Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

Posts

Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#1

Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

charlie belden

>Don�t know which forum this should be posted to but this one�s the most generic.

Mark Sfirri�s article �ANATOMY OF A MASTERPIECE - The 1931 Corner Desk by Wharton Esherick� in the August 2008 issue of Woodwork has had my head spinning since I read it the first time a couple of weeks ago. Almost everything about this piece is what, in the �Sixites�, was referred to as Mind F**K - designed speciifically to Mess With Your Head, especially if you make furniture. There are few square corners, or for that matter few rectangles, with slanting trapezoids and triangles everywhere. And almost every actual surface is visually broken up further through the use of what I think is veneer - triangles within triangles.

If Shaker and Tansu are examples of visual simplicity, and �Scandanavian� the extreme of simplicity - The Corner Desk is WAY at the other end of the design spectrum - out there in the X-Ray and Gamma Ray range. There is almost nothing in this piece that is familiar - and that�s just on the outside of the piece.

In addition to looking extremely different, it functions very differently as well - with hidden hinged folding trianglular parts, trapezoidal drawers with no handles, some side mounted forming slanting trapezoidal surfaces, disquised latches and pull out parts. Almost nothing about this piece is intuitive - a piece of of furniture designed for, or by, a Transformer / GoBot? It�s a piece of Cubist Sculpture made of wood. No, it�s a functional desk, all be it a very odd looking desk. It�s Two, Two, Two Things In One!

Oh look - a built in, cleverly disguised, integerated into the design, swing out desk lamp!

Hey - there�s a secret compartment under here!

This thing�s a Magical Mystery Tour. What a trip!

And then I start examining this thing from the builder�s perspective.

While the Designer may be free to let his/her mind run wild, totally unfettered by some of the constraints reality might impose, it�s the Builder who must try and make the Designer�s vision (or hallucination?) into an actual three dimensional assemblage of wood - that actually functions as a piece of furniture.

THAT lucky (or poor) guy was John Schmidt, �Esherick�s woodworking teacher and lifelong collaborator� - a furniture maker brought up in the European apprenticeship system and thus familiar with joinery and how to make them. The interplay of the collaboration of these two distinctly different men must have been fascinating - Schmidt with his German discipline and precision, Esherick the manic, way �outside the box� designer with plenty of imagination and relatively little furniture making knowledge and skills. I suspect that without Schmidt�s gotten beyond a bunch of lines on a piece of paper (I�ve spent hours and hours with a simple CAD program just trying to do a 3 Views drawing of just the outside of the piece based on photos in the article and even more hours pencil sketching what I THINK I�m seeing in the photos). Yet Esherick has become a furniture maker icon, Schmidt merely mentioned, if acknowledged at all. To his credit, Esherick at least put Schmidt�s initials, J.S., on pieces he played a significant role in making.

And that brings me to my question (finally!).

Why is it that The Designer gets all the glory, recognition and the rewards while The Maker is known only by the hardcore aficianados, if at all - and probably paid by the job or by the hour - if at all.

Think Greene & Greene. Who then thinks Hall?

Think Stickley. Who actually made all those �Stickley pieces�?

Think Wright. Who even knows the name of one of the people who turned his ideas into reality?

Or Charles Comfort Tiffany?

Now think Krenov, Nakashima, Maloof - all Designer AND Maker. What will their place be in the history of 20th Century American Furniture?

charlie belden

ps - attached is a four views drawing I�m working on based on photos in Sfirri�s article. Not to scale and I keep finding lines I�ve missed - but it may give you an idea of just how strange this piece is - and that�s just from the outside. Want to try doing a 3D version in SketchUp in order to get a better idea of how this thing was put together.

pss - if anyone has more images of this piece I for one would surely like to see them - pretty please!


img

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#2

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

Dick Coers

>Isn't that just part of our capitalistic society? It's basically the same thing around here at work. I am not recognized at the top administrative level for the day to day work I do. If I do get recognized, I sure don't get the same bonus as the managers. Car industry the same. You always here about Zora Arkus-Duntov as the hero of the Corvette, but you don't hear anything about the industrial designers, modelmakers, draftsman, builders........ Somebody has to be the genius, somebody has to make it. Never the same.

My bigger complaint along these lines is why can a plumber make more per hour with a truck and wrenches than I can with a shop full of equipment?

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#3

Anybody can cut a dovetail

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#4

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

Fred Davis

>Dick, ,

who do you call when the toilet is stopped up or the furnace or water heater went out in the Winter time on a weekend in foul weather?

When I think of the small plumbing contractor I knew on his first subdivision contract and discovered after about 30 days after the first owner move in, that the toilet bend had not been connected to the waste line, he sucked it up and instead of screaming at his men, he fixed it.

He had the courage to put on a wet suit and go in to correct the plumbing and had his guys hose him down after he came out from under the house, each time .....

He kept his reputation and moved on to bigger and better jobs.

FredD

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#5

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

Dick Coers

>Call a plumber? I was raised on the farm. I put in my own furnace, do all my own plumbing, but I did have a small HVAC guy come out and install the central air. I don't have the equipment for that.

My reference was a comment in general about the lack of respect cabinet and furnituremaking professionals get. I ran a custom woodworking business for 8 years and have been a professional woodworker for 20+, and over 35 years total woodworking experience. If someone hasn't seen my portfolio, they have a general opinion that I am basically a carpenter. Heck, they see that stuff being done on TV with nail guns and such. How tough could it be? Other trades don't seem to have as much of a problem since the public can't go to a big box store and get a product that replaces the skill of the trades. Unlike how they can go get cheap particle board furniture.

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#6

Exception to the rule

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I bet you never heard of Philip Webb. He designed perhaps the most famous piece of furniture of all, but it's called by somebody else's name. What is it?

Clint

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#7

the reason

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>The answer is not too hard to imagine: people (rightly IMO) reward true originality, which is rarer by far than mechanical ability. A quick scan of the work posted on most ww forums will confirm this: great original designs are clearly the exception (and the reason most of us should be making reproductions).

The example you chose certainly has a complicated structure and challenging comstruction. So, sure, yes, the maker should be acknowledged. But since our ecological niche is brainpower, we tend to honor that part of what we accomplish most.

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#8

Re: Exception to the rule

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Google would seem to indicate the William Morris chair to have perhaps been his work.

What do I win?

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#9

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

Fred Davis

>Well Heaven forbid you get lumped in with Carpenters, that would be a experience for sure.

Carpenters not only build the house you live in , the ones temperamentally suited for it go on to run jobs as Foremen,Construction Superintendents, Project Managers, as I did, simple stuff like that.

Along the way I picked up the cabinetmakers trade for my own projects , have been known to make a piece now and then, have more requests for it then I ever will respond to.

I quit using a portfolio of Kitchen and Bath projects years ago , just didn't need one , word of mouth took over. That in my opinion is the best form of notice of your talent and it doesn't cost anything, but your best effort.

But I digress.

By the way , how small was that HVAC guy??

FredD

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#10

You got it

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>First Prize: A wealthy Nigerian will contact you soon to share his $millions if you just give him your bank account information.

Clint

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#11

Drat! I wanted that!!!!

John in New Mexico

>

Re: Designer Gets The Credit - The Maker?

#12

And another...

John in New Mexico

>Tell me who first designed the Parsons table (named I understand after the Parsons School of Design). Clint will handle awarding of the prize.