Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

Posts

Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#1

Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Folks -

I'm trying to decide if it's worthwhile to purchase a load of these bricks of compressed dust/chips/wood - one brand name is Biobricks, another is called Liberty Blocks. My understanding is that they are similar to the pellets made for pellet stoves, but can be put in regular woodstoves.

I get my regular wood "free" - lots of work, but I don't purchase it. It is supplemental for me, with regular oil heat being my main source. However, if the bricks, as touted, really do burn evenly and slowly, they might be useful for overnights, so I'm thinking of shelling out $$ for them. They go for about $270/ton.

Does anyone have any experience with these? Do they really burn differently than well-seasoned cordwood? Is there some way to figure out a rough price comparison, BTU for BTU, with oil?

Thanks -

Ken


Biobricks

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#2

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Don't know about these Ken, but I heated solely with wood for about seven years. If your current stove won't burn well overnight, you may want to invest in a better stove. I had a large airtight stove with a intake air "thermostat". It had a bi-metal spring that controlled the heat intake air via sensing the heat at the stove. I could load the stove with decent wood (dried oak, locust, sycamore, etc. and it would burn well for 16 hours - putting out about 80M btu/hr. My house is a story and a half 4 bedroom built in about 1882. I did replace all windows and insulated it well, but had no problem heating to 80 deg with outside temps at -10 F. (I did have an old restored small Pot belly stove in my kitchen at the time I used when it got really cold &/or very windy - mostly to get more heat to areas far from my primary stove.) My son used a friends corn/ pellet wood stove - it didn't really impress me but did work pretty well. I had surgery on my back/neck a few years ago and decided I couldn't cut or handle the wood any more. I now have a NG High efficiency furnace both in my house and shop (with central air).

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#3

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

Paul Leuba

>Ken:

The following web site has a table on energy conversion units to allow the computation you would need to assess the relative efficiencies of heating oil vs. other fuels, such as, wood, or wood shavings and sawdust. Using the table, 1 gallon of fuel oil yields 135,000 BTU. If the furnace is at 85% efficiency, then the delivered heat will be 114,750 BTU, or so. At $4.50 per gallon, this is 25,500 BTU per Dollar.

For wood, listed at 7,870 BTU per pound, a ton is a total of 2000 lbs per ton x 7,870 BTU per pound = 15,740,000 BTU per ton. At @ $240 per ton this yields 65,583 BTU per Dollar @ 100% efficiency. If the wood stove is running at 85% efficiency it will yield about 55,500 BTU per Dollar. This is over 2X the yield per Dollar of fuel oil.

However, the table also lists sawdust/shavings at 3,850 BTU per pount, or about 1/2 the wood value. So, depending on the acutal makeup of the bricks, you could get efficiency somewhere between equal with fuel oil, or 2X fuel oil.

An accurate BTU value for the bricks would be needed to make a good estimate of the relative efficiencies, but it appears that there is some savings to be had. An important variable is the efficiency of the wook burning stove.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD


http://www.generatorjoe.net/html/energy.html

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#4

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks

Curly Smith

>What does a cord of wood cost in your area? This site suggest that it's might be a rather poor deal Wood Heating and Weight Values since a cord weighs more than a ton and, as Paul mentions, it has a higher BTU content.

Any reason that you can't hire some high school kids to cut wood?

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#5

Better stove economics

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Man, I'd love to get a really nice stove. I'm held back by the structure of my house, which pretty much dictates that I have to have one of the kind that inserts into a fireplace, which limits us somewhat. There just really isn't any good place to put a freestanding stove. And, since I really just use the wood as a supplement, it just isn't worth the time/effort/expense at this point in life to try to have a good stove installed somehow. It's really a pity - I've seen how well one can heat a house with a proper stove in a good spot.

I'm sure envious though when I see a house that really can take advantage of a good stove. Thanks for the info.

Ken

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#6

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Paul, many thanks. I looked at that site, but am not sure I understand the sawdust lower number, as I thought that pretty much all wood had the same BTU/pound, being all basically the same stuff chemically, just different densities for each species. Anyhow, I appreciate the assistance. Looks like it might be worthwhile to try a pallet of the stuff and see if I like it.

Ken

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#7

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Even though I'm getting up there in age, I still do ok with my sledge and maul. High school kids around here (including mine) seem mostly interested in their cell phones. It's only the geezers like me who want to split wood.

Seriously, I have a decent supply of regular cordwood, enough for the immediate future. I was mostly interested in whether this stuff might be better in some ways for my situation, as an adjunct to the firewood I've split, let it go farther, etc.

I'm still unsure, but might give it a try. Maybe some folks who've used it will chime in too. Thanks for the reply,

Ken

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks *LINK*

#8

Re: Semi-OT: Economics cordwood vs bricks

Paul Leuba - Hunt Valley, MD

>Ken:

If your going to try some of the composite wood bricks for heating, please post information on your experience. It would be quite helpful to many of us to learn of the results of your trial comparing the heat output of the bricks to split wood.

Paul