Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Plumbing problem (OT)

Posts

Plumbing problem (OT)

#1

Plumbing problem (OT)

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Our house is on a slab with embedded water lines. A leak in the cold line somewhere is showing up where the line exits the slab, in the wall, that serves an outside faucet. The faucet and line from where it exits the slab is OK. Assuming that the leak is in the dedicated branch for the outside faucet, my thought is to kill the branch by pumping something into line from the outlet end that will plug it from the inside. I don't know yet if there's such a thing, and I'd have to guess how much to inject so the main doesn't get blocked.

My wife suggests bulldozing and building our dream house.

Suggestions?

Clint

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#2

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Do you have the plans from when the house was built? I don't think they can do joints under the slab, so maybe there is a place in the wall somewhere which could be found, and cut and blocked there.

It would probably be the nearest cold water line to this faucet. Are there any bathrooms or kitchen near? It will likely T off of the line somewhere above the slab inside the wall.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#3

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Thanks. No plans, but I'll check into the wall possibilities.

Clint

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#4

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Barry Irby

>Clint, As far as I know they are not allowed to put connections under the slab so the pipe should loop from some where else. If you can psych out where the other end is you could cut it there and cap the supply.

I don't know of any internal sealant that might work.

Actually, I agree with your wife.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#5

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Here in Seattle we have a company that does nothing but in place pipe relining, should be worth checking out. just do asearce for Pipe relining

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#6

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I am not a plumber but I worked as a maintenance man for several years where the plumbing (copper) was in or under a slab.

This was all hard copper, and I cannot for the life of me see any way the job could have been done WITHOUT having connections or joints under the concrete. Even if connections to various fixtures are accessible above the slab, you are going to have to have 90�s and 45s� to get the pipes from under the slab to above the slab. Plus, you are going to be using couplings in a lot of places that will ultimately be under the slab.

I�m not sure what method is needed to locate the leak, but I�m pretty sure the fix involves a jackhammer. As has already been suggested, a larger jackhammer, i.e. a bulldozer might not be that bad an idea.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#7

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

steve mackay

>Only a thought but . . . FIL had the dude with the "radar" thingie look through the concrete to find a broken drain pipe under the slab. I guess they found it and the next item in the conversation included a jack hammer. As to re-lining . . . I know they did my folks (the whole street into the houses) gas lines but they had both ends open. I think I'd be snooping through all my walls to find another option before busting concrete. No matter how carefully you bust it I'd think the pipe is going with it.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#8

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Barry Irby

>Locally, when they use copper, they switch to soft copper for the loops under the slab, so that there are no fittings under the floor. Also, the pipe run under the slab, not in it.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#9

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Fred Davis

>Responsible Plumbing contractors do not use jack hammers on relocating plumbing lines in a slab or finding a leak because most building codes do no allow it.

The vibration from the hammer does far more damage to joints then the leak you are looking for has.

The procedure generally uses listening devices for locate the approximate spot of the leak and then the slab is cut with a wet concrete saw, pipe replaced and trench mortared in.

FredD

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#10

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Barry Irby

>Clint, There may be companies around that can find the leak by one of several methods. Can listen for it or look for it with an infrared scanner.

You might be able to find it yourself by turning on the water at the outside faucet and then carefully listening for the sound of the water in the pipe. You could try using a funnel or wine glass as a stethoscope. The premise behind the infrared is that the wet area will be cooled by the evaporation. Of course, you already know where that is. But, they might be able to "see" the pipe under the concrete if the water is distinctly colder than the surrounding area.

(I saw a "picture" they took of a motor. Amazing. You could see right through the motor and see the internal parts almost like an X-ray.)

In either case, I would expect them to charge you something on the order of $300 for the service.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#11

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Do you have the plans from when the house was built? I don't think they can do joints under the slab, so maybe there is a place in the wall somewhere which could be found, and cut and blocked there.

It would probably be the nearest cold water line to this faucet. Are there any bathrooms or kitchen near? It will likely T off of the line somewhere above the slab inside the wall.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#12

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Thanks, All, for the responses. As there doesn't appear to be any way to find and plug the leak from the inside, and relining is not technically or economically feasible, I think the best solution is to re-plumb as much as necessary to fix things. So tomorrow, it's tear into the wall that the well tank feeds into.

I guess that's why it's called Labor Day weekend.

Clint

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#13

Good luck !

steve mackay

>

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#14

Re: plumbing problem --insurance?

Steve Schoene

>I hope you do realize that there are circumstances where broken pipes and the resulting damage can be covered by homeowners insurance. Policies do differ in coverage so check your policy, and consider a professional estimate before you tear everything up. At least take photos and document the causes of the damage.

Re: Plumbing problem (OT)

#15

This may be to late but...

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Unfortunately I have way to much practice at finding leaks in conctere slabs. I maintain a few thousand square feet (like 20-30 thousand) of heated concrete slab used to melt snow. I have tried listening devices and thermal imaging but the lines are only 1 foot apart and a water leak is hard to hear. The best luck we have had is to hook the water line to an air compressor and grab wooden broom handle as a listening aid. Pressurized air makes a lot more noise than water. The other trick which won't work in your case is to wait for a damp day heat the system up, close all the return lines and look for a dry spot in the concrete. Only the leaking line will have flow and then only as far as the leak. I use a very small concrete drill with hammer only capability. SDS chuck size like a Bosch Bulldog. Some iron pipe afte 20 years in concrete looks brand new and some, just a few feet way, has holes the size of you thumb, I sure wish I knew why.

good luck glc