Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

Posts

Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#1

Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

Doug in Denver

>I made a table top - 38" X 67" - that is all heartwood cherry 1" thick. It is made up of 6 boards. I used biscuits. When I went to square the ends, I stupidly forgot which biscuits were closer to which end, and cut ever so slightly into the holes where there is play for the biscuits. Did not actually reach the biscuits themselves. So I have a top with five little rectangular holes holes in one end, each the thickness of a slot cutter blade and maybe half again that long - pretty small. Of course I could fill them and nobody but me would ever know probably, but yuck, that idea does not appeal to me. All I know for sure is I really don't want to add bread board ends.

What other options are there that maybe I have not thought of? One option I thought of was since I have put a band of walnut near the bottom of each leg, and put a thin walnut band aroun the skirt bottom, I could route a real shallow groove and add a thin inlay strip of walnut around the whole edge, but would that gap at the corners as the top expanded no mattter how thin I make it? Any other ideas? Thanks.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Cut an end grain plug the width of a biscuit

steve antonucci

>Glue it in, pare it down with a chisel. Even you won't be able to find it.

Steven

P.S. Use a scrap from the same boards...

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#3

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?------

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundaryx2CO+cQCkYnfS8AP

>Put in a Dutchman. Cut some of the matching scrap you must have left over to fit the slots -slightly enlarging them if necessary- then glue them in with end grain showing. This will match the end grain of the table ends. Once finished they shouldn't be noticed.

------WebKitFormBoundaryyNwL+7NPNr1xADKT

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#4

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

John McGaw

>As other have written you can plug the holes. Of course unless you are committed to the exact dimensions you quoted, you could simply cut enough off of the "problem" end to get past the biscuit slots and it will be as if they didn't exist. I guess my idea comes from never using plans for anything so that anything goes.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#5

I never see the simple solution

Doug in Denver

>Putting in tiny endgrain plugs never occured to me. Really. And they allow me to drive a car! Thanks.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#6

agree...ban the biscuits forever

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>and don't ever use biscuits again as they are of no use in edge gluing. They do not strengthen a joint. And if you glue a top such as this, one board at a time, you will achieve better alignment than using biscuits.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#7

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>don't forget to align the plug growth rings the same way. This is really an easy fix if done with some care.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#8

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

Jim Dillon

>Doug,

Having made that same mistake but not, so far 8-), in an area that would be visible in the final project, I can appreciate your frustration. I agree with the others that a simple plug cut from the same board (the piece you accidently cut off for example) would be so easy to do and the plug size is so small that only you would know it was there. Somewhat more adventuresome would be a larger ebony/walnut inlay/plug done on both ends but that might not fit in with the style of your table. Now, if you want to buy a new tool to solve your problem, may I suggest a Festool Domino. Takes about 10 minutes to do a breadboard and 7 minutes of that is deciding where to put the mortises. In fact, I did one yesterday and it sure is slick. But I say this sorta tongue-in-cheek as it is way overkill for your problem. However, if you want to spend some money ... 8-).

Jim

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#9

Jim:

paul in AZ

>"Somewhat more adventuresome would be a larger ebony/walnut inlay/plug"

I've done that on purpose with approx. 1/4X 1 1/4 inch cherry strip inset into an ash table top almost 3 feet wide. The plug was laid flat [not end grain] and only where the two outermost boards joined.

It worked out rather well as a little accent to the end grain ash but of course nobody ever notices.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#10

Bill, can you clarify...

Dan Mitchell

>"And if you glue a top such as this, one board at a time, you will achieve better alignment than using biscuits."

Are you saying if you're gluing up a top, say 5 boards wide, you should glue the 1st 2, let the glue set, glue on another board, let the glue set, and do the same for each of the last 2 boards? If so, why is this superior, if not, what am I missing?

TIA

Dan

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#11

I'll try.........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, a disclaimer. How I currently assemble a panel is to glue up skip-dressed lumber and run the panel through a wide planer. If the panel is wider than the planer then I do the above with sub panels and then glue the sub panels together after planing. However, in days past...........

My guiding principal is that I can get one joint perfect with some care, but I can't get 4 at a time perfect. So If I am assembling sub panels, or in the past a panel from several boards, I would glue them one at a time, taking care to get each joint perfectly, or near so, aligned. There are too many things moving about to get 4 joints perfectly aligned all at once. It saves a lot of belt sanding.

With yellow glue an hour in the clamps is plenty of time to move on to the next board, presuming the lumber is dry and it is reasonably warm. I have run panels through a planer after an hour., if pressed for time

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#12

Thanks Bill

Vincent - Azle, Texas

>I have done that very thing, and felt like a novice doing it. Well, lets face it, I am a novice. But it's nice to see that a pro does the same, or did.

I only have a 12" planer and I would glue up two sets of two boards, plane them and then glue them together, only gluing one joint at a time. Took more time, but I'm pretty sure it was more than made up for in the work of scraping and sanding.

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#13

Re: Jim:

Jim Dillon

>Paul,

I agree that it can be quite a nice feature and makes the tabletop a little less ordinary - even if no one notices 8-). Right now I am two-thirds done building Darell Peart's Greene & Greene style Aurora end table and used the domino to cut all the exterior mortises in the top for both the stationary and sliding ebony "plugs". But then those details define the G&G style.

Jim

Re: Help me fix mistake in Cherry table top?

#14

Thanks for the info

Dan Mitchell

>I'll try your approach next time.