OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Why doesn't the power company just shut off the electricity to an area that most certainly will loose power because of storm damage? It seems as if that would at least save transformers.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Why doesn't the power company just shut off the electricity to an area that most certainly will loose power because of storm damage? It seems as if that would at least save transformers.
Re: OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary
>There are breakers that blow open when things short out to protect the transformers. When those breakers blow open, it makes a loud boom, which makes a lot of people think it was the transformer.
Re: OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
>Actually, I've heard of it (planned shut-downs) happening in some instances. Don't know if it would save transformers but it sure seems it would make it safer by eliminating live downed wires.
Re: OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Charlie Self
>The lawsuits might eliminate a few power companies, too. AFAIK, there is no "pull this plug, this block goes out" set up, so shutdowns would necessarily take in people who would not have otherwise lost power. I don't know about yuo, but if a power company decided my freezer full of food could do without electricity for a week or so, I might so inform my insurance company. That would add to the problems those who need electrically operated machinery to stay alive would have in area wide shutdowns.
Yes, they have all those problems IF the area shuts down, but those are nature shutdowns, not business. If it's a business decision to force people to take a chance on their personal back-up systems working, I'd bet the lawyers would be delighted.
Re: OT- Power Company/Hurricane Question
Stuart Johnson
>When hurricane Alicia came through Houston in '83 we lost our power for about a half hour. Our neighbors across the street lost theirs for almost two weeks. I have no idea had the power been shut off if they would have had theirs turned back on earlier. But by not turning off the whole area they did have ours to use.
Thanks
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Thanks for the answers. All make sense except for someone whose life depends upon uninterrupted power. It would be folly not to have back-up power of some kind if your life depended upon it.
Re: Thanks
Fred Davis
>Barbara,
there is a simple solution to power outrages that you will never here utility companies volunteer to implement and that is the under grounding of over head lines in neighborhoods and along roads and highways unless the government ( thats us) insist on it.
In CA where I lived for forty years , they started about twenty years or so making PG@e and Southern Cal utilities underground all new subdivisions and setting aside a percentage of renewal funds to underground existing lines.
This greatly improves uninterrupted service .
If the utility company is left to it's own devices mt hey will tell you it is to expensive, but you will here them scream about expenses after every disaster.
North of Abilene , Kansas where I presently reside , we had a ice storm state wide that shut off our power for a week in zero temperatures last January.
I found my self hauling water in five gallon buckets for stock tanks cussing every backward utility company official and bought off Government official I could think of.
Forward looking city governments like Abilene are requiring under grounding in new subdivisions , but that is all so far.
Yell at your local representative and point out to them what should be obvious , underground all utilities.
FredD
The irony...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>For 11+ years, I lived in a small town where EVERYTHING was overhead. In fact, on the SE corner of my property, and the same corner on the neighbor's across the street to the west each had about 20 lines attached to them in some way, shape or form. Looked like the Spaghetti Junction of overhead lines by my house. We rarely lost power. The worst was about 6 hours, and maybe another half-dozen times of 1/2- to 1 hour in those 11 years. We even made it through an ice storm that had all the lines grow to 2+" without an outage once.
Now, in our new-to-us digs, where all lines in the neighborhood are underground, we've lost power probably at least a half-dozen times in the 15 months we've lived here. Probably 3-4 of those times have been in the 1-4 hour range. There are some clocks in our house that aren't even set now because I'm tired of setting them. Granted, the lines a short ways from the neighborhood go overhead, but still...
Jason, tired of setting clocks, and wanting pro-rated electrical service...
Re: The irony...
Fred Davis
>Give it time Jason, your lines grew 2", ours went down to the ground in places and half way in many others.
Destroyed more trees then you could imagine.
If we are lucky and live long enough and raise enough hell over incompetence, the Naysayers and the "don't rock the boat" people" will die off and common sense will once more be the norm rather then the exception.
FredD
Re: The irony...
kirk constable
>How can they prorate electrical service any more than charging you by usage? Don't know about you, but the $11 monthly 'customer charge' isn't what's killing me... it's the usage. And, of course, usage isn't going up when the power is out. :-)
Re: We NEVER have Hurricanes.........
Jesper, Denmark
>...except for once in 1999!. As a result all power under 11 kV are going underground. The power companies also take this opportunity to run pipe for fiberoptic cables into each house at the same time.
The whole project will likely last another five years. When finished, all the ugly masts will be gone, every house will have access to 20 Megabit internet and the major risk to the power supply is a homeowner with a shovel.
In the cities, the high tension supply wires are already underground. Out here in the countryside, we will have to put up with a few 11 kV lines across the fields.
Back-up power supply Questions????
Barry Irby
>It seems to me that the current hot homeowner item, the back-up generator is another way of letting the power company off the hook. I agree that they should be hardening the power grid to avoid interruptions, but if you had a backup generator, you might see an interruption as a confirmation you were really thinking and ahead of the curve. Only relatively well to-do people can afford permanently installed back-up power supplies. Wouldn't those be the very people we want on the phone to the power company and legislature demanding that as stock holders and consumers and voters they want something done so this power outage is ended and the lines are made tougher so it won't happen again?
On a different note, from the government's point of view, shouldn't they lower the CAFE numbers so cars would use more gas so more money would flow into the coffers from the tax on gasoline? Then they would have the money to fix the roads and bridges.