Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

electric chain saws

Posts

electric chain saws

#1

electric chain saws

Jerry Gibbs

>neighbor wants electric chain saw because he can't pull start gas. max log would be 12". any advice on power and size? also comments on electric chain saws in general. Jerry Gibbs

Re: electric chain saws

#2

Re: electric chain saws

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Remington makes one that is a pretty good piece of equipment. It sells for around $80. It is great for smaller stuff, however 12" would probably tax it somewhat. I'm not sure any of the electrics can handle that big routinely.

John

Re: electric chain saws

#3

Re: electric chain saws

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Jerry,

I have a little Remington which I use for bowl blanks. Electrical items are whimpy as compared with their gas counterparts. However, they get the job done slowly, and the price ius right.

George

Re: electric chain saws

#4

Re: electric chain saws

paul in AZ

>I have borrowed one that I think is a Remington a couple of times.

No comparison to the gas saw I used to use back east to cut oak and maple firewood.

That said, with a well sharpened chain I have whacked trees almost a foot in diam. That wood was relatively soft ficus natida and on one occasion helped the saw's owner cut down a considerably harder olive 8 or 9 inches across. Cutting something really hard like mesquite should be possible but the max. I've cut is about 4 inches. I'd guess that you could easily cut hardwood up to half or 3/4 of the length of the bar.

It just takes longer than a gas saw. the keys are a very sharp chain and a little patience.

Re: electric chain saws

#5

Re: electric chain saws

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>If your neighbor cannot pull a gas chainsaw I am concerned that he will have a problem with a kickback if he encounters that situation. If he is used to setting logs to cut and knows how to avoid kickback then a sharp electric is the way to go.

Re: electric chain saws

#6

Re: electric chain saws *LINK*

Curly Smith

>The link should take you to website for a dealer near me with prices, prices in other locations may vary (go to http://www.stihlusa.com for dealers near you). Electric chainsaws are more dangerous than the average chainsaw because they are "instant on" when you pull the trigger. There is no "revving up" as with a gas chainsaw.

The MSE 220 has been around for a long time, gets good reviews, and it's a steal at $530. I don't know anything about the other 2 less expensive, but still pricey, models.


Stihl Electric Chainsaws

Re: electric chain saws

#7

Re: electric chain saws *LINK*

Wade

>Jerry, have your friend take a look at the line of Stihl electric chain saws. I am an avid firewood and bike trail maintenance chain saw user with saws from 50cc's to 88cc's, but I must admit, I was pleasently surprised at the Stihl pro electric model MSE 220. The weight is 11 pounds, double of what most electric chanin saws are, 15 amp motor and it handles bar sizes of 16, 18 and 20 inches. They also offer MSE 140 and 180 saws that are smaller, lighter and less power, but still a significant step up from the typical electric chain saws.

No affiliation to Stihl, just love to make saw dust and firewood with their saws.

Wade


http://www.stihlusa.com/chainsaws/electric.html

Re: electric chain saws

#8

Name brand or junk?

Tom Dunlap

>The Remington will work...for a while. Then it will die and become more junk in the landill or hopefully the metal will be recyled.

Stihl, Husky, Makita and Milwaukee all make good electric saws. They are up built to the same standards as the rest of the tools. Not down to a pricepoint.

Make sure that whatever saw is purchased has a chain brake. If not, don't buy it. Electric saws will cut right through the ballistic chainsaw clothing that is required for pro chainsaw use. Electric saws have much more torque but lower chain speed. This lulls people into thinking that they're 'safer'. In some ways they are.

The formula that I use for sizing a chainsaw is to find out how long a bar it will take compared to the density of the wood I expect to cut. Frozen, dense, dead hardwood will cut like rock. Thawed, soft, live softwood will cut like butter. Then, I look at the diameter wood I expect to cut with a particular bar. The saw I have will take a bar that is 20% longer than the wood I expect to cut 80% of the time. In other words, I overpower by 80%.

If your friend wants to cut 12" diameter logs they would be looking at a saw that will take about a fifteen inch bar. I don't think that is possible with electric. If you do find that combo I think that you'll be expecting way more of the saw than it will deliver. You can expect a shorter life because of overheating the motor. It will cut though...that's the advanatage of electric. A gas saw will bog down when you try to force the cut.

Buy a proper helmet, face screen, safety glasses and hearing protection too. Even though the electric is quieter it still is loud. Besides, having on the PPE may remind the user that this tool is not a casual use tool.

Chainsaws have been called one of the most constructive and destructive tools than humans have ever made.

Tom

Re: electric chain saws

#9

Great post, Tom

Ellils Walentine

>... and I second the safety advice. Way back in 1970, a friend and I were ripping barn beams to install in the living room ceiling of a new house we were building. My pal was using an electric chainsaw, a Sears IIRC, without a chain brake. When he hit a nail, the saw kicked back so fast that it cut his nose nearly in half and sliced through one of his eyebrows. Needless to say, it took a trip to the emergency room and several months of recuperation for him to recover from that little incident.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: electric chain saws

#10

Re: electric chain saws

Barry Irby

>Great Advice so far, especially on all the safety stuff. Do It.

I have had two electric saws. A Remington from Lowes. Piece of crap. Cut OK for things like bowl blanks and it was good to be able to run it in doors in the shop. Tried to cut a log and it snapped closed on me and pinched the chain. Turns out the saw has a metal gear running inside a much larger plastic gear. Stripped the teeth. They replaced the saw under warranty (90 days?). The second one gave up the ghost in a few months. Can't remember exactly, but I tried replacing parts but it was just to much effort to keep replacing the crappy plastic gear.

Went to Sears and bought a Craftsman (yes a Crapsman) to get the extended warranty. Paid for two years. ($12) Saw lasted about four years. I treated it poorly and beat the crap out of it. They had assured me that if it broke under the warranty they would just hand me a new one. I really tried to activate that warranty. I finally abused it to the point the shaft stripped out of the main gear. The gear was MUCH more substantial than the first saw, even though they were both made by Remington. Warranty was long gone. Bought parts for about thirty bucks and put it back together and its still going. Could of gotten by for about twenty bucks but I replaced everything that appeared worn. Its chugging right along.

It was about $100 at Sears including the warranty. I am not a fan of Sears and generally don't darken their doors, but I have no complaint about this. When sharp the saw cuts better than I would have thought. 16" bar.

Not a Stihl, but not $500 either.

Re: electric chain saws

#11

I have a Sears...and Husky...and Stihl

Tom Dunlap

>The Sears is electric, the others gas.

I got the Sears at a garage sale for no more than $20. It isn't often that I use it though. One time it was 2am and Iwas in my home shop working. I needed to cut down some lumber and a rough cut was fine. I know that the gas saws would have been too loud...hehehehe...so the electric came out.