Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

Posts

handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#1

handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

paul mayer

>I have read a few different sets of instructions on cutting dovetails, and they either suggest that you set the depth of the scribe line to either the thickness of the stock, or slightly less than the thickness of the stock. Wouldn't it make more sense to set it a hair deeper than the thickness of the stock, which would allow the pins and tails to slightly protrude, making the flush sanding or planing much easier than if they are slightly recessed below the face of the mating board? What am I missing?

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#2

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

wilbur

>Actually, setting the scribe line a hair deeper than the stock is what I do, for exactly the reason you state.

Of course, I would think hard about any dovetail advice I have to give, unless you want your dovetails to be as crappy as mine. :@)

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#3

depends

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>For a lipped drawer setting the pins proud enables them to be pared off with a chisel leaving a bright attractive surface. For an inset drawer there is something to be said for the following procedure....

Fit drawer front to the opening with desirable clearance (I shoot for a scant 1/16", total). Fit sides slightly proud. After drawer assembly plane sides down to pins in front and to fit in back . It is not a difficult task planing the sides if the sides are a straight grained soft wood as they should be. This procedure guarantees a perfect fitting drawer or at least as perfect as the drawer front was fit to begin the porcess.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#4

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

Fred Davis

>You sound right on to me Paul , I have made a few dovetail drawer boxes in my time and never used soft wood for sides, never heard it recommended and besides being easier for some people to work , I can't think of a compelling reason to substitute softwood for stunning drawer sides out of quarter sawn Sycamore , curly Maple, ribbon grain Mahogany and so forth.

Well made drawer boxes are a hallmark of craftsmanship and add their own special look to a piece of fine furniture or just plain old kitchen cabinets.

FredD

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#5

Re: depends

paul mayer

>I should clarify, and perhaps this answers my question. I am cutting through dovetails for the carcase of a large base for a gun cabinet. So, for half-blind dovetails (probably the far more common type), I could see why you would want to scribe it a bit under the thickness, to ensure that you can fit the drawer together. Since I am doing through dovetails, I will not have the problem of the pieces not fitting together if they pins and tails stand proud of the mating panel. They will slide together and I will sand them off. I believe this mystery is solved. I am headed to the shop right now to test this theory...

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#6

Re: depends

Sgian Dubh

>No-one yet has mentioned to you yet another reason for setting the cutting gauge just a whisker shy of the wood's thickness.

It's related to assembly of dovetails in general including through dovetails and assembly of such items as drawer boxes.

If you intentionally mark the shoulder line of dovetails a whisker deep the end grain of tails and/or pins protrude at assembly. What happens if you need to apply a bit of cramping pressure to fully close the joint? you can't just slap a block of wood across the ends of the corners and put a cramp on because the pressure is against the end of the protruding pins or tails. There is a solution, but it's a bit fiddly.

Set the cutting gauged shoulder line a hair shy of the wood thickness and the exterior faces of the tails and/or pins protrude a bit. Here it's easy to slap on those wood corner blocks and tighten up the joint.

Whichever option you go for, ie, shoulder line a bit deep or a bit shy is up to you. I don't think either is right or wrong. I use both, but in reality I set the cutting gauge a whisker shy probably 95%+ of the time. I do this because experience has taught me this setting produces good dovetails faster and with a lot less aggravation. I'm all for that because time is money as the old saying goes, and nearly every form of dovetail I execute is for money, not for fun. Slainte.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#7

You learn something new everyday

wilbur

>Actually, I have never heard the rationale for setting the scribe line a hair short the way you explained it. But that makes a lot of sense, especially since planing the face grain to bring the joint flush should be easier than planing the endgrain of the protruding ends.

Thanks for the tip! I'll try it next time I do dovetails.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#8

Re: You learn something new everyday

Sgian Dubh

>We are talking just the tiniest whisper shy wilbur. If you get it right it leaves just the lightest skimming to do with a plane afterwards, or scouring up with a sanding machine if electric woodworking is your preference.

It tends to mean that cramps are seldom needed on small to medium boxes because you whack the corners together with a protective block of wood and meaty hammer blows probably 90%+ of the time. And if you do need a cramp or two, which is almost always the case anyway if you're working on big things like chests, try using a bit of MDF as a cramping block, not solid wood. The MDF flakes off the assembled and glued corner nicely without tearing out a chunk of your valuable and attractive solid wood carcass.

You may like the 'shy of the thickness' shoulder line technique or you may not in the end, but as you say it's probably worth experimenting with on a job or two. Slainte.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#9

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

Chris Friesen

>Traditionally the sides, backs, and bottoms of drawers as well as dust frames, runners, kickers, etc. were all made of a cheaper secondary wood and often not even finished.

Since most of the time drawers are kept closed, very few people would ever appreciate any fancier materials.

Of course, it's up to the maker/customer to decide how much effort to put into different parts of a project.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#10

here is a reason for "soft" drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is very much simpler to repair a worn drawer side than the groove that a hard side eventually cuts into the drawer support pieces.

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#11

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

paul mayer

>Well, I cut some practices cuts with the baseline exactly at the thickness, a hair under the thickness, and a hair over the thickness of the stock. To me, they were all fine. I decided to go with my original instinct and build the production piece with the baseline a bit deeper than the stock thickness. Now I have a lot of end grain sanding ahead of me, so after that, I might wish that I had set the baseline at the exact depth of the stock thickness.

Thanks for everyone's input!

Cheers,

Paul

Re: handcut dovetails; scribing the baseline

#12

Re: next time i will set to exact depth

paul mayer

>The sanding of the end grain is not fun. I have about 1/32" of end grain across a 19" span of 5/4 rock maple, x 2 corners. Not fun!

Next time I will set the baseline depth to exactly the thickness of the stock, and the sanding will be much quicker...