legitimate option
Michael Dresdner
>What Howard suggested is true -- first ascertain if there is value enough in it to leave as is, or do nominal finish repairs such as white ring removal and French polishing. If not and you decide you would still like to refinish it, you still have an option that is quite durable enough for everyday use and still appropriate to the period: oil based varnish. It, along with shellac, was one of the two common furniture finishes used in the 1800's, is still around, and has high enough heat, abrasion, chemical, water and stain resistance to deal with heavy use.
Bear in mind that this mania for not refinishing antiques is a fairly recent one. In the time period your table is from, refinishing was considered a perfectly acceptable option for antiques and not one that, assuming it was done properly, would diminish its value. Such fashions change with the times and may yet change again if a new and different thinking batch of conservators takes over Antiques Roadshow. What makes something valuable is whatever we all agree is important for it to be valuable, and nothing more. How else could one account for an oil painting worth 93 million dollars when another oil painting from the same period and using the same materials, but from a different artist, is worth next to nothing?