Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

broken screw removal help needed

Posts

broken screw removal help needed

#1

broken screw removal help needed

gary s clarke

>What is the best way to remove a broken screw and insert a new one in a wall to hold a railing bracket? thanks.

Re: broken screw removal help needed

#2

Depends, of course

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>What's the wall made of? What's the screw fastened to in the wall? Is the screw broken off below the surface or can you grab it?

If the wall is wood frame with drywall, and the screw's into a stud and broken off below the surface of the drywall, I'd look at the railing bracket to see if there's somewhere to drill another hole in the bracket near the hole with the broken off screw under it, then drive a new screw into the stud. If not, I'd look at whether I could drill an angled hole into the stud (up or down from the existing hole) and drive the screw in that way.

Woodcraft used to, and may still, sell screw removers that are basically pieces of tubing with sawteeth cut on them in the reverse of the usual configuration; there may be others who sell them too. The idea is that pick out one the right size, put this in your electric drill, set it on "backward," then set it over the screw and run the drill. The sawteeth are supposed to catch the screw and wind it out. I bought one, and removed one or two screws, then found the teeth were pretty well wrecked; kind of spendy for the useful life.

If not drywall - if you're going into concrete or masonry of some kind - the problem gets more complex, because drilling angled holes and getting good retention of the screw gets harder (the masonry is more likely to break out if there's an adjacent hole). In this case, the alternate-hole approach is probably best.

If the broken part is sticking out from the wall, it's time to buy yourself Vise Grips. My experience is that the small size (5", I think they list as) are best for this purpose. These have any number of uses, so a worthwhile investment. Do NOT get anything but "Vise Grips." Off-brands are [word not permitted in family forum].

Re: broken screw removal help needed

#3

Re: Depends, of course

gary s clarke

>thank you

Re: broken screw removal help needed

#4

Re: Screw extractor *LINK*

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I've used this Sears product repeatedly to extract screws where the head broke off or the head stripped so a driver wouldn't work.


screw extractor

Re: broken screw removal help needed

#5

Re: Depends, of course

Binen

>I have a set of the screw extractors described. However I use them in a different way. I selected one with an inside diameter larger than the screw and bored out the wood around the screw. Popped it off like a plug. Then filled the hole with a dowel or plug. The ODs of the extractors seem designed to do this since they are a standard size.

Binen