Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Chair joinery question

Posts

Chair joinery question

#1

Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>My MIL sent me a Woodcraft gift card for my birthday. For some reason, they included a copy of the May, 2007 Woodcraft magazine. In it was a construction article for a chair I might like to build, shown below & in the next post. The design is a take off on a minimalist chair done in the '30's.

Not surprisingly I guess, the project centers around an expensive tool Woodcraft "just happens" to carry, the Festool Domino joiner. "Only $800 at a Woodcraft near you... ".

No, the gift card is not sufficient for this purchase ;-(

I'm thinking I might be able to do this with the strength the design requires using an alternate approach, and in particular, using the "Beadlock" jig I bought a couple years back which has pretty much been gathering dust ever since. Anyone have any thoughts on this approach, or other applicable techniques?

TIA

Dan


img

Re: Chair joinery question

#2

Constructon details, etc. 

Dan Mitchell

>


img

Re: Chair joinery question

#3

Re: Chair joinery question

Neal in San Jose

>The Festool joint is simply a floating mortise and tenon so I think I would use a thru M & T or maybe a bridle joint. You could use a non-thru M & T if you didn't want the joinery to distract from the minimalistic lines of the chair. I've not used the beadlock, but it is another floating tenon, and I think any of those joints should be strong enough.

Re: Chair joinery question

#4

JL

Re: Chair joinery question

JL

>What Neal said. I build the majority of my chairs with regular tenon joinery. A floating tenon such as the Beadlock system would work quite well.

You've got to remember - with a correctly sized joint (i.e. not one where the glue is starved (way too tight) or where the glue is trying to bridge a gap) - the wood will typically fail before the glue does.

Re: Chair joinery question

#5

Re: Chair joinery question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Why would anyone want to make it? I looks nothing like the Reitveld original, which itself was an affected attempt to make an "artistic" statement that was a structural failure and of no utility. The pictured example is just plain Ugly, with a capital U, to boot.

Clint

Re: Chair joinery question

#6

Re: Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>Yeah I think the beadlock will work. I'll try a joint mock-up 1st.

Thanks for the replies.

Dan

Re: Chair joinery question

#7

Gee Clint, what do you really think?

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: Chair joinery question

#8

No accounting for taste

Ellils Walentine

>Modernism in general is not my cup of tea, but, there are those who love it. But, aesthetics aside, woodworking magazines publish projects and techniques that are designed to teach skills and widen repertoires. Often the designs are simplified simply to eliminate some aspects of the construction that are beside the point of the article. We found that most people who build projects from our published plans took all kinds of liberties with the design, proportion, materials and joinery anyway.

This is another case where "making do" without an expensive mortiser is a distinct option for anyone who likes the look of this chair. The Beadlock system would actually perform quite well in this case, as would many other forms of mortise and tenon joinery. I've made knee joints similar to these using multiple dowels, through tenons (box joints), thick feathers and homemade loose tenons. If you have a shaper with a finger-jointing cutter, you could probably make that work as well. I'd consider using a non-creeping glue like epoxy for those knees, though.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Chair joinery question

#9

Re: Chair joinery question

paul mayer

>If the idea is that your MIL is implying that you should build it and give it to her, then I would consider using a butt joint for the knees.... :)

Re: Chair joinery question

#10

Re: Chair joinery question

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>I'll venture two probabilities here: (1) whoever originally built the chair didn't use a domino and (2) anyone much over 50 lbs never sat on that chair very often or very long. Furniture like that thrill the designer set, get a magazine cover, and end up in a museum where no one is allowed to sit on it.

Re: Chair joinery question

#11

Re: Chair joinery question

John in New Mexico

>I think if I were to try this chair, I'd make the joints as finger joints, about 3/8" for each finger. Not easy to do with the angles and all, but I'd expect most other joints to fail. I suppose the other thing I might try is cutting a dado in the back of the "leg" parts so I could bend up some 1/2" steel rod and epoxy it in, then let in a strip of wood to cover it. That would probably not fail, though it would be rather difficult to get right!

Re: Chair joinery question

#12

Re: Chair joinery question

McKay

>I use the bead lock and like it a lot, but having used the Domino at the school where I teach, I believe that it is much tighter in tolerance and thus that is what I would use if I were to make the chair. Worth the money? I don't know. The school has purchased about 6 festools. They are nice, but I will stick to my Makita drills and PMS.

Re: Chair joinery question

#13

Re: Chair joinery question *LINK*

DickL

>On your supposition 1, you are correct. David Dundas, from down under in Oz, did not use a Domino on the original chair. On point 2, you are very incorrect. See the video.


