Depends
Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI
>There are two types of this product I'm familiar with. One looks like a rubber membrane and is shiny on top, although it's not slippery underfoot unless it's wet. The other looks like a thin shingle with some aggregate on the top. Both have adhesives on the underside that are designed to seal up around penetrating fasteners that hold down your finished roofing.
The one with the shiny surface just doesn't come off unless it was placed over funky decking. You'll destroy the plywood trying to scrape it off. The other one can be sort-of scraped off, but it's a real chore. If the roof deck is intact, you can apply a new layer of the shiny type (Grace Co. product) over the existing one as long as you remove old nails and have a clean surface.