>I have two associated questions. I am making a traditional style woodworkers bench. I plan to make a section of the top out of � Jatoba. The section is 12 inches wide by 60 inches wide by 2 inches thick and the glue up will require approximately 50 pieces of wood (the pieces to be used are between 12 and 60 inches long). My questions are:
1)What process should I use to glue-up the top? Should I try to glue all of the pieces at one time with the open-time for the glue a concern? Should I glue-up 8 inches of the top first and then append the last 4 inches after the first section is dry? I don�t want to glue-up two separate sections and then glue the two sections together because I don�t want to join the two sections before gluing them together (it would leave more narrow boards where I had to join them). Is there another process I should use.
2) Given what process I should use to glue up the boards, what type of glue should I use?
>That which we call a 'butcher block' is in fact very dissimilar to a real butcher block. The real thing consists of a strongly built table with strong sides raised some 8 inches. Onto this table are placed many approx 12 inch long by approx 2.5 by 2.5 inch pieces of wood (Maple??) standing verticallly. The resulting surface is used to place and cut meat. The table is repeatedly washed and scrubbed with a chlorine solution to maintain hygiene. It is this washing that causes the wood pieces to swell and to remain tight in the table. Remember that meat is cut on the end grain, never on the side as per the vast majority of so called 'butcher block'. Many old blocks are very worn and much prized, one of my friend's (a butcher in the UK) blocks has some 8 inches missing over the major cutting areas .
>I'm no expert on this, but 30 years ago I made such a table from hard maple. I chose to hold all pieces but the outsides with several long "bolts" made from allthread rod, then glued on the outside caps. I used waterproof resin glue. We are still the table today.
>Glueing in sections worked for me! I just completed a similar project, but my center section is made from Ipe (Brazilian Walnut). Used the design and advice from a fairly recent WoodSmith (October 2007, Issue # 173). I glued up 3 sections before finally glueing the sections together. I used clamping cauls to keep the individual 3/4" wide X 1-1/2" thick strips aligned as I drew home the clamps. I also did some amount of loosening - leveling - retightening in order to keep things as flush as possible. Same basic scheme when I put the 3 sections together. I used normal woodworkers glue, at a brisk, but not overly hurried, pace. I had a minimum of surface cleanup and leveling once it was all dried, which I accomplished with a combination of scraper and sander. Had expected that I'd need to haul this huge bugger to the local mill with a big wide belt sander, but it cleaned up easily enough that I didn't need the trip. YMMV.
>A small observation since I've recently been working in both jatoba and hard maple, the more traditional material for butcher block tops.
Jatoba contains a lot of silica and is much harder than hard maple, so much so that it has no apparent "give" whatsoever. A bench has to absorb blows, but the jatoba is more likely to simply transfer the energy to the frame. Jatoba is also brittle, and its splinters hurt. The silica is also hard on tool edges.
Others will probably disagree, but unless you already have the material, I'd go with a maple top rather than jatoba.
>I agree with Garrett. We used Jatoba with pre-engineered flooring for the kitchen in my son's house, and I custom milled the transitions, and fussy bits from raw stock. It's beautiful, resistant to the heavy use, and to my grandsons, and I would use it for furniture in almost every other room. I would hesitate to use it for a joinery bench. It likes a belt sander much more than a hand plane. The maple butcher block I built for their counter looks and works much better as that.
>why would a self proclaimed "traditional woodworker" not make a bench from a traditional wood. As far as the glue up I would thin some yellow or white glue 5% to slow the set time, get some help to slather the glue as well as a 2" paint brush for slathering and have at it. You will need a multitude of strong clamps to get the pressure you need. Keep tightening them as the glue squeezes out. Something to keep the whole assembly aligned will be helpful as the assembly will tend to want to slide apart during initial stages of clamp tightening.
>...is to use white glue and to glue the entire top at once. (If you're adding a dog hole strip, do that later.) I helped build a batch of five benches at Frank's shop a few years ago, and this is how we glued them all. Of course, our laminations were wider than 3/4", so we had fewer glue lines, but a tiny paint roller makes short work of getting the glue on there in a hurry.
My favored method of gluing most flat assemblies, including tabletops, was to apply the glue to all the pieces, arrange them across a series of I-beams (mine were about 2 1/2"W x 4"H x 4'L, faced with masonite and waxed heavily to prevent glue from sticking), put mating I-beams on top, and then clamp all along the length with pipe clamps, alternating over/under orientation. You always need to use an outside clamp caul on each edge to distribute the pressure equally to the glueline and protect the edges of the actual top from clamp impressions. (That's another discussion, if you are unfamiliar with the procedure.) The I-beams raise the assembly high enough off the bench that it makes it easy to get your pipe clamps under it. I prefer pipe clamps or bar clamps for this rather than case-assembly clamps such as Bessey K-bodies, because square jaws are not important but pressure is, and pipe clamps can deliver about twice the clamping pressure of a K-body (not to mention that they are a lot cheaper). I also like the idea of using Weldwood Plastic Resin glue if you want a longer open ass'y time and better water resistance, but you need to be really careful to get clean, flat glue faces, as this kind of glue doesn't bridge even small gaps very well.
>The spacing for beam platforms like this isn't critical. If your stock is straight enough, you can get by with three beam pairs per 8 ft. of length. If there is a lot of surface unevenness in between the beam pairs, you can use intermediate wooden cauls to clamp the laminations flat.
>In the workbench I did of maple, I used roughly 8 2.5" wide pieces and glued in groups of 2 until I got to the final thickness. I used Titebond 2 yellow glue, which I dislike from an open-time perspective. Now, I'll admit that I'm pretty slow at slathering on the glue and clamping, but I could not imagine trying to do all 8 pieces at once!
For anyone recommending plastic resin glue, I am curious on what the cleanup process is? Get it while it's wet? Wait until it dries? Sander, scraper, etc?
For alignment, I ran 1/2" dados down the center and used a thin strip of 1/2" ply in the joint.