Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT: Water Heater Woes

Posts

OT: Water Heater Woes

#1

OT: Water Heater Woes

Warren E. White

>I need some help regarding my natural gas water heater. It isn't excessively old, but something new is happening of late.

The water heater is in the garage, and has an insulated blanket around it. When the ambient temperature is high (90 degrees plus)... the result is cold water. It seems to me that the water heater doesn't ask for heat when the ambient temperature surrounding the water heater, or the water itself which runs in the open through my garage gets to the water heater.

When do you know when to just turn the temp up, or when to replace the water heater, or some part in its guts? It works when you turn the temp up, but it is way too hot.

Any thoughts for a confused person whose family has to to take an occasional cold shower?

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#2

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I'd guess that you have a bad gas valve on the heater that sticks when the ambient temperature gets to the right range to cause it. If the heater itself is five or fewer years old, it probably would be worth the investment in a new valve. I doubt there's any other type of service for the existing valve.

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#3

Asking the obvious question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>What is you water heater temp set at? If it is close to 90 then I could agree with the thermostat not working. If it is higher than that then you have a fault, either in the thermostat (or thermal link) itself or the gas valve.

Lee

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#4

Re: Asking the obvious question

Warren E. White

>Let me add a few pieces of information left out of my first post. The water heater was purchased in November 1999, so it is coming up on 9 years old. It has a 12 year warranty.

This has happened once before, and what I did last time was to cycle the thermostat up and down a few times and set it a bit higher than it had been. It is now at the "A" setting which corresponds to 130 degrees.

I see where you are going with this; no setting should be lower than the ambient temperature of the garage. Since it starts the heat when you run the temperature up, it probably isn't the valve. The only way I have seen the thermocouple fail is to shut off the gas, so I would tend to question the thermostat. How does one test that, or is it something that you just replace and see if it fixes the problem. If that is the case, is replacing the thermostat something that a do-it-yourselfer can do? The parts are still under warranty, but I will have to pay for service and then convince the company that the thermostat is at fault.

Thanks for your help thus far.

Warren

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#5

Re: Asking the obvious question

Fred Davis

>Warren,

at eight years old your WH is getting long in the tooth and not near as efficient as it was a few years ago.

Haven't seen a 12 year warranty, but a inside secret on water heaters when they were offered at five or ten year warranty was this.

The only difference between the five year WH warranty and the ten year WH warranty was the label and the price.

So one could see the that opting for the five year warranty with the same identical WH was the way to go.

Of course this doesn't help your current problem, but is good to know if you replace it.

FredD

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#6

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

galen V

>Time for a new water heater as it could be a combination of problems.

You probably have had the insulation blanket on for a long time but they are not always a good idea. If it slides down it can block the air intake and this would shut the burner down. Insulation blanket over the temperature probe and high limit probe can be a problems.

Higher ambient air may help keep the covered high limit probe just hot enough that it provents burner from lighting as it thinks it is up to temp limit. By the time cold water can enter and finally cool probe you cannot recover and it is cold water. The cold water inlet drop tube could be rusted off and as you use water the cold water now entering just at top can push the hot water down to were it can still hold off lighting as high temp probe being heated by water forced down. Warrenty on units not as long as they use to and like noted same unit in some cases you just pay for extended warrenty on unit. Just had a new unit put in and not sure the electronic igniter is going to be any better than old pilot type but saves tiny amount of gas, at higher cost electrical parts. Told me no added jacket to throw off sensors or block air as it has a larger air port at bottom.

Since gas it take city inspector and your plumber so easier to have them handle all. City guy just looked at 2 minutes and left after putting his sticker on.

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

#7

Re: OT: Water Heater Woes

Warren E. White

>My thanks to all who have responded. Regarding the insulation blanket, this one cannot slide down as it is held in place by the strapping (we live in earthquake country). I have a cut out around all of the thermostat and such.

I have increased the thermostat slightly and it seems to be working (for now). I will just replace it when it fails again. It seems to be the thermostat or temperature sensor, but as has been said it is a bit long in the tooth.

Again, thank each of you.

Warren