Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

lightfastness of colors for mahogany

Posts

lightfastness of colors for mahogany

#1

lightfastness of colors for mahogany

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I need to finish the mahogany piece I made in the class in the Headley workshop. I have no experience finishing mahogany so I have been experimenting. There are three commonly practiced ways to color mahogany plus one I added.

The experiment: A stripe of color was made on a mahogany board. Half this stripe was masked from light and the board put in a light fastness testing machine simulating direct sunlight through a window. After 5 days exposure to these accelerated conditions the piece was removed and comparisons made. Referring to the picture, the entire piece on the left was exposed to ammonia fumes. At first the wood assumed a nice red brown color which changed to a neutral brown walnut color after a few days, which I didn't find attractive. The left portion was masked from the light. While it does not show in this picture, the exposed portion was a bit lighter in shade but the color was not much changed by the light. I conclude this color is light fast, but ugly.

On the top right, the dye was lye. When fresh it was a pink color but it darkened after a few days, loosing some of the pink. This color faded completely upon light exposure. In the Articles section a coloring procedure is described using lye, which produces the same color as lime. I do not recommend this coloring procedure becasue it is not light fast.

The middle stripe is antique cherry analine dye, water based. Some of the red component of this color fades upon exposure. The expert that ran this test for me judged this color to be the most light fast of the colorants evaluated.

The bottom is colored by potassium dichromate. While this colorant is traditional and pretty, dichromate is a known carcinogen when inhaled, which would be easy to do when sanding after application.

Conclusions: Water based analine dyes are as good as anything and a lot safer to use than dichromate.

Note: I tried making the differences more noticeable by over coating with shellac after fading. This addition was a failure. The shellac reflection make it harder to see differences. The shiny places are where the shellac didn't absorb in the wood as much.


img

Re: lightfastness of colors for mahogany

#2

let's go further

Michael Dresdner

>"There are three commonly practiced ways to color mahogany plus one I added."

Actually, there are many commonly practiced ways, and you did not even mention the one that is far and away the most common, but let's take a look at your test and I will get to that one at the very end.

While it was a reasonable and sensible approach, the sad truth is that you did not go far enough, and as a result, some of your conclusions might mislead some readers here.

While short term QUV testing, such as what you did, will indicate relative degrees of fading, it is certainly not absolute. Ammonia fuming, a common chemical stain treatment, is more lightfast than some (but not all) dyes, but it is fugitive, and substantially more so than most pigments, for instance. The same, by the way, is true of all chemical stains, including potassium dichromate; they tend to have decent short term and low dosage fade resistance, but they do fade over time or with higher dosage.

As for dyes, bear in mind that many of the dyes sold today are not aniline (please note the spelling -- there is only one a in aniline), and many of the second generation dyes often sold under the general rubric 'aniline dye' are substantially more lightfast than their coal tar derived predecessors. The irgasperse and organasol dyes developed by Ciba Geigy and widely sold today, for example, are highly light fast, and bear little resemblance to true aniline dyes, which tend to be very fugitive. It's one of the reasons I am a big fan of dropping the word aniline; it's just misleading in so many cases.

I will say that if you simply drop the word 'aniline' from your last sentence and change it to 'lightfast,' I would agree completely. Lightfast dyes, which abound at woodworking specialty stores, are indeed far safer and easier to use than any chemical staining process. They are also more predictable and ultimately may be notable more lightfast, depending on which dyes you choose.

As for my promise to address the most common coloring method; the one thing you left out was pigment. Stains made from pigments are often completely lightfast, and even slow the rate at which the wood itself changes color. These days there are several companies selling ultra fine grind pigments that act more and more like dyes in terms of how they color wood, but still retain their fade resistance.

Re: lightfastness of colors for mahogany

#3

Re: let's go further

Mac in Indy

>Thank you Michael for the informative response. I have used Behlens Light Brown Mahogony NGR dye stain on all my mahogony projects to establish a background color. Is it one of the "new" lightfast dye stains you speak of? how can we tell the difference between the lightfast and older aniline dye you say is less lightfast?

By the way I follow the Lt Brn Mahog dye stain with a sprayed on coat of lacquer, a dark brown gel stain used as a glaze, and then a couple more coats of lacquer. I love the results!


img

Re: lightfastness of colors for mahogany

#4

you have to ask them

Michael Dresdner

>Unfortunately, asking the vendor is the only real way to know how light fast or fugitive the dye you are buying will be. They will know. Let's hope they will be honest with you. Since he is a popular source on this message board, I can tell you that Jeff Jewitt's dyes, both the TransFast and the TransTint, are VERY light fast. His company is called Homestead Finishing. www.homesteadfinishing.com