigoriev

>"Paint it black. Black is the best at giving up heat by radiation."

If the black body is 50C above the environment at 30C, it can dissipate 400W per square meter of surface by radiation. Considering size of the motor, that would be 100-150W. Still that's something.

Re: When is a motor too hot?

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

40 degree's C

Jim in Burlington On

>I did get a huge laugh about the paint it black idea. Most of the small single phase motors run hot. Service factor is what will tell you how good the quality of the motor is. They often dip smaller motors to repair them. IMO they don't last and it's not worth it.