Re: depends
Sgian Dubh
>No-one yet has mentioned to you yet another reason for setting the cutting gauge just a whisker shy of the wood's thickness.
It's related to assembly of dovetails in general including through dovetails and assembly of such items as drawer boxes.
If you intentionally mark the shoulder line of dovetails a whisker deep the end grain of tails and/or pins protrude at assembly. What happens if you need to apply a bit of cramping pressure to fully close the joint? you can't just slap a block of wood across the ends of the corners and put a cramp on because the pressure is against the end of the protruding pins or tails. There is a solution, but it's a bit fiddly.
Set the cutting gauged shoulder line a hair shy of the wood thickness and the exterior faces of the tails and/or pins protrude a bit. Here it's easy to slap on those wood corner blocks and tighten up the joint.
Whichever option you go for, ie, shoulder line a bit deep or a bit shy is up to you. I don't think either is right or wrong. I use both, but in reality I set the cutting gauge a whisker shy probably 95%+ of the time. I do this because experience has taught me this setting produces good dovetails faster and with a lot less aggravation. I'm all for that because time is money as the old saying goes, and nearly every form of dovetail I execute is for money, not for fun. Slainte.