Testing the Z Chair

Re: Chair joinery question

#14

Or the lack of it

Dan Mitchell

>I personally like the clean lines of modern design, as well as those of Shaker & to a lesser extent Craftsman styles. To my eye, all of these are an improvement over the obvious, overly ornate, seen-it-a-million-times, tacked on decoration demonstrated in a lot of pieces.

We all see plans & final projects that are not in keeping with our personal esthetic. Fortunately for the continued civility of the discussion however, very few of us are rude enough to make comments which amount to "why would you want to make that piece of crap".

BTW, the article does specify epoxy.

Re: Chair joinery question

#15

Re: Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>"If the idea is that your MIL is implying that you should build it and give it to her, then I would consider using a butt joint for the knees.... :)"

Yeah, it could be my 1st commission!

Actually, Woodcraft threw in the magazine, presumably to promote subscribing.

Re: Chair joinery question

#16

Re: Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>The article does show the Domino in use on the piece, which is also reviewed in the issue.

As to strength, they claim at least 576 #'s:


img

Re: Chair joinery question

#17

Re: Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>Interesting video, I like the rocker version they show at the end. Again though, the magazine article does specifically show the Domino in use.

Thanks for the reply.

dan

Re: Chair joinery question

#18

Re: Chair joinery question

Dan Mitchell

>I don't think anyone would contend Festool doesn't make nice products, but their pricing seems a bit extreme at times ;-)

Thanks for the reply.

Dan

Re: Chair joinery question

#19

I've been incorrect before....

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>but that chair ain't gonna make it....I notice in the picture that the chair is up against a corner and not out in the open of a room and the three guys are against the wall for stability and support...you can build a bridge out of balsa straws if you want but eventually....have someone in that chair and lean back and rock on it a little (as people do)...

Re: Chair joinery question

#20

Re: I've been incorrect before....

charlie belden

>Rocker standing on one of his Z-frames. Looks like a clamp used to hold the sides together. Racking seems to be the weak link, not the Zs.

Another joint that probablyh would work is a sliding dovetail. Easy enough to do if you use a router table, a micro adjustable fence and don't change the dovetail bit's depth of cut. Gives you lots of glue surface area and mechanical strength even without glue.

Nakashima's Conoid Chair is another non-traditional chair design.

charlie belden


img

Re: Chair joinery question

#21

Re: I've been incorrect before....

Dan Mitchell

>Roger - The image I posted isn't the best, in the magazine it's more apparent that the 3 men are being supported solely by the chair; they're not leaning against anything but each other for balance. Check out the youtube video DickL posted in this thread. I agree, the design seems to defy prudent engineering, which is part of its appeal. I also agree that if person of sufficient girth plopped down in it & proceeded to lean back, rock on the rear of the feet, etc., it may still fail.

The article suggests a set of these chairs at a dining table. In my case, I would make just one as an "occasional piece", mostly for decoration.

Thanks for the reply.

Dan

Re: Chair joinery question

#23

Re: I've been incorrect before....

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>Dan...your image appeared to me to have shadows from the three guys and that is what lead me to believe that they where up against a wall...I could be wrong about that also...but thats what my impression was...I'm sure you know that the stresses imposed on a joint can be a large multiple of a persons weight when someone moves about quickly, bounces up and down, rocks back, etc, etc and this design essentially has a built in lever that acts against the integrity of the joint IMHO...but to get back to your original question, I would go with a floating tenon...also, by the way, I believe that if you are intrigued by this design, that you should definitely build it and maybe do some experimenting with it along the way because a real part of this woodworking thing is to explore your own ideas, interests, and solutions...ie: creative freedom...have at it, Dan...nothing ventured, nothing gained etc etc.

Re: Chair joinery question

#24

Re: Chair joinery question

janderr

>at 250 lbs i would love to test any joinery system for this design as my desk chair. My bet is it wouldn't last the year's end.

Re: Chair joinery question

#25

Re: Chair joinery question

Tony - Memphis

>Dan, I hope you try this and let us know how it goes. I'm very interested to hear/see how it works out. Aesthetically, its not my cup of tea, but from an engineering/woodworking perspective, its very cool. My taste is mostly in the 18th century stuff and when I look at what they did with cabriole legs, it scares me. I see pieces all the time with legs that look like they wouldn't support much yet they are supporting a pretty heavy cabinet. I really like pieces that look like they ought not to work. Gets people's attention. I've seen that design recently. Is it in a chair book I have maybe? Can't remember the guys name, but his chair book is pretty popular. Come to think of it, my wife is kind of artsy and she has a chair from long ago (70's or 80's) that is round, but has a similar design. I'll have to check that out. I think it is still in the attic.

Tony