Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tung oil or Teak Oil?

Posts

Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#1

Tung oil or Teak Oil?

Vincent - Azle, Texas

>I am going to sand in a drying oil on Bz. Cherry. I'll let it cure while out of town for the long weekend and then apply several coates of poly. I had planed on using Watco Danish oil but my local store only has the colored varieties on hand.

Being Bz. Cherry and very hard, similar to teak, I am considering using teak oil. After my recent woes with the hand rubbed oil finish on my white oak, I am naturally a little more cautious than usual.

I would much appreciate input from some of you guys out there.

Thanks,

V.

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#2

Too slow!

Vincent - Azle, Texas

>Well, you old guys are just to deliberate, and hour and a half is just too long for a young buck to wait for advice.

I went ahead and sanded in the teak oil. And Holy crap! was that a lot more work than I wanted it to be! And apparently, sanding in uses twice as much product as just wipe on, wipe off.

I had planned to do both the formal dinning and the study tonight, but the study will have to wait, I'm short on oil. And thank goodness, I'm tuckered out.

I'm off to bed, not that I'll get to go to sleep. The LOML is a night owl and I'm a morning person.

See you at 0500, aka o dark hundred.

Booth

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#3

Re: Too slow!

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Not sure why you're "sanding in" the oil. In fact, with your plans to coat with poly, I'm not sure why you're using oil at all. Not that there's any harm in doing it that way but...

Brazillian cherry (Jatoba) sands nicely and even though it's a dense wood, it's got some open pores. When you "sand in" oil, these pores will fill and while slight, will tend to cause muddiness in the clarity of any finish you put on the wood.

If it's your intention to fill the pores, you'd be further ahead to sand to your final grit, vacuum with an upholstery brush attachment making sure to "scrub" the surface with the brush, apply several coats of SealCoat (dewaxed blonde shellac) and then using a scraper (not sandpaper), scrape the product off the major portion of the surface, leaving it only to remain in the pores. This will level your surface and prepare it for your polyurethane top coats. As SealCoat dries in about 20 minutes, you can apply/scrape/apply/scrape several times in an hour and get the pores etc. filled in no time.

As for oil first, then poly - it's a nice idea, but tends to be a waste of time. Assuming you're using an oil based polyurethane - it's already got oils in it. After application and prior to the poly drying, these oils will penetrate the Jatoba in exactly the same way as the drying oils you're using, and the end effect will be the same. An oil "primer" won't offer any more chatoyance than poly itself. BUT - if your wish is to darken the wood a bit, you can use a "prime coat" of BLO prior to the poly. This will add a bit of colour to the equation. If you do this, you'd be wise to let the BLO set up (crosslink) for several days (a week preferred) prior to applying the poly. Although truth be told - I rarely wait that long.

Good luck!

Rob

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#4

Thanks Rob, How about thinned poly?

Vincent - Azle, TX

>I'm not much of a hand at applying poly, have had a couple of bad experiences to prove it. Any harm or benifit in thinning the poly and just applying more coates to get the final finish?

Also, I have already sanded in the teak oil, wiped if off and reapplied twice. I'll let this cure over the long weekend before applying the polyurethane.

Any suggestions on how to minimize the cloudiness that you mentioned?

Thanks,

Booth.

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#5

Re: Thanks Rob, How about thinned poly?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Nothing wrong with thinning poly. In fact it's an inexpensive way to make your own "wipe-on poly". Careful not to use too much thinner though. 30% is an absolute max - I add enough so the drag is reduced on the cloth as I apply it - it's a feel thing. In fact I use poly like this all the time - brushes and me don't get along too well all the time :)

As for the clarity, scraping the surface with a sharp cabinet surface will brighten things up for you. You may want to try a small section to see if you think the effort is worth-while.

rob

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#6

Re: Thanks Rob, How about thinned poly?

Tony - Memphis

>Another option is gel poly (I use Rockler). I've built a few things out of some jatoba I got on sale to play with. With a few coats of gel poly, the stuff is beautiful. Mine was difficult to work, but it sure is pretty. It has a nice glow to it. All I did was sand and apply the gel.

Tony

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#7

Re: Thanks Rob, How about thinned poly?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Sorry, but I think gel poly is a gimmick. It's a cool product, but it's a gimmick.

Gel stain makes some sense as the increased viscosity means better control of the product on woods that tend to blotch when stained, but that concept, when translated to poly is wasted. There's no need to reduce penetration time when applying poly. In fact it could be argued that in order to achieve a better mechanical bond between poly and the wood, lower viscosity is better.

Save your "gel poly" money and spend it on other aspects of your project. You'll be miles ahead. If you want to apply a poly finish by hand, thin regular poly by 10 - 25% (depending on your project etc.) or if you really have to spend $$, buy prepared wipe-on-poly. Either one will deliver an excellent finish that's easily controllable by you

Rob

Re: Tung oil or Teak Oil?

#8

I disagree completely

Michael Dresdner

>I'm sorry, Rob, but I don't agree with you at all on this one.

There is no difference in the way gel polyurethane and liquid polyurethane adhere. In fact, there is almost no difference at all between the two except for the fact that the gel does not drip so much, making it a bit easier to handle. In many cases, depending on the company involved, the solids content of the gel and liquid are identical, as are the resins used. Bear in mind that most gels are thixotropic, or at least pseudoplastic, so their viscosity at rest does not affect how they address the wood in terms of adhesion, wetting, or even absorption.

Either way, you will build a finish much faster using either liquid polyurethane right out of the can, or gel right out of the can, than you will if you buy wipe on poly, which usually has less resin, or if you reduce liquid polyurethane, which does nothing but make you buy paint thinner.

Adding thinner to any oil based material does not change it, since the thinners you are adding are diluents, not solvents. In other words, the molecular size and weight does not change when you add paint thinner, and that is almost totally what controls how far the resin will be absorbed by the wood.