Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

Posts

Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#1

JL

Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

JL

>I started cleaning on this old chair. Thus far I've only hit it with mineral spirits. I sanded the back of this little piece that fits under the front of the chair. Well - it ain't oak, that's for sure.

The piece is rather old. I have placed the front piece between a piece of black walnut (bottom) and what is supposed to be mahogany (top). The acetone can is there for color reference. The two bent pieces are included.

I'm glad I didn't hit it with any ammonia based cleaners or lye based cleaners! I haven't found any evidence of residual finish on the piece. Gentle sanding gives me just wood dust. I don't believe it is black walnut due to the color (unless black walnut will fade a lot). It doesn't appear to be a mahogany - the color is off and the pores are wrong. I don't really have an end grain shot that I trust.

So - what wood is it? Other suggestions for cleaning?

TIA


img

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#2

JL

Seat wood

JL

>There were $$#$% idiots in this chair's provenance that stapled a cushion or cover on the chair. As you can see, there are some nice tannin/iron reaction stains. I'll probably have to go the oxalic acid route to clean (or lemon juice and sunshine).


img

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#3

Wood ID

John K Jordan

>JL,

Do you have the book Identifying Wood by Hoadley? It has photos of the end grain of many species and is the best thing I've found to identify or at least narrow down the choices even if the wood has changed color significantly. Find an unobtrusive 1/4" patch of end grain to shave with a razor blade and examine with a 10x hand lens. I generally use a low-power (10x) microscope.

If you don't have the book but have a good macro lens (or simply hold a digital camera up to the eyepiece of a microscope) and can take a picture, I can try to find it in my book. Attached is a sample of a photo I took by hand-holding a camera to my microscope eyepiece, identifiable by the structure as elm.

PS: Did you get a chance to look at the hickory and will it be useful to you?

JKJ


img

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

Dale Lenz

>The bottom piece looks like quarter sawn black walnut, the round thingy could also pass as walnut, from a walk by view, walnut does lighten in time. Iron on walnut will turn the surrounding wood black due to the tannic acid. Many other woods will do the black thing with iron: oaks & cherry for starters...Sorry your pictures are a bit fuzzy, as you said an end grain picture of 10x in decent quality would help greatly. Dale

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#5

Re: Seat wood

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Not sure why, but your post struck a chord with me. I've been one of the #&$^ idiots that have done things like that. I did so because I wanted to use the object, not preserve it for the next guy.

I'm pretty sure it's a safe bet that the modifications done to the chair were done by or paid to be done by a previous owner to make the piece more in keeping with how they wanted the chair to be when compared to how the chair was. Chairs are made to be useful objects - designed to help us day by day. If the requirements for that chair are changed over time or due to circumstance and the chair can be changed to meet the new requirements, it's a well designed object.

As the new keeper of the chair your requirements are different than those of the previous owners. And the first thing you're doing to the chair is what you think is right, but in the process, you're modifying the chair from it's current state. I may be wrong, but I believe that makes you the guy the next owner is most likely to call names.

Rob

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#6

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It looks like walnut. If not stained, walnut will bleach to a light yellow- brown color if exposed to sun light.

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#7

JL

Yes, the hickory was useful - one handle made

JL

>Haven't done anything with the other stuff.

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#8

JL

Re: Seat wood

JL

>I am not the owner of the chair - I'm just rehabbing it. I do see your point. But - the chair had been a caned chair. It still has nice caning holes. My objection lies in not using the caning holes.

Re: Wood ID, rehash of cleaning question...long..

#9

Bart Goldberg

Walnut!

Bart Goldberg

>