Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

Posts

OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

#1

OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

Tony V

>I have a cedar sided house with painted wood trim. The gutters need to be replaced. There are also a few facia boards and pieces of soffit that need to be replaced. I figured that while I have someone putting up new vinyl gutters that I would have them install vinyl soffit at the same time. When talking it over with the installer, we talked about cutting the siding at the point where the j channel attaches to the side of the house so that the j chanel lays flat against the house. he alternative is to put the j channel directly over the boards and have gaps where the boards overlap. This would also mean that if I needed to replace any siding that I would have to cut at the j channel to get the board out.

What is the best thing to do in this situation? Does anyone have any experience or suggestions. I guess that putting the j channel over the siding is more common due to reactions that I am getting from installers. Putting the j channel over the soffit is cheaper but I think it might look cheaper too. One estimate refused to cut for the j channel saying that I would be dissatisfied with the result due to chip out at the cut edge.

Please advise

Tony V

Re: OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

#2

Re: OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

Fred Davis

>Tony ,

talk to a contractor that does all around exterior and interior work, not some fly by nite vinly siding companies installer who will only tell you what he wants to do , not what is appropriate or good construction practice.

The guy that refuse to do it , gave you a clue to his companies skill level.

FredD

Re: OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

#3

Re: OT - Wood Siding and Vinyl Soffit

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>Sounds like you either get a neat, trim job or a bunch of slapdash application "trimmed" out with caulking.